Best non-US remote gun turret of WW2?

Admiral Beez

1st Lieutenant
6,350
6,297
Oct 21, 2019
Toronto, Canada
We all know of the remote turrets on the B-29 and the P-61. What of the other countries? Who fielded the best non-US remote aircraft gun turret in WW2? By remote I mean the gunner is not directly sighting along the gun, but is instead using a separate observation station to control the guns.

Here’s the remote turret on the Messerschmitt Me 210.

ornisse-Stab-II.ZG26-(3U+CC)-RAF-Cosford-Museum-05.jpg
 
Last edited:

PAT303

Staff Sergeant
1,259
776
Dec 31, 2018
I'm going to give my two cents, British aircraft are often criticized for only having .303's but I feel that sitting upright and comfortable behind the guns far surpasses any advantage of bigger guns in awkward turrets,


1662936675153.png

1662936744080.png
 

FLYBOYJ

"THE GREAT GAZOO"
Staff
Mod
28,097
8,667
Apr 9, 2005
Colorado, USA
I'm going to give my two cents, British aircraft are often criticized for only having .303's but I feel that sitting upright and comfortable behind the guns far surpasses any advantage of bigger guns in awkward turrets,


View attachment 686501
View attachment 686502
And you're comparing one of the better British gun turrets to a "gun position" rather than a powered turret, in the B-17F. This was later improved upon

1662938462111.png
 

Greyman

Tech Sergeant
1,767
1,384
Jan 31, 2009
Would devices like the Lancaster's under-turret and rear turret be considered "remote turrets"?

No.

The British didn't have any remotely-controlled turrets out of the prototype stage by the time the war ended.
  1. RAE system (Lancaster test bed, I assume intended for Lincoln)
  2. Vickers-Armstrong system (Windsor)
  3. Fraser-Nash FN 95 (Avenger test bed, intended for Spearfish)
 

EwenS

Staff Sergeant
999
1,933
Oct 19, 2021
I don’t consider the various periscope sighted turrets fitted in US or British aircraft as being “remote” mounts. The gunner was generally sat directly on top of the mounting.

I can’t think of any British designed remote gun turret that reached operational service. A few were trialled though.

FN95 for Fairey Spearfish in an Avenger.
1662961457275.jpeg


1662961507494.jpeg




Spearfish cutaway.
1662961844710.jpeg




And the remote nacelle mountings designed for the Vickers Windsor. A variant was trialled in a Warwick.

And a Boulton & Paul trial installation in a Lancaster in 1944.

1662962055753.jpeg





There was also the one fitted to the He177.

1662961780797.jpeg


And an old thread on this site about German remote turrets.

Another thread with some information about an Italian system on the P.108B that I’ve never previously noticed.

 

Greyman

Tech Sergeant
1,767
1,384
Jan 31, 2009
And a Boulton & Paul trial installation in a Lancaster in 1944.

My papers give the RAE credit for this system but Boulton Paul would seem to make more sense. Only additional info I have is the small blurb from R. Wallace Clarke's RAF Gun Turrets book (which also puts the system under Boulton Paul).

Would you happen to have anything more concrete?
 

EwenS

Staff Sergeant
999
1,933
Oct 19, 2021
My papers give the RAE credit for this system but Boulton Paul would seem to make more sense. Only additional info I have is the small blurb from R. Wallace Clarke's RAF Gun Turrets book (which also puts the system under Boulton Paul).

Would you happen to have anything more concrete?
Sorry but no. My recollection was from the R. Wallace Clarke book. And Google isn’t being my friend today beyond the illustration I posted.
 

wuzak

Captain
7,899
2,542
Jun 5, 2011
Hobart Tasmania
The CAC Ca-11 had remote turrets on its nacelles

 

Admiral Beez

1st Lieutenant
6,350
6,297
Oct 21, 2019
Toronto, Canada
Would devices like the Lancaster's under-turret and rear turret be considered "remote turrets"?
For the purposes of this thread I had in mind turrets where a remote control system acts between a gunner's observation station and the gun‘s line of sight.
The CAC Ca-11 had remote turrets on its nacelles
Good example. Reminds me of those positioned on the Piaggio P.108’s engine nacelles.

p108%2Bremote%2Bcontrol%2Bturrets.jpg


There's a previous discussion on this here German Remote Controlled Turrets
 
Last edited:

Thumpalumpacus

1st Lieutenant
6,187
8,701
Feb 5, 2021
Tejas
I don’t consider the various periscope sighted turrets fitted in US or British aircraft as being “remote” mounts. The gunner was generally sat directly on top of the mounting.

Of course they're not going to sit too far away. You also have examples like the belly turrets on a B-29 where the spotting stations are indeed a ways away. That's remote enough for me.
 

Admiral Beez

1st Lieutenant
6,350
6,297
Oct 21, 2019
Toronto, Canada
The Me323, BV222 and He177 were some that had remote turrets but they didn't seem to be very effective against attackers.
The B-29 had an analog computer running its guidance. I have to expect the Germans and Italians had no such tech, and instead there was some sort of offset gunsight for which a set range had to be dialed in for where gunner's aim and turret fire converged.
 

Users who are viewing this thread