1930-1945: alternative engines for military purposes (3 Viewers)

Their 'small' V12s were compact and reliable engines, but there the benefits really stop. Something that is V6 sibling of a 30-35L V12* would've gotten them compactness and reliability, too, but also lower price and time to make the engines and gearboxes, easier maintenance in the field, and will require the shorter engine bay.

* Germans were thinking about the heavy tanks much before they gotten into that in reality, that a big V12 should be powering.



The French were designing and making heavy tanks in the 1920s and 30s. Them opting for V12s for these tanks, with en eye for V8 and/or V6 versions for the smaller tanks might've been both economicaly and military prudent.
Also - their heavy tanks were big and boxy. A good radial engine would not be too much for the hull to house these.


An inline 6 would've been an ideal engine if the tank has the 'Merkava' layout - engine sits besides the driver, front sprocket driving the tracks. While not common on tanks of the day, it was not unheard of - Vickers light tanks had that, so did a lot of Soviet light tanks, and so did the Elefant (but with the electric 'transmission'). Frees a hefty % of the hull length and volume, and the tank can be repurposed into a SP chassis in an elegant fashion.

Another way of making the engine+transmission bay a good deal shorter was to have the engine being installed in the transversal position. That 'trick' was done on the T-43 tank, making the tank much roomier. An inline 6 installed in such a fashion would've netted even greater benefits vs. the longitudinal installation.
Every configuration has its issues, and packaging is a worse problem for AFV than small weight increases.

Looking at 1930s technology levels, I think some options are unlikely, like Hyperbar engines or extreme levels of supercharging, as in MTU's modern tank engines.

Some possibilities:
Two stroke spark ignition engines. These would require direct fuel injection to be reasonably efficient, and that technology was bleading edge. Obviously, crankcase scavenging is out. Roots blower or stepped piston would be easiest, but a Lysholm compressor would likely be better. Schneurle porting would likely be best, as uniflow designs require valve gear, opposed piston, or split-single configuration. The last has been used in cars and motorcycles, that is small engines with up to about 4 cylinders. OP spark engines were uncommon but not unknown.

Radials are tall, which is a packaging issue, and air cooling complicates packaging. A liquid cooled radial won't be much more compact, but the separate radiators would ease packaging. So would mounting the engine with the crankshaft vertical. A two-row radial wouldn't benefit much from being laid down. This does limit size and thus output to about 400 hp.

For diesels with 1930s-era technology the best choice would probably be an opposed-piston two-stroke. Get Fairbanks-Morse on the phone.

The UK and US didn't really develop clean-sheet AFV engines pre-war. Both countries had the industrial base to do so.

AFV engines are useless without transmissions. Wheeled AFV (that don't use skid steer) transmissions are straightforward. Tanks, not so much. Rear-engine, front drive seems to be the worst possible arrangement in terms of volume.

-------

Transverse, OP 6 cylinder diesel, rear-engine, rear-drive tank would be interesting....
 
Last edited:
Two stroke spark ignition engines. These would require direct fuel injection to be reasonably efficient, and that technology was bleading edge. Obviously, crankcase scavenging is out. Roots blower or stepped piston would be easiest, but a Lysholm compressor would likely be better. Schneurle porting would likely be best, as uniflow designs require valve gear, opposed piston, or split-single configuration. The last has been used in cars and motorcycles, that is small engines with up to about 4 cylinders. OP spark engines were uncommon but not unknown.
Not too bad idea for an aircraft engine, too...
 
What is the technology level/s of the time/s?

What they could do in 1944 was a lot more than they could to in 1932.
It is not just theory or ideas or even prototypes, it was the ability to make the hoped-for engine in quantity and had have it work and work one hundred hours (or more than a hundred) in use.
There were a lot of changes in materials (alloys) and some nations had material shortages (raw materials) that affected things.
Many nations made some pretty crappy tank engines. Even the US with all it's resources (and raw materials, both domestic and imported) could not build enough of the desired engines. Or at least didn't think they could and signed contracts for thousands of "substitute" standard engines. A lot of which were given away as Lend-lease.
Cadillac had made ohv V-12s and V-16s from 1930-31 to 1937 in ever diminishing numbers and even the 452cu/in V-16 was not powerful enough for a 15-20 ton tank (and was way too expensive) and Cadillac built a new 346 cu/in flat head starting 1936. This monoblock engine replaced the older V-8, the V-12 and the V-16, partially because of market conditions (no real market for V-16 cars) cost of production. Even the old flathead V-8 used separate crankcase and cylinder block/s construction. "New" flat head was lighter, cheaper to make.
Cadillac made over 16,000 cars in 1940. They had a production base. Military engines were down rated to 110hp from 135hp. One source claims the engine only had 3 main bearings. So did the Ford flathead V-8.
Getting heavy duty engines was often harder than just grabbing existing car or truck engines.
Boat engines were usually to large and heavy. Commercial boat engines (diesel was just beginning to take over, so not much help there) were often expected to last thousands of hours Years as fishing boat or tug).
A lot (most) WW II tank engines were not very good. Reliability and durability are not the same thing. Soviet V-2 engine increased engine life from around 100 hours to start to around 150hrs in 1943/44(?) Soviets also used a lot of Aluminum in the engine. Soviet supply of aluminum may have been better than Germany or Italy or Japan? Or Germany wanted to use their aluminum for airframes and not build wooden aircraft? Wooden aircraft need suitable wood, not just any wood.
The US GMC -71 series of engines is quite well known with production stopping (at least for road vehicles) in 1995 but it only started in 1938. Yes, they built about 39,000 of them for tank/afv use in WW II but they build 57,000 of them for use in landing craft. How many went into diesel generators? They bult 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6 cylinder in-lines. The V engines didn't show up until the Mid 50s. It seems like the V-6 and V-8 should have been no-brainer ideas but either there was no market (?) or there was problem putting two conrods on one crankpin.
Mid 1950s metallurgy was very different from 1938-41 metallurgy.
Diesels, at least high-power ones need either better metallurgy or a lot more weight or both to even get close to the same power as a gasoline engine. GM's diesel car engine fiasco of 1978-85 shows that rather well.
 
Not too bad idea for an aircraft engine, too...

I think a stepped-piston, direct injection two stroke would be a useful, low power aircraft engine. A little work was done on two-stroke aircraft engines, but they didn't seem particularly practical for high powers, as they were little less complex than four-strokes and thermal limitations limited power and the need to for direct fuel injection was a much harder thing to get fielded than most manufacturers seemed to expect.
 
What is the technology level/s of the time/s?

What they could do in 1944 was a lot more than they could to in 1932.
It is not just theory or ideas or even prototypes, it was the ability to make the hoped-for engine in quantity and had have it work and work one hundred hours (or more than a hundred) in use.
There were a lot of changes in materials (alloys) and some nations had material shortages (raw materials) that affected things.
Many nations made some pretty crappy tank engines. Even the US with all it's resources (and raw materials, both domestic and imported) could not build enough of the desired engines. Or at least didn't think they could and signed contracts for thousands of "substitute" standard engines. A lot of which were given away as Lend-lease.
Cadillac had made ohv V-12s and V-16s from 1930-31 to 1937 in ever diminishing numbers and even the 452cu/in V-16 was not powerful enough for a 15-20 ton tank (and was way too expensive) and Cadillac built a new 346 cu/in flat head starting 1936. This monoblock engine replaced the older V-8, the V-12 and the V-16, partially because of market conditions (no real market for V-16 cars) cost of production. Even the old flathead V-8 used separate crankcase and cylinder block/s construction. "New" flat head was lighter, cheaper to make.
Cadillac made over 16,000 cars in 1940. They had a production base. Military engines were down rated to 110hp from 135hp. One source claims the engine only had 3 main bearings. So did the Ford flathead V-8.
Getting heavy duty engines was often harder than just grabbing existing car or truck engines.
Boat engines were usually to large and heavy. Commercial boat engines (diesel was just beginning to take over, so not much help there) were often expected to last thousands of hours Years as fishing boat or tug).
A lot (most) WW II tank engines were not very good. Reliability and durability are not the same thing. Soviet V-2 engine increased engine life from around 100 hours to start to around 150hrs in 1943/44(?) Soviets also used a lot of Aluminum in the engine. Soviet supply of aluminum may have been better than Germany or Italy or Japan? Or Germany wanted to use their aluminum for airframes and not build wooden aircraft? Wooden aircraft need suitable wood, not just any wood.
The US GMC -71 series of engines is quite well known with production stopping (at least for road vehicles) in 1995 but it only started in 1938. Yes, they built about 39,000 of them for tank/afv use in WW II but they build 57,000 of them for use in landing craft. How many went into diesel generators? They bult 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6 cylinder in-lines. The V engines didn't show up until the Mid 50s. It seems like the V-6 and V-8 should have been no-brainer ideas but either there was no market (?) or there was problem putting two conrods on one crankpin.
Mid 1950s metallurgy was very different from 1938-41 metallurgy.
Diesels, at least high-power ones need either better metallurgy or a lot more weight or both to even get close to the same power as a gasoline engine. GM's diesel car engine fiasco of 1978-85 shows that rather well.
In the 1930s, Germany seems to have been well ahead in Diesel technology.

For AFV, it seems a bad idea to have tanks use a different fuel than the other army vehicles: see France 1940 for why, as the French tanks were frequently immobilized as they needed special fuel, not pool gas.

Japan and the USSR had diesel-engine tanks, so the technology was there.
 
Japan and the USSR had diesel-engine tanks, so the technology was there.
Yes and no. Soviets used a very high-powered diesel. It is claimed that it was developed from an aircraft engine. Perhaps not directly but it used a lot of aircraft features. Aluminum block and heads for one thing.
Japan used several diesels, aside from fuel economy and less problems with fire they may not have had much to recommend them.
There was a 120hp 14.3 liter 6 cylinder that was air cooled, same basic engine was used in several different tanks. Japanese then shifted to 21.7 liter V-12 of 170hp. In 1942 they got a version of the engine up to 240hp and got it into production in 1943. I don't know what the size or weight of the engines are.
British wanted 300-350hp in 1939 for their cruiser tanks.
The US was putting 350hp engines into the first 18 M2 tanks and upgraded the engines to 400hp in the M2A's. I have no idea of what size diesel was needed to make 400hp in 1939 in the US. The Guiberson company did sell some of their A-1020 engines to the Army for some M-3 light tanks. The A-1020 engine was 5 in bigger in diameter and about 175lbs heavier than the R-670 Continental. There were 28 M3 mediums tried with a T-1400 350hp Guiberson but these were judged unsatisfactory and no more were built and none of these were used in service (possibly for training in the US?). The engines, a least the A/T-1020s were built by the Buda company, a well-known maker of industrial and truck engines. A 1400 cu in radial would have been good for 450-500hp running on crap gas. Caterpillar converted some (200?) Wright R-1820s to diesel and got 450 hp and these were put into the M4A6 Shermans (75 built?) starting in late 1943. For some reason (ducting? or just available?) these had the same stretched hulls as the tanks using the Chrysler multi-bank engine. Wright was getting 620hp out of R-1820Es back in 1930-31.
Italians used V-8 diesels in the M11/39 of 105hp, enlarged to 125hp in the M13/40 and further uprated to 145hp in the M13/41. By this time the engine was 11.98 liters and attempts to get more power were unsuccessful and a version using gasoline was built which gave 192hp.
Italians did develop a diesel 330hp 24 liter V-12 for the P-26/40 but that was in early-mid 1943.

The US and British did not have fuel shortages in actual raw supply. They had problems transporting enough fuel to some theaters. Germans, Italians and Japanese did not have enough fuel at the source/s compounded by transport problems.
 
The Wright Whirlwind was handed off from Wright to Continental to build, in part because the Army had already paid for a new factory to build the IV-1430 12 cylinder engine that went nowhere and so they had production capacity to spare and in part because Wright had enough to do building R-1820s, R-2600s and R-3350s. There may be other reasons. At some point the engines in Shermans were called Continental Whirlwinds or Continental R-975s.

The Famous GMC 6-71 was rated at between about 165 and 225hp depending on model and use. They often changed the fuel injectors do get different power ratings.
The displacement was only 7 liters but it was a two stroke engine so double the number of power strokes per revolution. It was a largish engine and heavy, around 2200-2300lbs.
I know I have said that weight isn't important but you need two of them to replace one Ford V-8 or one GMC diesel weighs about 200kg less than a Tiger tank engine (1000kg to 1200kg) while giving under 1/3 the power.
Granted even a 225hp 6-71 is going to be darn near bullet proof compared to the Maybach but it is not hard to see why.
Jumo diesels worked but not well. They worked for long flights with steady throttle settings, like airline flights and maritime patrol. They had trouble with rapid changes of throttle in quick succession. Like normal medium bomber missions. We are guessing about tanks, but most tanks don't run very long at a steady rpm.
 
I was doing some reading on maritime engines and in the US at least, there was no standard diesel fuel or actually standards for diesel fuel (different grades?) until the mid 1930s. 1920s diesels for fishing boats or agriculture were designed to run on large variety of liquied fuels that were not gasoline. Anything from kerosene to better grades of crude oil interchangeably. They thought they were doing good when they got 1 hp for 25lbs of engine weight. In many applications the engines were supposed to last years in work boats, literally thousands of hours. Even a 100hp engine was running at 200-300rpm. Transitioning to high speed diesels engines was happening in the 1930s but it was taking time. People knew the advantages of diesel engines in fuel economy and range, safety, and low maintenance (including freedom from ignition troubles). The trouble was making practical/reliable high-speed diesels that could compete with gasoline engines on a power to weight basis (and this means the weight of the engine plus fuel for a given trip) and as diesels got lighter some of the reliability went away. They did sort it out, but the late 1930s diesels were in a state of evolution.
The US navy decided in 1933-34 to used diesel engines in all ships boats and many harbor launches. They adopted 3 engines designed and built by Buda to replace many of the existing gasoline engines. The Buda engines were licensed to the Norfolk navy yard which had been building gasoline boat engines. One specification from the late 20s called for a power to weight ratio of 27.5 lbs per HP so we can see how far off even a boat engine was from a 1920-30 tank engine. Things improved tremendously during the 1930s and diesels really benefited from improved materials. It was only in the last few years of the 30s that diesel tank engines became viable and high-power diesels (350-450hp) were really on the edge.
Soviets accepted a lower engine life than some other countries did. Test engines often last longer than service engines do. Needing to ship spare engines 1/2 way around the world can also change expectations about engine life.
 
Soviets accepted a lower engine life than some other countries did. Test engines often last longer than service engines do. Needing to ship spare engines 1/2 way around the world can also change expectations about engine life.
What was the bigger Soviet problem: with transmissions, or with big diesels?
Do we have some firm data on their engine life as the war progressed?
 
Somewhere . . . on the internet . . . I ran across a translated Soviet document covering the reliability of the early T-34. It was the minutes of a meeting between various plant managers, engineers, and Stalin himself (I think). IIRC the focus seemed to be mainly on increasing the reliability of the transmission and final drive. There were serious problems with the metallurgy and manufacturing process.

There are several documents & articles covering the reliability of the Soviet tanks over at "Tank Archives"

Development of the V-2 engine from pre-war "T-34's Heart on Trial"

A wishlist of development for the T-34 (& other AFVs) from 1940 "Wishlist"

A more detailed wishlist for the T-34 from Nov'40 "The New T-34"

Development of the T-34 re reliability & such, from 1939 onward "The Myth of the Disposable T-34"

Production trials in 1940 "Production Trials"

V-2 & Main Clutch reliability -1941 "Weakest Link"

T-34-76 reliability vs other types including UK & US types early-1943 "Reliability and Repairs"

T-34 (& KV-1) tests in the US druing 1943 "Aberdeen: T-34 and KV-1 Test"

T-34-85 reliability as of 1945 "T-34-85 Reliability, 1945"

There was a US analysis of a captured T-34-85 in Korea (again on the DTIC website). It was found that for the most part the manufacturing quality standards were as good as those of the US made tanks.

I may have downloaded the minutes from the meeting and the US analysis of the T-34-85. If so I will post them in this thread.
 
Last edited:
If you are willing to put up with a translator, I'm pretty sure T-34info.ru talks about engine reliability as well.

If we go by what the Soviets were doing I'm pretty sure that transmissions were a bigger issue during the war, as both KV-1's and T-34's initial transmissions were identified as problematic and replacements designed (introduced on KV-1S, IS-1 and later T-34s), and even then these improved transmissions were not the best the USSR was looking for.

The Soviet engine industry was rather small and inexperienced at the time and many engines other than V-2 failed, so initial models were going to be rough no matter what design they would opt for. At least, the V-2 was specifically designed for tanks/military purposes and embodied more optimal features than commercial engines, so it competed quite well in performance with Western diesels and even some underoptimized petrol engines.
 
What was the bigger Soviet problem: with transmissions, or with big diesels?
Do we have some firm data on their engine life as the war progressed?
Soviets (and everybody else) had problems with engines and transmissions and transmission can be further broken down in several subsections. Main clutch, transmission gears, steering set up (many different types) and steering clutches and steering brakes and the final drives/final gear reduction before track sprocket. Soviet peak problem area may very well have changed a number of times over the years.
Matilda tanks for instance were rather reliable if drive in straight lines, but you can't do that in real life. The main clutch was good and the transmission itself was good. The problem (or the main one) was declutching in inside track and then re-engaging the steering clutch on that side for every turn or correction to the turn that was made. Think driving a car and every time you adjust the steering wheel while going around a curve you have either disengage and re-engage a clutch or slip the clutch. Some units in NA resorted to pulling their Matidas around corners with heavy trucks to save the steering clutches for combat.

This a problem for different vehicles and for different steering setups. The simple clutch and brake system used on things from the Bren carrier to T-34 (and larger tanks) and the heavier the tanks got the more problems the system had. NATO in the late 50s or early 60s estimated that around 1/3 of all T-54s would be immobilized after 3 days of road marches due to broken steering clutches. Perhaps this was wishful thinking? On the other had the Soviets did outnumber the western tank force by several times so perhaps it was part of the Soviet strategy. Lots and lots of cheap tanks so that there would be enough to get the job done 3-4 days into the battle rather than relying on fewer, more expensive tanks.

If the Soviet big diesels last 150 hours and the transmissions only last 75 to 100 hours the Diesels don't really show up as the problem unless a deeper dive is taken.
The US 1951 engineering study provided by ThomasP raises several questions. T-34-85s were supposed to have 5 forward gears but the analysis only describes 4 gears.
It also says that gears 2 & 3 were reversed (using the same number of teeth) rather than slightly different gears used an early example. The gears were not really identical as dimensions on the hubs were not identical. It does note that the transmission appeared to be on verge of failure with worn and damaged gears and quantity of steel pieces in the bottom. This is attributed to grinding gears on the non-synchromesh transmission. It is a US analysis, and the US was moving to automatic transmissions and torque converters. Very few ground gears, but they had other problems. The Soviet transmissions were not going to suffer from a clogged valve in the shifting body in the transmission.
Many 1950 (and early 60s) NATO tanks broke down fairly often. Finding figures on minor breakdowns vs major (bad fan belt vs cracked cylinder head) is hard. It was a major push to developing power packs that could be changes in a few hours with the aid of crane. Some late tanks could have their power packs change in under an hour. Now how many spare powerpacks does a tank battalion have in stock and how many repair vehicles with 5 ton cranes are available?

The Soviet V-2 engine in T-34 seems to have done fairly well, how may tanks lasted long enough to need new engines?
Same engine uprated to give more power in the KV and Stalin tanks had more problems, it was also driven harder. Operated nearer to full throttle more often.
Soviet transmissions also caused problems for the engines. Due to the difficulty in shift the transmissions (legendary hammer for the driver) they spent a lot more time in 2nd & 3rd
gear than the designers intended. Many tanks only used 1st gear for starting on a hill or in poor ground conditions. Not using high gear on road marches (the column was traveling at a speed that 3rd gear could deal with) meant more wear on the engine and less than "book" range. It did mean that the driver was not trying to shift on minor up grades or if he was getting tool close to the vehicle in front.
 
The US 1951 engineering study provided by ThomasP raises several questions. T-34-85s were supposed to have 5 forward gears but the analysis only describes 4 gears.
It also says that gears 2 & 3 were reversed (using the same number of teeth) rather than slightly different gears used an early example. The gears were not really identical as dimensions on the hubs were not identical. It does note that the transmission appeared to be on verge of failure with worn and damaged gears and quantity of steel pieces in the bottom. This is attributed to grinding gears on the non-synchromesh transmission. It is a US analysis, and the US was moving to automatic transmissions and torque converters. Very few ground gears, but they had other problems. The Soviet transmissions were not going to suffer from a clogged valve in the shifting body in the transmission.
A perhaps interesting story from 1990-91, when I was a mere young conscript in Ljubljana suburb, in (not only) today's Slovenia. Turbulent times, but the real storm was just brewing, with Slovenes openly saying 'we want out'.
There were many old tanks just under the tin 'roofs', the T-34-85s with the .50 BMG strapped to the commander's hatch position, as well as the Pattons. Every now and then, these tanks were being dismantled there, and parts were shiped as scrap to, I think, steel works. I' recall my commander (captain 1st class then) complaining about the Pattons being destroyed, since "these are so easy to drive, one can go downtown Ljubljana easy-peasy, need-be"; and "probably the Slovenes love us destroying the good gear".
1st time I've read a real manual for a tank - Patton - ever.

Another thing: the old ww2/post-war tanker, also from Slovenia, was commenting that the driving the Stuart tank felt like a taxy cab after the Soviet tanks he drove, that were akin to the agricultural tanks in his words.

Not to rain on the Soviet tanks' parade, their T-34-85 were the welcome addtion to the firepower in the 1990s, even on the rugged Dalamtian and Bosnian terrain.
 
re
The US 1951 engineering study provided by ThomasP raises several questions. T-34-85s were supposed to have 5 forward gears but the analysis only describes 4 gears.

The early T-34 had a 4-speed transmission. A 5-speed (dual?) planetary transmission was introduced on at least one production line in late'42, and subsequently to the other production lines. This was supposed to fix the reliability issues with the earlier transmission. (If my information is correct, at about the same time or maybe a little later the KV-1 received a new 6-speed transmission of similar design to the new transmission on the T-34, replacing the earlier 5-speed.)
 
anything beats nothing and many soldiers did near miracles with what the high command (or circumstances) gave them.

We often forget the level of industrialization of the Soviet Union in the 1930s.
Much of the machinery they were building tanks and guns with was imported from the US and other countries in the 1930s for tractor factories or trucks. Lend lease included thousands of lathes and milling machines and drill presses. The Soviets often built what they could, not what they wanted. Lend lease also included drill bits, milling machine cutters and other expendable machine tooling in addition to actual machines.

I will note that the famous Australian Sentinel tank used the American M-3 transmission as a prototype but converted it to crash box instead of synchronized because Australia did not have ability to manufacture the synchro rings.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back