I guess it depends on who I have to turn and burn with.
Obviously most allied fighters could boom and zoom vs the Japanese aircraft, history proves that. If I wanted something to TRY and turn and burn with the Japanese fighters, it would have to be a Spitfire. I think with any of the top U.S. fighters, turn and burn would not be a good idea.
Europe, I would feel good in a P-38J/L, P-51, or a F4U Corsair.