Speed Discrepancy between Ki-43-II and A6M3/A6M5

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

Laurelix

Senior Airman
304
211
Jun 13, 2016
ソース(Source) 「キ43飛行性能表」『飛行第59戦隊整備関係資料』防衛研究所蔵
(Library of National Institute for Defense Studies)
"Ki43 flight performance table" from "Maintanance documents relating
to 59th FR"
登録番号(registration number) 陸空-濠北方面-84

高度 最高速度 上昇力
(Alt.) (Max. speed) (Clim. speed)
1000m 463km/h 1'13"
2000m 481km/h 2'25"
3000m 498km/h 3'30"
3340m 504km/h
4000m 504km/h 4'35"
4800m 500km/h(supercharger switching altitude)
5000m 503km/h 5'49"
6000m 515km/h 7'24"
6080m 515km/h
7000m 514km/h 9'12"
8000m 508km/h 11'09"
9000m 497km/h 13'36"
10000m 478km/h 17'20"

------------

Based on these figures we can estimate the SL max speed is roughly 445km/h at Military Power and 515km/h at 6000m
Now... the A6M3 features the same Sakae 21 / Ha-115 engine....

According to TAIC...
A6M3 Hamp has 457km/h at SL with WEP which is with 1130 Horsepower, this corresponds to 440km/h at SL at military power with 1010 Horsepower. A6M3 Hamp is given 557km/h max speed at optimal altitude with WEP.

The issue here is... Ki-43-II is supposedly faster at SL with 445kph at military power which would correspond to 562km/h max speed with WEP at optimal altitude. However the japanese source only lists 515km/h at 6000m at military power and at best youre getting 530-532km/h with WEP with that Military Power figure.

The issue is that with 515km/h at 6000m at military power, with the Ha-115 power curve i would expect only 420km/h at Sea Level, but then there would be the issue of it being slower than Ki-43-I at Sea Level despite having bigger wings (more drag) and weaker engine. So either 515km/h is just wrong... or the Ki-43-II critical max altitude ended up being a lot lower than that of the A6M's despite using the same engine.

-------------

1736253636842.png


According to JICPOA
A6M3 Mod 22 has
520km/h (281knots) at 3250m
541km/h (292knots) at ~6000m at military power
Based on Power Curve the Sea Level Speed is somewhere between 445-452kph at military power.
Ki-43-II is listed at basically 445 at SL as well but its optimal alt speed is a lot lower.


Ki-43-II supposedly has
504km/h at 3250m
515km/h at 6000m at ~6000m
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back