Inaccurate

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

Also, the dive brakes on the SBD made it dive slower than Zeros. Zeros would overshoot.
 
I'm not sure since I didn't see Midway but some reviewer said that they show Lt.Cmdr Leslie as the lone survivor of the torpedo attack. Wrong man, wrong squadron.
 
Well, if you ask this question about modern version of it, Iran Iraq war of 80's, the answer would be every single movie that is made about that war by Iran.

But regard to WW2, IMO, Saving Private Ryan is a candidate.

However, I personally am a fan of Russian / Soviet war movies, rather than Hollywood made ones.
 
To the best of my knowledge, no A-36 was ever used in a war movie (as either German or otherwise).
In the movie "30 Seconds over Tokyo", there is a brief appearance of an early Mustang in the early part of the movie that was either a P-51A or an A-36, but that was it.
 
Regarding 'Saving Private Ryan' I agree both from a historical and a film making standpoint. The film 'The Longest Day" came out in 1962. I simply cannot understand why the film makers did not use that as a guide or template to start from in making SPR. As far as accuracy of action is concerned, the first scene while accurate enough for modern film making still suffers from some details. The only other accurate action scene is the ending, if it is remembered that the actual numbers of troops involved have been dramatically reversed.
 

Users who are viewing this thread