swampyankee
Chief Master Sergeant
- 4,324
- Jun 25, 2013
According to one of Stan Miley's papers, in-line and opposed cylinder aircooled engines generally have greater cooling drag than radials, as they tend to have more flow separation in the engine's cooling flow. Of course, with any air-cooled engines designing a system with low cooling drag is hard. It's not that much easier to get low cooling drag with a liquid-cooled engine. In both, you have to slow the air down before it goes across the heat transfer surface and try to get it to match or exceed the local air velocity where the cooling air is exhausted. This is easier with radiators, because you can put the radiator remotely. With air-cooling, the engine is the radiator. A radiator would probably need about the same surface area as an air-cooled engine of similar size, because air -- to which all piston engines are rejecting a lot of their waste heat -- is a crappy heat transfer medium, and the heat is rejected at about the same temperature for both.The air-coooled inlines/Vees for the aircraft.
In order for these to make any sense, they need to be big enough. No point in inisting on the new, relatively fancy and expensive V12 engines doing 450-600 HP for trainers, since that power bracket can be covered with small and cheap radials or simpler inlines. I'd suggest that the starting point is a radial engine with big cylinders, like the Jupiter/Pegasus/Bramo 323 and their lineage, Hornet/BMW 132, R-1820 and it's Soviet siblings, or R-2600.
A mildly supercharged V6 version on 87 oct fuel should be already making 400-500 HP by the second half of the 1930s, the V8 another ~150 HP, and the V12 800-1000 HP (note that I'm traing to stay on the conservative side here wrt. the power; the very early R-2600s did 1500 HP, for comparison, and the Pegasus did 900-1000 HP already by 1938 and 87 oct). Use the V6 on trainers, V8s on transports, V12s on the actual combat aircraft?
By the time the war started, and the engines are improved, the basic 9 cyl engines all do about 1000 HP down low and 800-880 HP at ~4 km; all on 87 oct. That should transpose into the V6s doing 660-670 HP, V8s doing close to 900 HP (~750 HP at 4 km), and the V12s being at 1200 HP (and about 1100 HP at ~4 km). With 100 oct, where available and at least while looking at the later Mercury and R-1820 versions, this goes by another 20% up, albeit on a bit lower altitude).
Note that all of this is still with the legacy superchargers, that were summarily bad on the 9 cyl engines of the day.
What will be the shortcomings? The V12 will be quite long, even if not as long as the Mikulin's engines or the DB 603. Without the liquid cooling system, the installed weight should not be problem. The indifferent I-F Delta did 750 HP at altitude with 87 oct and at 510 kg; a sole V12 doing 1000 HP at altitude should still be under 700 kg? Engine cooling will need to be well designed, I prefer the way D-H cooled their Gipsy 12, FWIW.
Advantage vs. the radials of the day should be lower drag (= good for speed and mileage), better visibility over the nose, the short stacks for extra exhaust thrust can be easily copied from the liquid-cooled V12s. A V8 might compete vs. the R9s as a fighter engine, the V12 against the big R14s. The radials should still be a bit lighter, and certainly cheaper to make.
By mid-/late-war, and again by looking at what the high oct fuel and/or ADI did for the radials, together with improvements on engines themselves, the power might grow to 1500-1700 HP on the V12s.
As for weight, the crankshaft is a major contributor to an engine's weight.