Dogfight Involving 125 Indian and Pakistani Fighters

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

MIflyer

Captain
7,764
16,708
May 30, 2011
Cape Canaveral
It appears that neither side left its own airspace but did long range air-to-air missile duels.

More than 125 Indian and Pakistani fighter jets reportedly engaged in a dogfight lasting more than an hour in the early hours of Wednesday, according to an unnamed Pakistani security source cited by CNN.

If confirmed, it would mark one of the largest aerial battles since World War II.

The alleged operation, referred to as "Operation Sindhoor," is said to have taken place entirely within the airspace of both countries. CNN reports that long-range missiles were exchanged from distances exceeding 100 miles, with neither side breaching the other's airspace. The source noted it was due to a 2019 incident where an Indian pilot was shot down and publicly showcased in Pakistan, which heightened tensions for both nations.

Meanwhile, Pakistani officials claim their forces shot down five Indian aircraft during the confrontation, though no physical evidence has been presented, and the claims remain unverified by international media. India has not officially responded but has previously accused Pakistan of spreading misinformation.
 
Is it really a "dogfight" if it's a BVR missile lobbing contest?
There was an actual concept from around 1972 that used a C-5 fitted with a large number of AIM-47 missiles. The AIM-47 was sort of an early AIM-54 Phoenix and was proposed to arm the F-12A. The AIM-47 had a 100 miles range and the "FC-5" would fire barrages of them from long range. I guess the FC-5 would have a suitable radar, and it sure did have the room for it. I'd guess they would use that big "airliner" section aft of the wing and above the cargo compartment for the firing room.

But it sure sounds more like a job for the IM-99 BOMARC to me.

Screenshot 2025-05-10 at 22-07-19 im-99 bomarc missile at DuckDuckGo.png
 
It appears that neither side left its own airspace but did long range air-to-air missile duels.

More than 125 Indian and Pakistani fighter jets reportedly engaged in a dogfight lasting more than an hour in the early hours of Wednesday, according to an unnamed Pakistani security source cited by CNN.

If confirmed, it would mark one of the largest aerial battles since World War II.

The alleged operation, referred to as "Operation Sindhoor," is said to have taken place entirely within the airspace of both countries. CNN reports that long-range missiles were exchanged from distances exceeding 100 miles, with neither side breaching the other's airspace. The source noted it was due to a 2019 incident where an Indian pilot was shot down and publicly showcased in Pakistan, which heightened tensions for both nations.

Meanwhile, Pakistani officials claim their forces shot down five Indian aircraft during the confrontation, though no physical evidence has been presented, and the claims remain unverified by international media. India has not officially responded but has previously accused Pakistan of spreading misinformation.
There can be no such thing as a 125-plane dogfight!
At least in context of the 400 members I dealt with when secretary of the American Fighter Aces Assn.
DOGFIGHT requires maneuvering for position advantage in a single cube of airspace. At least that's been the historic definition for more than a century. Shooting long-range missiles at one another does not
repeat not
qualify as a Dogfight
regardless of how many missile launch "platforms" might be involved.
 
There can be no such thing as a 125-plane dogfight!
At least in context of the 400 members I dealt with when secretary of the American Fighter Aces Assn.
DOGFIGHT requires maneuvering for position advantage in a single cube of airspace. At least that's been the historic definition for more than a century. Shooting long-range missiles at one another does not
repeat not
qualify as a Dogfight
regardless of how many missile launch "platforms" might be involved.

I think most here understand that by now.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back