Eastern front luftwaffe victory claim from tony wood and petr kacha

• May 30, 2018

• #1

G

gomwolf

Guest

It is just excelized file of Tony wood and Petr Kacha's charts for count for total victory claim. It include claims of Flak batteries assigned to luftwaffe.

Reliability of the figure from 1.1.45 to 8.5.45 are low. Kacha's chart were not divided by front, so I divided it myself(based on aircraft type, base of claimant's unit, and claimant's record). The case seems likely, but without any proof, it is included in the 'Possible E/F Claims'.

Some mistouches possible.



It is quite smaller than I expected. I thought they claimed more than 40,000 victories but, only 32,945 were claimed include 'possible case'. Might be many missing cases in those charts, but I can't find any more reliable source. If someone have, please tell me.

 

Last edited by a moderator: May 30, 2018

• May 30, 2018

• #2

fubar57

General

34,021

21,318

Nov 22, 2009

The Jungles of Canada

I turned it into PDF for those who don't have Excel. Unfortunately you have to zoom in 500% to read it...

 

Attachments

• Luftwaffe Claims Eastern Front.pdf

  73.8 MB · Views: 336

• May 30, 2018

• Thread starter
• #3

G

gomwolf

Guest

Slightly fixed.

 

Attachments

• Luftwaffe Claims Eastern Front.xlsx

  2.1 MB · Views: 446

• May 30, 2018

• #4

tomo pauk

Creator of Interesting Threads

14,640

4,862

Apr 3, 2008

Thank you.
Re. Excel files: link

 

• May 30, 2018

• #5

fubar57

General

34,021

21,318

Nov 22, 2009

The Jungles of Canada

gomwolf said:

Slightly fixed.

Click to expand...

Is there much of a difference from the first one you posted?

 

• May 30, 2018

• Thread starter
• #6

G

gomwolf

Guest

fubar57 said:

Is there much of a difference from the first one you posted?

Click to expand...

Nope. Only few mistouches.

 

• May 30, 2018

• #7

GregP

Major

9,518

6,458

Jul 28, 2003

Chino, California, U.S.A.

I just ordered Frank Olynyk's Stars and Bars, with U.S. WWII aerial victories. It will likely take some time, after it arrives, to get into Excel, but I have a lot of others that have been posted in here before. Buried in "old threads," I'm sure. I'm not even sure how to find them.

But, if there is interest, I can re-post. Most of you guys likely HAVE my aerial victory files by now.

Cheers.

 

• May 31, 2018

• Thread starter
• #8

G

gomwolf

Guest

Finally, I found what I missed. Tony Wood and Petr Kacha weren't write ground destroying claims(by bombers or stukas and others) into their chart. It is aerial victories only. What a stupid I am... Ok. It means I need another reliable source about germans ground destroy claims. I want to claims not actual kills. Maybe I need to read more books about it.

If someone who have some info about it, please tell me. I'd really appreciate you.

 

• May 31, 2018

• #9

fubar57

General

34,021

21,318

Nov 22, 2009

The Jungles of Canada

GregP said:

I just ordered Frank Olynyk's Stars and Bars, with U.S. WWII aerial victories. It will likely take some time, after it arrives, to get into Excel, but I have a lot of others that have been posted in here before. Buried in "old threads," I'm sure. I'm not even sure how to find them. But, if there is interest, I can re-post. Most of you guys likely HAVE my aerial victory files by now.

Cheers.

Click to expand...

Very much interested Greg. I had one of your earlier Excel files but deleted it. Now that I can convert them I would love to see them again

 

• Jun 6, 2018

• #10

GregP

Major

9,518

6,458

Jul 28, 2003

Chino, California, U.S.A.

Hey Fubar57, PM me your email address and we can talk about the files.