Nobody convinced me that the proximity fuses would transform Luftwaffe flak into a weapon system capable of devastating allied formations. The Luftwaffe originally thought they needed to get the shell (88mm) within 30m of a bomber to destroy it. This was revised down to 3m. That's the problem. Your projectile needs to pass within 3m of the target to be "devastating" and nothing here has convinced me that this was possible often enough to have a huge effect on allied losses.
Cheers
Steve
Not 3m for a proximity fuse. I take it that the mechanism in that case was the blast damage breaking structural member. Which makes sense for an ordinary shell (because the fragments arriving mseconds after the blasdt wave would be within the 'preblasted' region if the shell exploded at all early (3 meters before the shell reached the airframe) or wouldn't impact at all if the shell burst past the aircraft. In a VT shell the detonation distance from the plane is adjusted by trial and error research to use the fragments and the blast wave together. (Maybe the blast wave to 'pre stress' the metal panels and thus the load bearing members of a plane the fragments arriving milliseconds later taking the combined stress past failure - either blowing away large areas of skin or doing worse damage. At least that's the way I imagine it. )
The distance of detonation may have been 20ft. In any case the area of 'lethal' destruction at minimum with the smallest 3.5" shell was very roughly equivalent to about 25ft radius with the best type 53 fuse and a 5"3/8 shell about 46ft radius, estimated using test ammo against a test plane suspended from pylons - mostly a 'Kate'.
(A VT fuze can give you a detonation disatnce correct to about 2or3 ft as far as I can tell/guess - or be a dud/premature completely)
Just running through the advantages of VT as I understand them:
No fuze setting - increases rate of fire (for the British vs V1s about double) x2 advantage to VT
Crew or autoloader can load VT, then wait and fire (there is no 'race' to predict aim and fire gun before the fuse setting becomes obsolete) shots taken are always at the highest accuracy possible. guess - another x2 advantage?
Depth (time accuracy factor) eliminated : to get a detonation within 3 meters either side at 1200ft per second typical approach speed with a fuze capable at best of 0.1second innate precision (never mind the accuracy of time of flight calculation) is a chance of 1 in 4 in the depth dimension at best. 20 - 25% accurate vs VTs 90% reliability. a x4 advantage
Bigger lethal diameter due to different mode of action about 23 feet radius minimum 46ft maximum: call it 15 m diameter from the surface conservatively : 'hit rate' advantage to VT of about x5?
If that's somewhere in the right region then a VT shell on average would be on the close order of 40 times as lethal as an ordinary shell against B17s and the like. Worth having - but not decisive on its own? (by on the close order of 40 I mean somewhere around 20 to 80). That's consistent with the reported UK result vs V1s of 2500 shots/kill to 100 with VT and still getting better.
Further advantage against low fast targets? - you get one more aimed shot in before the target closes or is obscured ?