- Thread starter
- #301
I think that your two points - Gladiator and J.22 - are well made.Going back to the overall OP the question becomes why would you choose a light fighter instead of a full blown fighter?
When compared with 'full size' fighters like the Hurricane or Spitfire, their performance and firepower, the Gladiator tick a lot of the boxes as a light fighter. IMO, it's purchase process underscores the wishes of the AM to have it's bases covered in case the new fighters and/or their new engines suffer a big delay, if not cancellation. Or, if another spec misses the target by a land mile, as it happened with the Defiant.
It was probably too bad that a small monoplane with retractable U/C was not also designed (hopefuly by my favorite company: DH, as many times before), powered by either Mercury or Kestrel. The J.22 example points out to the relatively high-performing fighter on modest power, and not everyone has access to the many hundreds, let alone thousands of Merlins, Sabres, DBs or R-2800s.
There is no point in over-did it.These are all forced decisions in different ways. Ceteris paribus the full power fighter will always be at an advantage but that does not necessarily mean that a good light fighter cannot be useful at all. Using grossly underpowered engines cannot be compensated for by bolting on less aeroplane and never works.
One will never make a reasonable fighter around the Argus engines, or around the 1-row Wasp, or around the Gipsy 12, or around any of the 500-ish HP engines. But once the 1000-1200 HP engines are in series production, access to the 750-850 Hp engines will be much easier, both for the domestic and foreign needs. Once the 1300-1600 HP engines are available for the mainstream fighters, up-engining the 750-850 HP light fighter with a 1000-1200 HP engine should not be a long shot.
A 950 cu in engine, or a bit bigger than half of the R-1820, or about 40% of the Hercules? Assumes decent supercharging, and 2-speed S/C drive - probably 700-750 HP with 145 or 150 grade fuel for post-war use? 600-650 HP with 130 grade?I do still wonder what might have been if the Bristol Aquila had reached later Hercules or even Taurus levels of specific power in a Vickers Venom……