Bf 109F-2 or F-4 (1 Viewer)

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

Jamoliva

Airman 1st Class
185
195
Feb 7, 2016
Northeastern Pennsylvania
Greetings all!

This was Hans Philipp's aircraft of I.JG54 at Krasnogvardeisk in early 1942. Was it a Bf 109F-2 or F-4? I am seeing and reading a lot of information suggesting both ways. Thank you for your help!

1619137049198.png
 
IMHO that's the F-2 vesion. If you enlarged the shot with its tail in you'll notice the two bars being the fuselage reinforcement. The F-4 variant didn't have the external fuselage reinforcement because it was moved to the fuselage interior, as memo serves.
 
The Werk Nummer for this aircraft is unknown, however I see no evidence of stiffening struts under the tail plane but this is certainly an F-2
 
Not the struts that were used in the A-E's.
Thank you, but I did not mean A-E tail plane struts but the stiffening struts applied to the fuselage following a spate of crashes caused by structural failure. I do see these on the image now!
 

Attachments

  • F-2 Rear Fuselage Stiffeners.jpg
    F-2 Rear Fuselage Stiffeners.jpg
    11.5 KB · Views: 58
Thank you very much all! I really appreciate all the answers. I think Hans Philipp's aircraft was a F-2 too but I also read that the stiffening struts applied to early F-4s as well. It might be wrong information. Another curious case is Herman Graf's aircraft which is usually described as an F-4 (W. Nr. 7420). Photos of this aircraft from May 1942 do show these struts. This does bring the question if the early F-4 models had these struts as well. The W. Nr. bloc 7251-7660 is referred as Bf109 F-4/Z built by Wiener Neustädter Flugzeugwerke (WNF). Thank you again for all the great information!

1620066360880.png

1620066385776.png
 
Hello,

List of 109F retrofitted with external stiffeners (From 4.4.41 to 10.10.41)

F-1: 5601 - 5608
F-1 AGO: 12601; 12602; 12605
F-1 Arado: 109.5401-109.5436
F-1 WNF: 6601 - 6771; 6773-6783

F-2: 5611-5616; 5618-5630; 5632-5639; 5641-5645; 5647-5654; 5657-5659; 5661-5665; 5667-5671; 5673-5679; 5681-5683; 5685-5701; 5703-5706; 5708-5714; 5716; 5718-5730; 5734; 5736; 5738; 5743; 5744; 5746-5751; 5753; 5754; 5757; 5763-5765; 5779; 8904

F-2 Erla: 8078-8086; 8088-8106; 8108; 8109; 8111-8114; 8118-8122; 8124; 8125; 8127; 8128; 8133; 8135

F-2 AGO; 12608; 12610; 12614; 12617; 12619; 12621; 12623-12625; 12627; 12630-12635; 12643; 12648; 12652; 12654; 12656; 12658; 12663; 12664; 12667; 12668; 12672; 12674; 12682; 12718; 12723; 12755

F-2 Arado: 109.5438; 109.5439; 109.5441; 109.5443; 109.5444; 109.5456; 109.5458; 109.5459; 109.5462; 109.5463; 109.5466; 109.5467; 109.5469-109.5471; 109.5475; 109.5476; 109.5477; 109.5479; 109.5480; 109.5482; 109.5485; 109.5486; 109.5491; 109.5499; 109.5504-109.5528

F-2 WNF: 6785-6800

F-4 WNF: 6999-7660

F-4 Erla: 8267-8806
 
Hello,

List of 109F retrofitted with external stiffeners (From 4.4.41 to 10.10.41)

F-1: 5601 - 5608
F-1 AGO: 12601; 12602; 12605
F-1 Arado: 109.5401-109.5436
F-1 WNF: 6601 - 6771; 6773-6783

F-2: 5611-5616; 5618-5630; 5632-5639; 5641-5645; 5647-5654; 5657-5659; 5661-5665; 5667-5671; 5673-5679; 5681-5683; 5685-5701; 5703-5706; 5708-5714; 5716; 5718-5730; 5734; 5736; 5738; 5743; 5744; 5746-5751; 5753; 5754; 5757; 5763-5765; 5779; 8904

F-2 Erla: 8078-8086; 8088-8106; 8108; 8109; 8111-8114; 8118-8122; 8124; 8125; 8127; 8128; 8133; 8135

F-2 AGO; 12608; 12610; 12614; 12617; 12619; 12621; 12623-12625; 12627; 12630-12635; 12643; 12648; 12652; 12654; 12656; 12658; 12663; 12664; 12667; 12668; 12672; 12674; 12682; 12718; 12723; 12755

F-2 Arado: 109.5438; 109.5439; 109.5441; 109.5443; 109.5444; 109.5456; 109.5458; 109.5459; 109.5462; 109.5463; 109.5466; 109.5467; 109.5469-109.5471; 109.5475; 109.5476; 109.5477; 109.5479; 109.5480; 109.5482; 109.5485; 109.5486; 109.5491; 109.5499; 109.5504-109.5528

F-2 WNF: 6785-6800

F-4 WNF: 6999-7660

F-4 Erla: 8267-8806
Wow, Steph! This is an awesome list. Thank you! What is the reference?
 
Actually it is very difficult to state if a particular plane is the F-2 or F-4 variant. The only thing that allows to say which verision we can see, is the triangle with the kind of the fuel applied below the fuel cap at the bottom of the cockpit hood. If there is the C-3 that's the F-2 but if there is the 87 or B4 that's the F-4. Unfortunatelly not always it is possible to find a nice image with the marking seen.

Bf 109F-2
Bf-109F2-Stab-JG51.jpg


Bf 109F-4
Bf-109F4-Marseill_e.jpg

the pic source: the Internet
 
Actually it is very difficult to state if a particular plane is the F-2 or F-4 variant. The only thing that allows to say which verision we can see, is the triangle with the kind of the fuel applied below the fuel cap at the bottom of the cockpit hood. If there is the C-3 that's the F-2 but if there is the 87 or B4 that's the F-4. Unfortunatelly not always it is possible to find a nice image with the marking seen.

Bf 109F-2
View attachment 621894

Bf 109F-4
View attachment 621895
the pic source: the Internet
Thank you! You are right. Great photos. Considering what everyone said, I think it is safe to say that Philipp's aircraft was a F-2. We don't have the W.Nr. and the fuel label was painted over. Graf's aircraft has a W.Nr. so know that it was a F-4. Interesting thing, though, was reading about this subject. If it is not wrong information, apparently there were some F-2s even retrofitted with DB 601 Es and MG 151/20s as they become more available which makes them practically F-4s with F-2 W. Nr.s.
 
That's true. It appears that the early and mid batches of the F-4 had the stiffeners attached. What makes the matter worse is the mix of the basic components used for both the F-2 and F-4. Eg... the air intake to the supercharger, the oil cooler, the external bulletproof windshield or the propeller
Here is a pic of Bf 109F that is said to be the same kite questioned here. But the image was taken a little bit later. Please notice the differemt colours of the spinner and what's more, the external bulletproof windshield .

16.jpg


16a.jpg

the pic source: the web
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back