Recent content by GregP

  1. GregP

    P-61 Performance

    According to modern pilots who have flown the Mosquito, it is a very neat airpalne, but will never be mistaken for a fighter by anyone flying it. ANY single-engine fighter will out-turn it and most are faster. The real problem for defense against a Mosquito was high cruise speed. If you weren't...
  2. GregP

    Was the Norden bombsight really that crap?

    The Norden bombsight was about as good a sight as you could get with optical lens technology. The trick wasn't to get the bomb to hit the target as much as it was to account for winds aloft from 30,000 feet. Without knowing the winds, it's like shooting a rifle with a loose bore ... all over the...
  3. GregP

    WW2: Why was the 9th Air Force given P51 ins6tead of giving them to the 8th Air Force in 1943?

    The first Merlin model with removable heads was the Merlin C, 21 Dec 1935 in a Hawker Horsley ... unless I am mistaken? My Excel file says it had separate ramp heads and crankcase as well as cylinder skirts.
  4. GregP

    highest kill ratio

    Have to agree that general statements don't get it. Numbers with referencers are MUCH better. Summaries of actual combat reports are good. I, too, have spoken with WWII and Korean War combat veteran pilots. According to them, the claims were almost universally, but not exactly always, made in...
  5. GregP

    highest kill ratio

    I've made these arguments many times in here and they fall on people convinced that loss data are somehow WAY more accurate than victory claim data. Since both types of data are taken down on paper (this is WWII, recall), data can be lost, can become unreadable due to water damage, and can...
  6. GregP

    WWII Rate of Turns

    I see yimes above, but no altitudes, airsp[eeds, or references. It's like saying a football score as KC CHiefs, 21, and nothing else. The times very considerably with altitude and airspeed.
  7. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    Any particular titles, GrauGeist? I'm definitely interested.
  8. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    There is also a tendency to understate combat losses. If a fighter (or other aircraft) sustains damage in combat, but starts to head home, and later something happens that causes it to force-land, it was usually carried as an Operational Loss instead of cumulative damage due to combat. Happened...
  9. GregP

    WW2: Why was the 9th Air Force given P51 ins6tead of giving them to the 8th Air Force in 1943?

    The 9th AF got P-51s instead of the 8th AF beause General Henry "Hap" Arnold decided that was the way way to go, and HE was in command. There was nobody that could be "appealed to" or persuaded differently. In the Military, orders are issued and followed. Any debate happens BEFORE the order...
  10. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    You do what you want to do, and do it in good health. The U.S.A. put a lot of effort into data after WWII, and those data are not anywhere NEAR easy to find answers from. I've been working on it for 40+ years. I have many answers, but not all, by long shot. I enumerated many concerns above. No...
  11. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    Not saying ANY records are completely inaccurate. I'm saying they are not anywhere near exact. I think all the records we can find thah are primary sourcers are either correct or close to correct. But we have no way to know if they are complete. Suppose, for the sake of argument, we actually...
  12. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    Once again, we'll have to agree to disagree, but not with any disdain or sarcasm, really. "Carful research" indicates the records you are researching are accurate. My entire point above is they are generally only semi-accurate, not accurate. I've worked in paper systems in the past and it was...
  13. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    There is an old saying about shooting/hanging/killing the messenger. In the USSR, Stalin was known to kill people who annoyed him, never mind people who told him he was losing a lot of ariplanes and troops to the Germans whenhe wanted to win. The Commisars weren't highly motivated to send in...
  14. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    Thanks for the Chatgpt info. Will have to try it. Only informational and not a disagreement, but what makes you think loss reports are any more accurate than claims? In many cases, they aren't even sure how many of some aircraft were built, accepted. and deployed (all separate numbers) much...
  15. GregP

    Japanese Versus American Victory Claims

    So much about aviation is covered incorrectly in the media that AI tends to retrieve the incorrect stuff as gospel. I've spent a lifetime around aircraft / aviation. Hardly any media civerage about aviation is anywhere near true. Quite a few of the books used as references by AI are nothing more...
Back