Recent content by Duke Soddy

  1. D

    Best Dogfighter Poll Revisited...

    The Dora was a beast to deal with between 15-20000 ft, but above that it was a pig, very sluggish at the controls. Hense the reason Kurt Tank considered the Dora and iterim fighter aircraft while he implimented his masterpiece the Ta-152. The only way you could possible consider the P-51 a...
  2. D

    Best Piston Engined Fighter Ever...

    Phenomally fast aircraft, nimble as an I-16... at altitude. below 20000 though she was a pig. At low altitude the wings that make it so nimble at altitude make it hard to reach 350 down low. It had absolutely no ablility to carry ordinance, and that is half of most operational fighters duties...
  3. D

    P-47N Thunderbolt vs. F4U-4 Corsair - Which was superior?

    What your missing is ... Figures don't lie, but liars do figure.
  4. D

    P-47N Thunderbolt vs. F4U-4 Corsair - Which was superior?

    This is such a tough one, I like both of the aircraft. Objectively they both have reputations as rugged and durable aircraft, but the jug edges out the corsair in that arena. The Corsair would edge the Jug out in wing loading and everywhere else except in range. Give any combination of variables...
  5. D

    Best radial fighter of '42

    At low altitude in fighter vs. fighter I will take the La-5, at medium altitude I will take the Fw-190 . The Tojo is a great climber but about 40 knots slower. Speed always trumps angles.
  6. D

    Best Bomber Killing Aircraft......

    The Dora really never had a chance, when it arrived they could never send it up in force, they went up against P-51s and Mk XIVs at odds of 4 and 5 to one Dora. I don't think the dora killed too many bombers.
  7. D

    Best Bomber Killing Aircraft......

    this can be measured in many a different way. #1 number of bombers brought down by any given aircraft #2 Kill/Death ratio fighter vs. bomber of any given fighter #3 A fighters impact on bomber formations when it [I]first[I]appeared in theatre/war #4 a matter of personal opinion My...
  8. D

    Best Russian Fighter

    You could counter that argument with the Boing P-26 Peashooter as the worlds first modern fighter. You wll argue the Boings lack of retractable landing gear, but the Boing had alot of firsts.
Back