A host of questions not deserving of their own individual posts. (1 Viewer)

70
19
Joined
Nov 26, 2025
A.H.H here. Those here who prefer answering questions to reading investigations are in luck this time.
As I work toward designing a hypothetical WW2 aircraft of my own, I have come up with a series of engine questions on which there is either conflicting evidence or insufficient discussion available.
For the sake of readability, I ask that respondents number the question they are responding to as I have done while asking them.
Thanks in advance, I will waste no more words on prelude.

1: Why did turbochargers of WW2 seem not to make use of the velocity of the exhaust gas? The images and schematics I have seen universally depict the turbine as being a single-stage axial type, with the exhaust not being encouraged in any particular direction of rotation as it entered the housing. This suggests to me that it is only the pressure difference that is being capitalized upon, rather than the flow rate. This is in stark contrast to turbochargers of today, which (excluding some axial types used on generator engines) seem to be almost a mirror-image of their impellor counterparts. Was there some metallurgical obstacle to this at the time? Additionally, I would think that even if a purely axial turbine is being used, there would be benefit to a consistent direction of gas rotation - both to reduce turbulent losses and to extract more energy out of the exhaust.

2: What is the performance limit of a single-stage supercharger using a variable-speed drive? Essentially, what becomes the limiting factor of performance/efficiency/ceiling if the impellor can be made to rotate at any desired speed? The texts I have found that claim to depict this are never in a language that I speak, unfortunately.

3: What differentiates a two-speed supercharger from a two-stage supercharger in terms of performance/efficiency/ceiling? Is one system downright superior to the other given the same level of design?

4: All other things being equal, what is the ideal location and method for the introduction of fuel? Carburetion, single-point injection, or individual injection into the air intake, compressor eye, intake manifold, port, or direct injection are all candidates that come to mind. Similarly, to what extent do the claimed benefits of these systems exist only as a consolation prize for an imperfectly designed engine? For example, is the reduced charge heating when fuel is injected in the compressor eye a benefit unobtainable by direct injection, or just a bonus that helps even the odds?

5: What is the ideal radiator type, all things considered? The Meredith effect is a wonderful thing, but if it mandates that the radiator be a good distance away from the engine there is then a penalty of weight, complexity, and fragility that results from the need to plumb the plane. The leading-edge system of the mosquito, as well as the annular system favoured by Germany, both come to mind. Annoyingly, the rationales of the people who designed these planes are not as available as I would like. If anyone has such information, I would be most grateful.

6: Was there ever any need for cooling air to be allowed into the engine compartment of a liquid-cooled engine, or was all cooling the job of the designated radiator? I would think the nuisance of water/glycol/oil cooling minute components that only barely need cooling at all to be a source of needless complexity.

7: If the mechanism was present, would there be any advantage to be gained by setting up an engine-driven compressor to also be half of a turbocharger installation? Would this allow for a degree of power recovery from the turbine when simply using it to further compress the charge is unnecessary, dangerous, or impossible?

8: To what degree did engine and airframe designers conspire when their products were being designed at the same time? Surely service, installation, and compactness could be substantially improved if there was any amount of cooperation happening.

9: For a firm the size of Rolls-Royce (for example), what is the approximate latest time an engine could have been first conceived of while still having it be "king of the hill" during the war? Obviously the later the basic outline is produced the better, as the fundamental groundwork of the engine would be more modern (and thus have a higher performance potential) but too late and you run the risk of not allowing the design to mature enough. For the sake of this thought experiment, assume that the company in question is not propping up the entire aerial military at the time, and thus can afford not to have an engine in full production for a few years. (Unlike Rolls-Royce....)

10: What fuel additives could have been helpful during the war that were not, besides those that were simply far too advanced for the time?

Explanatory images available upon request.
I may make a habit of creating these community Q&A posts.
 
Re 6. Most installations, air and liquid cooled, have cooling systems for generators/alternators and often for some other components. Air compressors, when fitted usually had a cooling system. These are often not visible as they are often fed from the engine or cooling air ducting.

I will try and add some diagrams/photos later.
 
Here is IMO until the people with real knowledge chime in:

2: What is the performance limit of a single-stage supercharger using a variable-speed drive? Essentially, what becomes the limiting factor of performance/efficiency/ceiling if the impellor can be made to rotate at any desired speed? The texts I have found that claim to depict this are never in a language that I speak, unfortunately.

We can probably take a look just at the highest setting, ie. the drive offering the highest designed/engineered tip speed o the impeller; the difference between the 1-speed and variable-speed drive is basically zero there. The highest value that I know is for the auxiliary supercharger on the V-1710 G6 engine (used on the P-82s), with 1376.16 fps if my math is correct (used 3200 rpm, max gear ratio of 8.087:1, impeller diameter 12.1875 in; all data from 'Vee's for victory'). The post-war R-2800s, like the E series -30 used on the F8F-2, was probably also using the variable speed drive (again, corrections welcome); FWIW, 2800 rpm at the max gear ratio of 10.55:1.
The last DB engines, like the 605D and 603E were also using high impeller speeds, although I don't have all data.

Making impellers turn at any desired speed will not work, there is the upper limit to that. Even the people at DB became aware of that, and were starting to make the 2-stage superchargers in order to improve the (very) high altitude power of their engines - the difference at 10 km was about 350 HP, the DB 605L (2-stage S/C) vs. DB 605D (1-stage S/C).

3: What differentiates a two-speed supercharger from a two-stage supercharger in terms of performance/efficiency/ceiling? Is one system downright superior to the other given the same level of design?

Two-stage supercharger has two stages of compression (to nobody's surprise). That means the two superchargers are working in series, the 1st stage using bigger impellers than the 2nd stage; stages are counted as the incoming air is encountering them. Two stage supercharging was making the pressure ratios of 5:1 to 6:1 feasible while still being above 70% efficiency, meaning that the engine can process much more of the air in order to make better power. The best 1-stage superchargers were good for 3.5:1 pressure ratios at or above 70% efficiency, limiting the engine power at high altitudes.
When people say 'two speed supercharger', that usually denotes a 1-stage supercharger. Several engines were powered by the variable-speed 2-stage superchargers, or the 2-speed 2-stage superchargers, while the Jumo 213E and F were with 3-speed 2-stage superchargers.

A 'special' kind of 2-stage supercharging was used on some US aircraft, like the P-47s, P-38s, and on the heavy bombers. Here the turbosupercharger played the role of the 1st stage of compression, and the engine-stage supercharger played the role of the 2nd stage.

A 2-stage S/C will be downright superior to a 1-stage S/C, unless the design team of the 2-stage S/C does not botch up their work.

4: All other things being equal, what is the ideal location and method for the introduction of fuel? Carburetion, single-point injection, or individual injection into the air intake, compressor eye, intake manifold, port, or direct injection are all candidates that come to mind. Similarly, to what extent do the claimed benefits of these systems exist only as a consolation prize for an imperfectly designed engine? For example, is the reduced charge heating when fuel is injected in the compressor eye a benefit unobtainable by direct injection, or just a bonus that helps even the odds?

From what I've read, the direct fuel injection is superior. It allows the increase of the valve overlap, and big overlap can up the power by 10% just by itself. Note that some engines moved from carburetor to fuel injection, while nobody reverted back to carburetor. The direct fuel injection also gives better mileage, again by some 10%.
Carb icing is not a thing on a fuel-injected engine. There is no need for choke and other things that mess with the air flow in the injected engine.
For a more professional take, see this video (never mind the catchy title): link

5: What is the ideal radiator type, all things considered? The Meredith effect is a wonderful thing, but if it mandates that the radiator be a good distance away from the engine there is then a penalty of weight, complexity, and fragility that results from the need to plumb the plane. The leading-edge system of the mosquito, as well as the annular system favoured by Germany, both come to mind. Annoyingly, the rationales of the people who designed these planes are not as available as I would like. If anyone has such information, I would be most grateful.

Let's not mix up the radiator types with radiator layout and with radiator placement.
Most of the people knew, by late 1930s, the benefits of the Meredith 'system' (roughly, the narrow inlet, wide radiator, then again the narrowing outlet; the improvement being the good controlability of the outlet for different flight & power regimes). How they executed it varied widely. One can have the Meredith 'system' achieved even with an annular radiator, or with the leading-edge placement.
Even the most praised aircraft - Mustang - changed the radiator layout layout perhaps 4 times until the P-51H?
A lot depends on when the radiator is designed-in - during the 'paper stage', or perhaps as a way to up-engine the aircraft? Spitfire was not supposed to have the classic radiators at all, and the raditors and the associated drag kept climbing with each engine upgrade. Bf 109 started out with single radiator for the small engine, and it was a small aircraft to begin with; it was never praised for the radiators, even if we might agree that these did their job well, despite the German radiator tech leaving a lot to be desired (less sturdy than the British designs; forced to use aluminium instead of copper alloys).

For my money, the Mustang set-up, at least when the P-51B emerged, was one of the best on a fighter. The annular radiators seem to be a good thing on the grounds of simplicity of the whole powerplant installation; being compact is also a plus.

This topic might be worthy of it's own thread, IMO.

7: If the mechanism was present, would there be any advantage to be gained by setting up an engine-driven compressor to also be half of a turbocharger installation?

The turbo-compound engines were a thing post-war, even if the power recovered by the turbine was used by the engine directly.
There was also a thing of the turbo being the only means of supercharging, IOW the engine-stage supercharger was not there. That left a good deal of engine power to the engine itself, and was tested on the inter-war Lockheed P-30, it was mooted for the Ford's V-1650 engine (the S/C was with two stages on same shaft together with the turbine), and on the last R-4360s (4300 HP was hoped for, vs. 3500 on the engines with the engine-stage S/C).
It is used today on many engines in the cars, from Fiats to Porsches.
 
10: What fuel additives could have been helpful during the war that were not, besides those that were simply far too advanced for the time?
A simple thing would've been the ethanol. It was known to work (it increases the octane/performance rating of the fuel), especially in the USA, but was buried by the companies wanting to sell TEL. Avoids a lot of health issues that were connected to lead (as metal, not position), the lead is not gathering at the spark plugs, cylinders run cooler, can use high compression ratios (tackles the sole problem of ethanol: the worse mileage than what gasoline was offering)...
The today's equivalent of the E85 would've been very intersting on an engine designed to run with it in the 1930s/40s.
 
Thanks for your two cents, Tomo.
I have a couple follow-up/clarification questions.

3: Are the individual compressor inefficiencies not multiplied in a two-stage system? I was under the impression that two-stage supercharging was used to reach boost levels not feasible in a single-stage system due to compressor speed limitations, and that single-stage supercharging would always give the best efficiency. I suppose I have neglected that larger single superchargers could have inferior friction/heating/parasitic loss characteristics.

What property of turbocharging necessitates that a mechanical supercharger also be present? Is it by chance that all turbocharged aircraft I know of also have an engine-driven compressor? What incentivises the turbocharger-first ordering of these systems?

Is the two-stage single-speed system better than a one-stage two-speed system? (I may not have been clear about my wording the first time)

5: I suppose I was misleading here as well. I understand that most, if not all radiator systems attempted to use the Meredith effect, but installations like that of the mosquito limited the ability of the exhaust thrust to contribute to propelling the plane. Was the advantage of the inlet being in an exceptionally high-pressure zone able to overcome this drawback? Similarly, does the annular system have any notable advantage over the "simple" Meredith duct system of the mustang?

Good idea about making a separate thread for this. Expect that later tonight, possibly.

7: Well, this answers my question about turbocharger-only aircraft! I would be interested in seeing under what conditions the turbocharger provided horsepower to the crankshaft, and vice versa.

10: Interesting, I had heard of ethanol but figured it must have been a more recent advancement in the world of engines. What prevented the adoption of ethanol in other countries, or was the "lead lobby" in full force worldwide? Another agent I have come across (in "The Secret Horsepower Race", of course) is methylaniline, used by Germany. How do these two octane boosters compare?
 
1. It may not be worth the complication.
US turbos "worked" at different altitudes and different speeds. By Speed I mean the rpm of the turbo.
Turbo the P-38J could be turning at 8,000rpm or less at low altitude at full power, at 26,000ft the turbo was spinning at 26,400rpm.
Turbo was working at cruise even with the engine making 400-750hp. A lot less exhaust flow (mass) even if the velocity wasn't much different.
Turbo's often made more power than was needed as is. This varied with time, engine used on and desired pressure. GE made two different size turbos. The "B" series used on the Allison, the P&W R-1830 and the Wright R-1820. As time went on GE changed turbine materials to allow for higher temperatures and higher RPM, Early P-38s were limited to around 18,000rpm.
Trying to optimize the exhaust gas flow though the turbine housing for different conditions may not have been worth it in terms of engineering difficulty and/or manufacturing difficulty.

7. we are getting into violating the KISS principle. Keep It Simple Stupid. The more you complicate things, the more things can wrong, sometimes exponentially.
Turbine is making a certain amount of power (at a given amount of exhaust mass and pressure/velocity). trying to send it to two different places is possible. Trying to do that at different power levels means you need some sort of variable drive to at least one output shaft. It may require a variable drive that changes the torque and not just rpm. The Turbo compound engines after WW II did not use the turbine/s to power the superchargers, they were power recovery turbines that just added power to the crankshaft and thus to the propeller.

10. A lot depends on what you are trying to do. Ethanol works but it has less BTUs per pound. You actually get less milage with ethanol blend fuels for the same weight of fuel. Beats having no fuel though. There may be water problems, one reason that they don't try to use more than 15% in ground vehicles. Long term storage can be a problem. This was a problem with some of the anti-knock compounds like benzine. Less BTUs per pound but not as bad as ethanol. If you want 18,700 BTUs per pound you can't use over 20% aromatics, If you can get by with less BTUs per pound you have more options
Everything has trade offs and some of the "stuff" they played with WW II had some real problems. Some of it makes lead from gasoline look mild, some of it was very expensive.
Toluene is a pretty decent fuel additive except in war time they want most of it for explosives, it is the 3rd T in TNT.
 
1: Interesting. Another possible reason your explanation makes me thing of is that the amount of energy returned from the turbine may already be nicely aligned with the amount of energy that the compressor ought to receive, so not harnessing the velocity of the exhaust could possibly make the whole turbine-compressor relationship simpler. (a sorely needed quality, with or without a unified engine management system)

7. Admittedly, this is the response I was expecting. I hope that in practice this sort of arrangement could be neatly tacked-on to a variable-speed supercharger drive, letting the existing variable-speed component handle the inevitable disagreement about how fast the whole thing ought to be turning. I will do some more scheming and see if I can come up with a rendition of this system that is remotely plausible.

10: When you talk of mileage, are you talking about horsepower-miles or just raw distance? If the latter, is it not possible that a better fuel (though with less energy) gets the same plane further due to the other benefits it provides? (Ability to run "hotter", use higher compression, etc)
This point reminds me of the frankly quite funny realization the designers of the XB-70 Valkyrie came to - that their penetration bomber ought to spend the whole trip at top speed, because their "cruise" setting was actually burning more fuel per distance!
 
3: Are the individual compressor inefficiencies not multiplied in a two-stage system?
Yes.
However, the benefits will outweigh the shortcomings. Already in the 1930s people (Bristol, Piaggio, Farman, Junkers) were making the 2-stage superchargers for altitude records, handily beating the 1-stage superchargers in that regard. Sometimes the engineers made a mistake here or there, but the road was clear wrt. the advantages of the 2-stager vs. 1-stager.
The impellers and compete superchargers were improving by the late 1930s and early 1940s, making the superchargers (both 1-stage and 2-stage) ever more efficient. See eg. this, with the different graphs showing the advances.

I was under the impression that two-stage supercharging was used to reach boost levels not feasible in a single-stage system due to compressor speed limitations, and that single-stage supercharging would always give the best efficiency.
At really low altitudes, the 1-stage superchargers can compete. The 2-stage S/Cs will be better already as we approach medium altitudes, and will be far better once above 20000 ft. Having good intercoolers/aftercoolers, water-alcohol injection, high octane fuel and low compression ratio took away the sting from the heat build-up, that was one, perhaps major, consequence of the inefficiency (as well as of the high pressure ratios).
If the 1-stage S/C is spun to the very high tip speeds in order to achieve the big pressure ratios that are required for high altitudes, it's efficiency drops off sharply. See again the pamphlet I've linked above, especially the Fig.11.

What property of turbocharging necessitates that a mechanical supercharger also be present? Is it by chance that all turbocharged aircraft I know of also have an engine-driven compressor? What incentivises the turbocharger-first ordering of these systems?
For really high altitudes, we'd really want two stages of compression. Turbochargers were usually with just one compressor stage, so the engine-stage is there as a second stage of compression. So no chance, but by a design, tat least for the ww2 US aircraft using that. It also allows that the mass-produced engine is simply taken as-is and that the turbo system is just a bolt-on accessory that helps with improving the engine power at high altitudes.
The 1st stage is bigger than the 2-stage as a rule. Big impeller running at high RPM will require a lot of power to run up high, talk 300-400 HP, and the exhaust energy is sorta free and available, so it makes sense that the turbo is the 1st stage. The engine-stage S/C will require perhaps half of that power?
Further, it will be very awkward to re-route the compressed air away from the engine-stage S/C towards the turbo.

Is the two-stage single-speed system better than a one-stage two-speed system?
I don't think that there was any military engine of 1930s-40s that have had a 2-stage 1-speed S/C. Piaggio made one for altitude records, before moving on 2-stage 2-speed version.

5: I suppose I was misleading here as well. I understand that most, if not all radiator systems attempted to use the Meredith effect, but installations like that of the mosquito limited the ability of the exhaust thrust to contribute to propelling the plane. Was the advantage of the inlet being in an exceptionally high-pressure zone able to overcome this drawback? Similarly, does the annular system have any notable advantage over the "simple" Meredith duct system of the mustang?

I'm not sure that the annular radiator has advantage in streamlining when compared with the Mustang's system, at least when compared with the 'developed' version as used on the Merlin Mustangs.
On the Mosquito, the wing extension housing the radiators also increased the chord of the inner wing, making it having lower thickness-to-chord ratio, and thus reducing the drag at high speeds, so probably it was a net gain with all pros and cons accounted for. Add also the lack of the boundary layer ingestion there.

10: Interesting, I had heard of ethanol but figured it must have been a more recent advancement in the world of engines. What prevented the adoption of ethanol in other countries, or was the "lead lobby" in full force worldwide? Another agent I have come across (in "The Secret Horsepower Race", of course) is methylaniline, used by Germany. How do these two octane boosters compare?
Germans used 30% of ethanol with the IIRC, 68 oct fuel (other 70%) to make the 80 oct fuel called A2, for the use on trainer aircraft. Italians were also using partially 'alcoholised' fuel for their aircraft.
My knowledge about methylaniline is weak :)
Americans (and possibly British) were selling the TEL technology abroad in the 1930s, including in Germany. Including making of whole factories. These factories (it was just a few of them) were not, unfortunately, high on the target list for either RAF or USAAF heavy bombers.
FWIW, French were experimenting with water (!!) added to fuel in the 1930s to increse the octane rating, and successfully, only that the experiments being squashed by the another domestic lobby - that of benzene-producing companies (benzene being a popular octane-boosting agent back then, despite it being very toxic)

tl;dr - Might be that people calling the shots were believers in TEL much more than they were in ethanol; their 'belief' being directed by some light or heavy bribing by the interested parties.
 
A lot depends on what you are trying to do. Ethanol works but it has less BTUs per pound. You actually get less milage with ethanol blend fuels for the same weight of fuel.
What engine has a better mileage - engine A with 6:1 CR running on 87 oct fuel, or the engine B with 7:1 CR using E85 (~100 oct rating, if not better)?
 
You might get around a 10% increase fuel consumption (decrease in actual fuel used per horsepower hour) if you actually get the 100-octane rating from 15% methanol.
A lot depends on the actual fuel, Getting to 87 octane (68.29PN) in the 30s and 40s required a number of changes from pure gasoline.
Straight run gasoline was around 54 PN lean and 61 PN rich without lead. With 4CCs of lead it went to 78 PN lean and 93PN rich. This was not pure, it was mix of Hydrocarbon paraffin + cyclic paraffin + aromatic. Cat cracked fuel of the same basic components ran around 61 lean, 85 rich with no lead and 93 lean/130 rich with 4CCs of lead.
Methanol, when running lean is about 75 on the PN scale. When running rich it is very high indeed, not listed on the chart I have.
However, for aircraft, Alcohol weighs about 10% more per gallon than gasoline and has about 66% of the energy per gallon we have a problem on range per 100 pounds (or 100kg) of fuel. Getting the desired increase in PN number (octane rating? ) may also depend on what else was added to the fuel. With methanol the law of diminish returns applies.
Getting non-cat cracked gas up to 68-69 PN (87 octane) without lead take bit of work to begin with. A lot of things don't respond to lead at all. Benzine for instance goes from 68PN lean with or without lead to over 160 with when running rich. Problem is that it is a solid (not liquid) at 5.5 degrees C. so you can't use too much of it ;)
 
Aviation fuel seems very complex. While it may be of less relevance to warplanes, how does diesel (and associated additives) compare here?
From what I know, diesel does not subscribe to the idea of octane, instead using the reverse (cetane number, higher meaning ignites more readily).
 
Aviation fuel seems very complex. While it may be of less relevance to warplanes, how does diesel (and associated additives) compare here?
From what I know, diesel does not subscribe to the idea of octane, instead using the reverse (cetane number, higher meaning ignites more readily).
It is a very complex subject. Only the American, British and German fuel situations/histories are talked about very much. Italian, Japanese, French and Soviet situations/histories get neglected.
A lot of work went into diesels in the 1920s, 30s and 40s. Practice was always behind theory and only at rare times did diesels show any advantage in performance and that was only for long-range flying where the combined weight of the engines and fuel came out less than spark ignition engines and fuel. The much higher compression ratios of the diesels called for heavier construction of the engines and higher weight for equal power. Savings in fuel weight only came out ahead for very long range and since the Spark ignition crowd was able to use better fuel and better materials the diesel advantage rarely lasted very long. And there were other disadvantages for diesels. For passenger use in unpressurized cabins they smelled worse (worse than gasoline fumes?). They often took longer warm up and they vibrated worse.
 
Methanol, when running lean is about 75 on the PN scale. When running rich it is very high indeed, not listed on the chart I have.
However, for aircraft, Alcohol weighs about 10% more per gallon than gasoline and has about 66% of the energy per gallon we have a problem on range per 100 pounds (or 100kg) of fuel. Getting the desired increase in PN number (octane rating? ) may also depend on what else was added to the fuel. With methanol the law of diminish returns applies.
Thanks for the feedback.
Please note that I've specifically said 'ethanol', not 'methanol'.
 
fuel.........................................................Methanol..........Ethanol
boiling point.............................................148...................173
freezing point.........................................-144.................-174
Latent heat of vaporization................473...................370
BTUs per pound....................................8,600.............11,500
weight pounds per gallon.................6.62...................6.58

Temps are Fahrenheit. Knock ratings are pretty much the same
Ethanol has more BTUs per pound but is still very low.
For engines with carbs the latent heat of vaporization gives more cooling of the intake mixture.
For gasoline it was around 140 depending on exact mix and this was one of the advantages of using alcohol. It lowered the intake mixture temperature.

edit. water had a latent heat of vaporization of 970BTUs per pound. Which is why water injection worked so well. The alcohol (of whatever type) was just there to keep the water from freezing. The BTUs of 1/2 pound of alcohol in a 50/50 mix is not going to make much difference to an engine.
 
Last edited:
How much utility does the injection of fuel additives outside the cylinder lose when the engine is operating on a two-stroke cycle? (Given the inevitable loss of some air and its contents out the exhaust port)

I would imagine that provided injected water evaporated entirely before entering the cylinder, there would be minimal difference.
But for anti-knock injecta, this may not be the case.

Why does a carburetor gain more use of vapourisation cooling?
 
I wanted to address this list 1st, before I go back to the next 10 questions:

1. They are taking advantage of both velocity and pressure.
Let's go back before we go ahead. Thee premier turbosupercharger manufacturer was General Electric. Their premier business was steam turbines, and by '30, it had been determined that the best shape for the turbine blades were airfoils. So, the turbocharger turbine is taking advantage of the pressure differential to get flow velocity over the airfoils to spin the shaft - far more efficient than raw expansion.​
​
Unfortunately, with the metallurgy available in '30s, even GE couldn't create a stator that would withstand the heat/corrosive gases. And the single row axial turbine made way more power than required for the intake side requirements. A​
​
Switching to the compressor: GE could have manufactured a multi-row axial compressor (You can't compress air 3.5:1 with a single row axial compressor), but the cost to do so was much, much greater than tacking on a centrifugal compressor. So, they did a quick and dirty solution on the intake and continued to focus on the exhaust (improved exhaust solution translates to improved steam turbine, which GE was going to be making 100s of after the war - they have shareholders to keep happy for the foreseeable future.​
​
Back to the exhaust, you will notice, even with modern super alloys and ceramics, centrifugal turbines are kept small. i.e. for the 2,400hp engine in the CAT 797, the 24 cyl. engine has 4 - "600" hp turbochargers, not 1 large "2,400" hp one.​
​
Even P&W had figured that out in WWII, the R-2800 sidewinder had 2 smaller compressors for the 1st stage as bigger was no longer proving better.​
​
2. Formula 1 turbochargers are currently limited by rules to 4.8:1 PR and a single stage.
Compressor efficiency would look like this chart:​

1779459459410.png


When you're in the sweet spot you get 78% efficiency, when you're not spinning at the best speed/compressing the ideal amount/flowing the ideal amount of air, the efficiency falls off the mountain peak.​
​
3. tomo pauk tomo pauk kind of danced around the two speed versus stage benefits:
Starting with Single Speed, Single stage: If you design your Merlin III to have peak performance (~1k hp) at 17k'; it will take "x" hp to drive the supercharger. But if you don't throttle the engine at sea level, the supercharger will over boost the engine and blow it up. When you throttle the engine, you now only have ~900hp available for take off.​
By adding a 2nd speed (30 lbs. of extra gears/housing/controls) in Merlin X, you can have ~1.1k hp at sea level for take off. By turning the supercharger slower, it is absorbing 100hp less and your no longer throttling the engine so you gain the other 100hp.​
When you shift into the high gear, it is just like the single speed.​
​
So, if you are flying below supercharger requirement of 3.5:1 (WWII efficient limit), Single Stage is all you need. If you can't justify the extra cost/weight (Fighter) of multi speed, Single speed is all you need. If you can justify it (fighter bomber/bomber), the variable or multi-speed is worth it.​
​
If you want to fly really high (>3.5:1 Pressure ratio); it becomes more efficient to use multiple stages, as it is easier to make 2 - superchargers with 2.1:1 PR with high efficiency than to make a single stage of 4.5:1 (2.1:1 x 2.1:1 ~ 4.5:1).​
However, if you don't have the ability to limit the boost, it would again over boost at take off and blow the engine up. As the supercharger is absorbing 200+ hp to provide you with 900 hp** at 25', if you just 'throttle' the engine, you will only have ~600 hp available for take off. So, including 2nd (or variable) speed when using 2 stages is basically a requirement​
​
* This assumes your basic engine design can pass the higher power output to propeller when putting less power to the supercharger.​
** For this discussion, I am assuming the same 87 octane limit for the Merlin (87 octane would allow ~100hp/cylinder raw power, then deduct what the supercharger takes to get what the propeller with receive)​
​
Work calls, so I will continue when I can.​
​
 
If you want to fly really high (>3.5:1 Pressure ratio); it becomes more efficient to use multiple stages, as it is easier to make 2 - superchargers with 2.1:1 PR with high efficiency than to make a single stage of 4.5:1 (2.1:1 x 2.1:1 ~ 4.5:1).
Are we sure that it is 'pressure_ratio x pressure_ratio', and not pressure_'ratio + pressure_ratio' for the superchargers with more than one stage?
 
Charge cooling works well because several things are going on.
As the 'water' cools the intake charge/mix and the temperature goes down the charge gets denser (more lbs per cu ft ) and we are not burning pressure, we are burning lbs of fuel with air. At high altitude we have trouble supplying enough air to go with the fuel we can inject into the airstream. Pressure was just the simplest way to measure the air flow but it requires a lot of assertions.
Pressure works pretty good for measuring water since water is not compressible. But it is not as good as flow meter. A kink/bend in an output line will give you a high pressure reading even if you have restricted flow.
With air in a supercharged engine and the air at 300-400 degrees the density of air at 44in is lot lower than air at 150 degrees and 44im as an off the cuff example.
The cooler charge also heats the engine less for less wear on the engine and/or less problems with cooling system/s. It can allow for more boost than an engine that is not using a charge cooling system (inter cooler, after cooler or water injection) and keep the temperature limits in line and using extra boost on the cooler/denser air is a multiplication.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back