Question about drag: wing tip tanks, vs. underslung tanks? (2 Viewers)

tomo pauk

Creator of Interesting Threads
15,912
5,848
Joined
Apr 3, 2008
The wing tip tanks were somewhat popular during the cold war, while the underslung drop tanks were popular like forever.
In the context of ww2 and the speeds & drag of the era, how big - if any - might be the difference in drag? Assumes just the location where the drop tank is attached is changed, plus there is no underwing pylon; let's forget the under-fuselage and other drop-tank placements for now.

drgondog drgondog & Aeroweanie Aeroweanie mostly, but any good infor from other people is welcomed, of course.
 
The tuna tanks on the 310 act like end boards to control spanwise flow. Later upswept tanks performed more like the winglets in modern airliners.
These are apples and oranges to underslung tanks, as most of them can be jettisoned for combat and tip tanks are on to stay.
 
Interesting thing about the F-80 and T-33A tip tanks. They featured a pressure regulator that reduced engine bleed air pressure down to 13 PSI. But the tip tanks had "sniffle" valves that acted like the pressure caps on automobile radiators. If the tank pressure got too high, then the sniffle valve would open and allow some air and a little liquid to bleed overboard.

But everything has tolerances, both the regulators and the sniffle valves. And a long standing problem even recognized in the F-80A-1 flight manual, was tanks that fed unevenly as a result. If one tank was about full and the other one ended up about empty, level flight became difficult and landing became highly hazardous. 230 gallons in a tip tank equates to over 1300 lb.

In 1977 OC-ALC got into an argument with SM-ALC over this long standing problem. SM-ALC said that OC-ALC should tighten up the tolerances on the regulator output. OC-ALC replied that the sniffle valves had a range of operating pressures and the answer was to be sure to match the two sniffle valves operating pressure. Of course, the SM-ALC solution required no work on their part, and probably would do no good anyway. The OC-ALC solution required no work on their part and probably would fix the problem. It was more than a bit absurd that two USAF organization were still disagreeing on how to fix a problem that had been around for over 30 years.

Hawk T-33-P1sm.jpg
 
I agree with the comments regarding 'end plate' and induced drag reductions. As always there are trade offs.

Droppable tanks are superior with respect to high(er) roll rates essential in ACM. While producing higher drag on pylons, as well as possible airflow interference issues at low speed (with landing gear), the drop tanks are jettisonable - both reducing weight of unused fuel and parasite drag at high speeds compared to end pylons.

There is no question that tip tanks are superior with respect to drag at cruise speeds.
 
IMO - better for tactical aircraft for the reasons I stated about roll.
Yes, certainly drop them off before combat.
 
drgondog probably knows much better than I do but are there strength considerations for using tip tanks?
The same weight on the tip of the wing needs a stronger wing structure than the same weight located 1/2 way out on the wing?
As aircraft speeds increased the wing structure had to be made stronger to handle the flight loads so perhaps the later high speed wings had enough strength either way?
Some fighters were speed restricted when carrying drop tanks. Structure or mounting point/rack restriction?
 
drgondog probably knows much better than I do but are there strength considerations for using tip tanks?
The same weight on the tip of the wing needs a stronger wing structure than the same weight located 1/2 way out on the wing?
As aircraft speeds increased the wing structure had to be made stronger to handle the flight loads so perhaps the later high speed wings had enough strength either way?
Some fighters were speed restricted when carrying drop tanks. Structure or mounting point/rack restriction?
Yes. Particularly for high angle of attack loads such as pull out from a dive. Not to mention potential torsional loads created by tip tanks at various CL.
 
drgondog probably knows much better than I do but are there strength considerations for using tip tanks?
The same weight on the tip of the wing needs a stronger wing structure than the same weight located 1/2 way out on the wing?
As aircraft speeds increased the wing structure had to be made stronger to handle the flight loads so perhaps the later high speed wings had enough strength either way?
Some fighters were speed restricted when carrying drop tanks. Structure or mounting point/rack restriction?
I would certainly not suggest that the biggest drop tanks are to be carried on the tips.
On a P-51, P-38 and P-40, perhaps the 75 US gal type would be still practical there, the Spitfire start out with the 45 imp gal type? German fighters with the 66gal/300L tank, the P-47 with the 75 gal and move to 108/110 US gal tank?
It should free the belly or the wing position for a good-sized bomb(s) to be carried, and without the bombs the drag of the set-up would've been lower both when the tanks are attached, and without them since there is no extra rack present.

Yes. Particularly for high angle of attack loads such as pull out from a dive. Not to mention potential torsional loads created by tip tanks at various CL.
Hopefully, the people will be jetisonning the drop tanks before the combat, dives etc.
 
Speed loss on the different payload configuration and type of racks on the Fw 190:

tanksracks.jpg

The best of the lot is the belly rack ETC 501, with speed loss when installed being 12 km/h (on the bottom of the pic). The best wing racks cost 18 km/h for the pair; the worst 40 km/h(!). Obviously, the speed loss with the racks carrying the payload (doh), is substantial, up to 90 km/h if three racks are carrying stuff.
The much higher drag will also cost the range, to nobody's surprise.

On the US aircraft, the P-51D and later were with perhaps the best of the lot, cost of only 4 mph for a pair; the earlier Mustangs' racks were of different design with cost being 12 mph.
 
Some Mustangs with tip tanks:
- navalized P-51H as pitched to the USN
- the 'Cavalier', post-war project with the turboprop in the nose

The B-26 'Counter Invader' with tip tanks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back