Hi DarrenW,
A red X is not a negative, it means "I disagree." Agreement and disagreement are the basis of discussion.
There weren't many WWII carrier planes with a landing speed of 81 mph. Most were slower.
I have not posted any "flame attempts" or said anything about you personally. The specs on the J2M I can find simply don't match what you've posted and I have the rather unique opportunity to see one live anytime I want to. Perhaps that makes a difference to me, but the J2M-3 seems like a pretty good fighter from all I can find, and that is backed up by a Planes of Fame Museum member from Japan.
I have no dog in this hunt. I just like the Raiden and you don't seem to. There is absolutely nothing wrong with either opinion.
Let's try a calculation. A basic wings-level stall speed should be about: Vs = 17.2 * square root (W / (CLmax * sigma * S)), where Vs = stall speed in knots, W = weight, CL max = max lift coefficient, sigma = altitude density ratio, and S = wing area (sq ft). Let's try sea level, 7,077 lbs combat weight, 215.8 sq ft wing area, sigma = 1 at sea level ... and I'll go with CL max = 1.5 for a decent WWII fighter wing average. It could be better. Calculated stall speed without flaps using the above formula is 80.4 knots TAS, making the flaps down stall speed of 81 mph in the specs look pretty darned close. And, it's a far cry from 138 mph. Let's say the flaps aren't very good and drop the stall speed by only 5 knots. That puts it at 75.4 knots or 86.7 mph. Considering I don't have the real CL max, I'd believe the 81 mph any day. If the real CL max goes to something like 1.65, the flaps-up stall speed calculates to 76.7 knots. The real number SHOULD be somewhere around 1.45 - 1.65, I can't say where it actually falls.
The J2M is rather widely regarded as a pretty good fighter when it was operating correctly.
We don't have to agree on the Raiden. There is only one left, and it isn't flying at this time. So, we just disagree on its merits. No biggie. Cheers to you.
Several sources: I can find the wing area at:
Mitsubishi J2M Raiden (Jack) Info or any number of websites. Try:
Mitsubishi J2M Raiden (Thunderbolt) 'Jack' , too, for number produced and
Mitsubishi J2M Raiden - Specifications - Technical Data / Description, too. I also have a book, "Japanese Aircraft Performance and Characteristics," written by Ed Maloney, founder of the Planes of Fame. His quoted specs come straight from TAIC. I have other books, but they say the same things.
Cheers again.