AspiringHowardHughes
Airman
- 70
- Nov 26, 2025
A.H.H here. Those here who prefer answering questions to reading investigations are in luck this time.
As I work toward designing a hypothetical WW2 aircraft of my own, I have come up with a series of engine questions on which there is either conflicting evidence or insufficient discussion available.
For the sake of readability, I ask that respondents number the question they are responding to as I have done while asking them.
Thanks in advance, I will waste no more words on prelude.
1: Why did turbochargers of WW2 seem not to make use of the velocity of the exhaust gas? The images and schematics I have seen universally depict the turbine as being a single-stage axial type, with the exhaust not being encouraged in any particular direction of rotation as it entered the housing. This suggests to me that it is only the pressure difference that is being capitalized upon, rather than the flow rate. This is in stark contrast to turbochargers of today, which (excluding some axial types used on generator engines) seem to be almost a mirror-image of their impellor counterparts. Was there some metallurgical obstacle to this at the time? Additionally, I would think that even if a purely axial turbine is being used, there would be benefit to a consistent direction of gas rotation - both to reduce turbulent losses and to extract more energy out of the exhaust.
2: What is the performance limit of a single-stage supercharger using a variable-speed drive? Essentially, what becomes the limiting factor of performance/efficiency/ceiling if the impellor can be made to rotate at any desired speed? The texts I have found that claim to depict this are never in a language that I speak, unfortunately.
3: What differentiates a two-speed supercharger from a two-stage supercharger in terms of performance/efficiency/ceiling? Is one system downright superior to the other given the same level of design?
4: All other things being equal, what is the ideal location and method for the introduction of fuel? Carburetion, single-point injection, or individual injection into the air intake, compressor eye, intake manifold, port, or direct injection are all candidates that come to mind. Similarly, to what extent do the claimed benefits of these systems exist only as a consolation prize for an imperfectly designed engine? For example, is the reduced charge heating when fuel is injected in the compressor eye a benefit unobtainable by direct injection, or just a bonus that helps even the odds?
5: What is the ideal radiator type, all things considered? The Meredith effect is a wonderful thing, but if it mandates that the radiator be a good distance away from the engine there is then a penalty of weight, complexity, and fragility that results from the need to plumb the plane. The leading-edge system of the mosquito, as well as the annular system favoured by Germany, both come to mind. Annoyingly, the rationales of the people who designed these planes are not as available as I would like. If anyone has such information, I would be most grateful.
6: Was there ever any need for cooling air to be allowed into the engine compartment of a liquid-cooled engine, or was all cooling the job of the designated radiator? I would think the nuisance of water/glycol/oil cooling minute components that only barely need cooling at all to be a source of needless complexity.
7: If the mechanism was present, would there be any advantage to be gained by setting up an engine-driven compressor to also be half of a turbocharger installation? Would this allow for a degree of power recovery from the turbine when simply using it to further compress the charge is unnecessary, dangerous, or impossible?
8: To what degree did engine and airframe designers conspire when their products were being designed at the same time? Surely service, installation, and compactness could be substantially improved if there was any amount of cooperation happening.
9: For a firm the size of Rolls-Royce (for example), what is the approximate latest time an engine could have been first conceived of while still having it be "king of the hill" during the war? Obviously the later the basic outline is produced the better, as the fundamental groundwork of the engine would be more modern (and thus have a higher performance potential) but too late and you run the risk of not allowing the design to mature enough. For the sake of this thought experiment, assume that the company in question is not propping up the entire aerial military at the time, and thus can afford not to have an engine in full production for a few years. (Unlike Rolls-Royce....)
10: What fuel additives could have been helpful during the war that were not, besides those that were simply far too advanced for the time?
Explanatory images available upon request.
I may make a habit of creating these community Q&A posts.
As I work toward designing a hypothetical WW2 aircraft of my own, I have come up with a series of engine questions on which there is either conflicting evidence or insufficient discussion available.
For the sake of readability, I ask that respondents number the question they are responding to as I have done while asking them.
Thanks in advance, I will waste no more words on prelude.
1: Why did turbochargers of WW2 seem not to make use of the velocity of the exhaust gas? The images and schematics I have seen universally depict the turbine as being a single-stage axial type, with the exhaust not being encouraged in any particular direction of rotation as it entered the housing. This suggests to me that it is only the pressure difference that is being capitalized upon, rather than the flow rate. This is in stark contrast to turbochargers of today, which (excluding some axial types used on generator engines) seem to be almost a mirror-image of their impellor counterparts. Was there some metallurgical obstacle to this at the time? Additionally, I would think that even if a purely axial turbine is being used, there would be benefit to a consistent direction of gas rotation - both to reduce turbulent losses and to extract more energy out of the exhaust.
2: What is the performance limit of a single-stage supercharger using a variable-speed drive? Essentially, what becomes the limiting factor of performance/efficiency/ceiling if the impellor can be made to rotate at any desired speed? The texts I have found that claim to depict this are never in a language that I speak, unfortunately.
3: What differentiates a two-speed supercharger from a two-stage supercharger in terms of performance/efficiency/ceiling? Is one system downright superior to the other given the same level of design?
4: All other things being equal, what is the ideal location and method for the introduction of fuel? Carburetion, single-point injection, or individual injection into the air intake, compressor eye, intake manifold, port, or direct injection are all candidates that come to mind. Similarly, to what extent do the claimed benefits of these systems exist only as a consolation prize for an imperfectly designed engine? For example, is the reduced charge heating when fuel is injected in the compressor eye a benefit unobtainable by direct injection, or just a bonus that helps even the odds?
5: What is the ideal radiator type, all things considered? The Meredith effect is a wonderful thing, but if it mandates that the radiator be a good distance away from the engine there is then a penalty of weight, complexity, and fragility that results from the need to plumb the plane. The leading-edge system of the mosquito, as well as the annular system favoured by Germany, both come to mind. Annoyingly, the rationales of the people who designed these planes are not as available as I would like. If anyone has such information, I would be most grateful.
6: Was there ever any need for cooling air to be allowed into the engine compartment of a liquid-cooled engine, or was all cooling the job of the designated radiator? I would think the nuisance of water/glycol/oil cooling minute components that only barely need cooling at all to be a source of needless complexity.
7: If the mechanism was present, would there be any advantage to be gained by setting up an engine-driven compressor to also be half of a turbocharger installation? Would this allow for a degree of power recovery from the turbine when simply using it to further compress the charge is unnecessary, dangerous, or impossible?
8: To what degree did engine and airframe designers conspire when their products were being designed at the same time? Surely service, installation, and compactness could be substantially improved if there was any amount of cooperation happening.
9: For a firm the size of Rolls-Royce (for example), what is the approximate latest time an engine could have been first conceived of while still having it be "king of the hill" during the war? Obviously the later the basic outline is produced the better, as the fundamental groundwork of the engine would be more modern (and thus have a higher performance potential) but too late and you run the risk of not allowing the design to mature enough. For the sake of this thought experiment, assume that the company in question is not propping up the entire aerial military at the time, and thus can afford not to have an engine in full production for a few years. (Unlike Rolls-Royce....)
10: What fuel additives could have been helpful during the war that were not, besides those that were simply far too advanced for the time?
Explanatory images available upon request.
I may make a habit of creating these community Q&A posts.