Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
Which leaves me to wonder what their levels of manpower are in strategic areas like their border with China, their far-eastern bases and garrisons as well as the western (European) border.Nearly Russia's entire army is in Ukraine, suffering '1st World War levels of attrition,' U.K. says
Nearly Russia's entire army is in Ukraine, suffering '1st World War levels of attrition,' U.K. sayswww.yahoo.com
Which leaves me to wonder what their levels of manpower are in strategic areas like their border with China, their far-eastern bases and garrisons as well as the western (European) border.
They must be keeping some regular Army at those locations, but have they drawn from those locations to bolster their units in Ukraine?
And I haven't seen any mention of Naval Infantry being deployed in theater, either.
Yeah, that is a bit confusing.Here is something, though how do you refer to something as elite and recently mobilized in the same sentence?
Elite Russian Marine Unit 'Nearly Destroyed' Near Ukraine’s Vuhledar - The Moscow Times
An elite Russian naval infantry unit made up of mostly mobilized troops has lost nearly all its troops in fighting near the eastern Ukrainian town of Vuhledar, Russian media reported Monday, citing one of the survivors.www.themoscowtimes.com
Going along similar thoughts. There seems to be a general agreement that Russia has lost more than half of their tanks and armoured vehicles. Working on the basis that these on average would have been the more modern and up to date bits of kit, the general quality of a Russian unit must have fallen quite considerably.Which leaves me to wonder what their levels of manpower are in strategic areas like their border with China, their far-eastern bases and garrisons as well as the western (European) border.
They must be keeping some regular Army at those locations, but have they drawn from those locations to bolster their units in Ukraine?
And I haven't seen any mention of Naval Infantry being deployed in theater, either.
I saw one vid and thought those tanks have just blown tracks and wheels, and could be repaired by Ukraine if they're reachable.I am sure we have all seen the video of the tanks and APC's driving around mindlessly in a minefield getting blown up one after another which seems to have supported this fall in effectiveness.
Going along similar thoughts. There seems to be a general agreement that Russia has lost more than half of their tanks and armoured vehicles. Working on the basis that these on average would have been the more modern and up to date bits of kit, the general quality of a Russian unit must have fallen quite considerably.
I am sure we have all seen the video of the tanks and APC's driving around mindlessly in a minefield getting blown up one after another which seems to have supported this fall in effectiveness.
You can see why Russia is depending on its artillery, it seems to be one of the few aces in its hands. After all it doesn't take a lot of training to load and fire a cannon.
I am not so sure. If they keep probing and find or make a weak spot in the Ukraine defence, and then throw everything at it, I think that there is a fair chance that Russia will make a breakthrough. How well they will be able to exploit it, now that's the question. It will depend I think on how well Ukraine can respond.One implication of this is that Russia cannot win with a quick offensive any more.
I am not so sure. If they keep probing and find or make a weak spot in the Ukraine defence, and then throw everything at it, I think that there is a fair chance that Russia will make a breakthrough. How well they will be able to exploit it, now that's the question. It will depend I think on how well Ukraine can respond.
I really hope that your right on thisI suspect the Ukrainians are husbanding forces for their own offensive, to launch once they feel this Russian move has culminated.
I am no 'expert' but I have been lurking since December '21. And I tell you proudly, This site has been amazing in the breadth and depth of aggregated material and personal insight and first hand experience it has provided. This site .... and BBC news.In this 2022 review of the war, there are a good many points made and I find it interesting that most opinions mirror what has been discussed here in this thread.
Maybe the experts have been lurking and taking notes?
2022 REVIEW: Why has Vladimir Putin’s Ukraine invasion gone so badly wrong?
Vladimir Putin hoped his invasion of Ukraine would result in a quick and historic victory. Instead, he ends 2022 with Russia's reputation as a military superpower in tatters. Why has the invasion of Ukraine gone so badly wrong?www.atlanticcouncil.org
Yup. That boat sailed (with the Mockba)One implication of this is that Russia cannot win with a quick offensive any more.
After all it doesn't take a lot of training to load and fire a cannon.