The best German Wehrmacht commanders
- Thread starter bob44
- Start date
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
That's a pretty broad question, actually...
Are you looking for overall best commander, or a commander of Armor, infantry, artillery...or one who made the best tactical gains with least loss of manpower, etc.?
Are you looking for overall best commander, or a commander of Armor, infantry, artillery...or one who made the best tactical gains with least loss of manpower, etc.?
meatloaf109
1st Lieutenant
Von Manstein, Guderian, Rommel...
davebender
1st Lieutenant
The Heer had so many good officers during both world wars you could pick at random and get a good one.
For the sake of argument let me nominate Hans von Luck. He fought well through the entire war but Operation Goodwood may have been his finest hour. His Kampfgruppe was key to defeating the largest British armored attack of WWII.
For the sake of argument let me nominate Hans von Luck. He fought well through the entire war but Operation Goodwood may have been his finest hour. His Kampfgruppe was key to defeating the largest British armored attack of WWII.
- Thread starter
- #6
DonL
Banned
von Manstein and Guderian are both on strategic and tactical level first rade generals.
Rommel was better on a tactical level but had also strenghts at the strategic level.
General Heinrici was the Master of Defence he commanded the 4th Army after von Kluge was commander of the Heeresgruppe Mitte and faught the Battle of the Seelower Höhen at April 1945 (which third to fourth class troups) at which the Red Army took such heavy losses that Schukow must regroup and he could hold his frontline for 4 Days against a whole Red Army Front (33 Schützen Divisionen 4 Panzer Korps and 4 Artillerie Divisions).
General Nehring the first commander of the Tunis frontline, a Master of improvisation and a very good all allround General (commander of the 18th Panzer Division at the East).
Faught the famous counterattack against Suchinitschi (Winter 1941)with one boosted Panzer Division against 30 Red Army Schützen Divisions and he could get in contact with the enclosed Wehrmachts troups and could reinforce them.
There are many other very good german commanders on the tactical level too much to name them all.
Last edited:
- Thread starter
- #8
GrauGeist
Generalfeldmarschall zur Luftschiff Abteilung
Rommel was in charge of the Normandy sector before and during D-Day but again, his power was limited by Berlin's edicts...
He had the manpower and armor to seriously blunt the Allies inward push, but because of lack of communication and co-ordination, it was 6 critical hours before the first armored unit moved up.
He had the manpower and armor to seriously blunt the Allies inward push, but because of lack of communication and co-ordination, it was 6 critical hours before the first armored unit moved up.
meatloaf109
1st Lieutenant
"The" best is a tough one. If they had been give the latitude to conduct war as they saw fit, I sometimes wonder how long the war would have lasted.
Njaco
The Pop-Tart Whisperer
stug3
Staff Sergeant
It didnt help that he was in Germany on June 6, either.
North Africa, 1941
During advances Rommel was determined to stay as mobile as possible and kept up with his forward troops.
Here's a couple more "who was that guy" names.
Hermann Balck. His exploits along the Chir River, blunting the Red Army's exploitation phase during Uranus with a single depleted panzer Division (11th) and a number of ad hoc Kampfgruppen under command, are nothing short of amazing.
Hasso von Manteufel. First given Divisional command in Tunisia (an ad hoc formation bearing his name), it was he who made most of the brilliant tactical decisions often ascribed to Nehring. He was a "lead from the front" tactician and worked himself to mental exhaustion during the chaos of the Tunisian fiasco.
Following recovery, he was given command of 7 Pz. and played a major role during the defensive battles in the Ukraine following the failed Kursk offensive. When 7th Panzer was fought out and pulled off the line, he was given command of the Grossdeutschland Division, and thrown right back into the defensive fighting in the East. He is notable for consistently inflicting punishing casualty rates upon attacking Red Army units through skillful use of maneuver and schwerpunkt counterattacks. He exacted a large toll for every withdrawl he made. There are far too many Divisional commanders to rate them all, but these are two that really stand out from the pack, IMO.
A nod to Steve (Stona) and his nomination of Richthofen. As subordinates, Fiebig and Pflugbeil(?) contributed much to his legend as well. The period covered by Hayward (Stopped at Stalingrad) is illustrative.
Hermann Balck. His exploits along the Chir River, blunting the Red Army's exploitation phase during Uranus with a single depleted panzer Division (11th) and a number of ad hoc Kampfgruppen under command, are nothing short of amazing.
Hasso von Manteufel. First given Divisional command in Tunisia (an ad hoc formation bearing his name), it was he who made most of the brilliant tactical decisions often ascribed to Nehring. He was a "lead from the front" tactician and worked himself to mental exhaustion during the chaos of the Tunisian fiasco.
Following recovery, he was given command of 7 Pz. and played a major role during the defensive battles in the Ukraine following the failed Kursk offensive. When 7th Panzer was fought out and pulled off the line, he was given command of the Grossdeutschland Division, and thrown right back into the defensive fighting in the East. He is notable for consistently inflicting punishing casualty rates upon attacking Red Army units through skillful use of maneuver and schwerpunkt counterattacks. He exacted a large toll for every withdrawl he made. There are far too many Divisional commanders to rate them all, but these are two that really stand out from the pack, IMO.
A nod to Steve (Stona) and his nomination of Richthofen. As subordinates, Fiebig and Pflugbeil(?) contributed much to his legend as well. The period covered by Hayward (Stopped at Stalingrad) is illustrative.
I think I'd just finished Hayward's book when I made that post.......highly recommended.
Steve
