Allied reaction to the Me 262 swept wings (7 Viewers)

Again great info but I have problems believing that 7 prototype aircraft had "used" 262 parts on them. Perhaps remanufactured parts reversed engineered from the original hardware. I know this was still in the post war period but if this was actually done it was beyond risk, it crossed the line into stupidity.

BTW, excellent site!
''

It may go back to a time when engineers still had a feel and sense of materials as a skilled tradesman might. I don't immagine that the slat mechanism was all that difficult to inspect or complicated a mechanism.
 
I find it pretty incredible that the put used components on the first 7 aircraft, when there was only 3 prototypes. The first production F-86's flew in 1948, and the first 4 had slats parts adapted from a Me262?? From a wing with a different sweep angle, span, and NACA profile.
 
The first seven aircraft used the German design not the actual parts. This often gets misrepresented as a literal swopping of parts from one wing to another!
Slat locks were a major modification introduced by the US engineers. The slats could be locked closed to ensure that asymmetric deployment did not occur. The lock was linked with the undercarriage to ensure that the slats were unlocked when the undercarriage was deployed for landing. None of this was a feature of the Me262 whose slats were entirely independent and automatic.
It is true to say only that the Me262 slats provided the basis for the american system.
The modified lockable slats were installed on the first 159 fighters and the locks were removed in early 1949 when an entirely new slat system was incorporated into the fighter.
Cheers
Steve
 
''It may go back to a time when engineers still had a feel and sense of materials as a skilled tradesman might. I don't immagine that the slat mechanism was all that difficult to inspect or complicated a mechanism.
Sorry pal, but I can tell you that no engineer in his or her right mind would allow parts to be placed on a production aircraft from an unknown source, especially from an enemy combatant. I could tell you that even in that era Quality Assurance managers wold have hung any engineer who would even had thought of that by his nuts in the office of the company president! In an R&D world maybe, but once in production everything changes. Back then MiL-Q-9858 was still young but very much enforced on the PRODUCTION shop floor.

BTW - the ONLY absolute way the strength of those parts would have been verified was by destroying them either during a tensile pull or during a spectra analysis.

The first seven aircraft used the German design not the actual parts. This often gets misrepresented as a literal swopping of parts from one wing to another!
Slat locks were a major modification introduced by the US engineers. The slats could be locked closed to ensure that asymmetric deployment did not occur. The lock was linked with the undercarriage to ensure that the slats were unlocked when the undercarriage was deployed for landing. None of this was a feature of the Me262 whose slats were entirely independent and automatic.
It is true to say only that the Me262 slats provided the basis for the american system.
The modified lockable slats were installed on the first 159 fighters and the locks were removed in early 1949 when an entirely new slat system was incorporated into the fighter.
Cheers
Steve
Thanks for the info Steve
 
Last edited:
AFAIK there were papers written about swept wings with regards to trans sonic flight prior to WW2. Swept wings before WW2 were used shift C/G. Look at the XP-55
The first to propose swept wings for transonic speeds was 18-year old Frenchman Nicolas Payen. He called it the avion fleche (bird arrow), gained instant fame, and built his first plane, the Fleche Volante, in 1934.
Of course, he wasn't the first to use swept wings or realize a "folded" wing is faster-even though it was terrible for that era's typical speeds. Grown engineers didn't openly discuss it, though they clearly had it in mind.
Sure, wing sweep was sometimes used to fix CoG, visibility, or stability. But we shouldn't project our own guesses onto those engineers. Yet anonimes do it!
 
[...] On swept wing research:

There were various papers on swept wings in the US and UK in the 1920s and 1930s, but, as noted above, mostly as a means of CoG management and AFAIK all of them dealt with low speed. Swept wings had appeared on quite a number of aircraft prior to WW2 and the advent of the various German swept wing aircraft during the war period.

The link between swept wings and supersonic air speed came in the mid-1930s in Germany. Adolph Busemann is credited with the idea of using swept wings for controllability of supersonic airflow, notably presenting a paper at the October 1935 Volta Congress on High Speeds in Aviation. The idea was then researched in Germany, with work shifting from theoretical to practical wind tunnel work during 1939.

German research in this area was therefore 5-6 years ahead of efforts in the US by the end of the war. In the US, Robert T Jones had come up the same ideas as Busemann at the end of 1944/beginning of 1945, a decade after Busemann presented his work publicly. Jones published papers on swept wings in May and June 1945 - just a few months before the first papers on German
[...]
Jones couldn't possibly have been proposing ideas that were already well-known to everyone for a long time. In the fall of 1939, the USAAC issued a request for a new fighter design (R-40C) with a target speed of 500 mph. Two out of the three designs were swept-wing.
And not like the Me 262, whose wing sweep accidentally ended up at 16.5 degrees. The DC-2 had a 10.5 deg sweep at the quarter-chord, the XP-55 had 24.5, the XP-56 had 26, the XP-79 had 20, and the Boeing 737, for example, has 27.5. Furthermore, flight tests of such wings with laminar airfoils began in the US in 1941 (CW-24B). I should note that the airfoil for the initially straight-winged Me 262 was an US profile, adopted (according to memoirs) after studying NACA Report No. 492, published in 1934. It was a NACA airfoil. There is no trace of Busemann in the Me 262.
 
The idea of using swept wings to delay shockwave formation and reduce supersonic drag goes to Dr Adolf Bussmann in 1933.

In 1935 Mussolini organised and sponsored a lavish aerodymanics conference in Volta Italy where every German, American, British, Italian, Swiss, Austrian etc aerodynamicist of note attended. Bussmann delivered several papers. He talked over it at Dinner. People Joked with him about it. They even drew humourous swept wing aircraft with scimitor props. Every allied aerodynamicist in attendance missed it or forgot it including Eastman Joacobs who had designed the NACA 4 and 5 digit aerfoils used in allied fighters such as the Spitifre (Mitchell actually travelled to see Jacobs before choosing the NACA 4 digit series for the Spitfire) and also developed the laminar flow wings used in the Mustang. Theodore Karman a German-Jewish immigrant who worked for Junkers in WW1 and left for the USA (15 years before Hitler, he was seeking better emplyment) and became one of the USA's foremost supersonic expert also missed it.

About 1938 Dr Alber Betz of the AVA at Goettingen (a sort of German NACA) proposed to use wing sweep to allow high speed transonic flight.

In Early 1940 Ludwig Boelkow wrote a paper showing how an aircraft with 37 degree wing sweep and NACA 22012 wings could fly at Mach 0.95 and not suffer Mach tuck.

This is significant because Boelkow designed the Me 262 (lofting its wing first thing out of uni) followed by ongoing contributions. Though the Me 262's wing sweep is attributed to a C of G changes driven by bigger engines the designers definitely knew the advantages.

1940 Willy Meesersmitt lobbies succesfully for a large scale supersonics program.

The swept wing aircraft we see used in early tailess designs carry little or no depth of understanding and would not significantly raise Mach, in fact many were dangerous.

The transonic swept wing tends to have to have profiles suited to higher speed flight anyway. It also needs to be symmetrical in camber to prevent uneven shockwave formation. It also should have minimal washout (wing twist) to also prevent shockwave formation.

The toughest technical problem is over coming spanwise flow. Due to the sweep and the interation with the fueselage the airflow tends to be along the wing in the spanwise direction. The greatly increased distance of flow means there is more distance for the boundary layer to thicken, then seperate and cause a stall at the wing tips, which being at the back move the center of lift forward and cause a pitch up and further deep stall.

German research deeply investigated these phenomena and came up with several solutions
1 Slats
2 Wing fences
3 Forward Sweep (eg Ju 287 jet test bed)
4 Crescent wing (ie reducing sweep at wing tips to let spanwise flow fall of to be used on the Ar 234 crescent wing)

5 To cope with the flutter issues that were eventuating Junkers developed for the Ju 287 a way of cantilevering the engines on pods to act like pendulums that lower the resonant frequency and to counterbalance wing. Hence the pods on the B-47

Salvaged Me 262 slat hardware was in fact used in the first 7 F-86 Sabre.

Note the premature tip stall of the Curtiss XP-55 Ascender (Assender) was never solved.

Bussman came to the US under paperclip. While lecturing and explaing how showaves formed in 3d and should be viewed as pipes Richard Whitcomb had an epiphany that led to the the formulation of the Whitecombe Area Rule. While everyone else laughed Bussmann actively defended him. The Germans has in fact been well aware of this effect, Whitcomb merely defined it eloquently.

1. The conference wasn't held "in Volta"; it was named in honor of Volta. Regarding the significance of Busemann's work, one should listen to the professionals of that era, not journalists or even von Karman.
2. For example, it is well known that Messerschmitt's team used a 1934 NACA report No 492. They certainly had no intention of building a swept wing and didn't even research it. The first researchers were in the US: in 1941, Curtiss tested the CW-24B with a laminar-flow swept wing at an angle of 24.5 deg (25% MAC). Importantly, the Me 262 used outdated, symmetrical NACA airfoils, whereas Curtiss used a laminar airfoil of its own design: NACA had nothing to do with it.
3. No, Messerschmitt didn't have a supersonic program, whereas the UK did. The UK had the first supersonic wind tunnel and was ahead of Germany in turbojet development—specifically the Miles and Whittle M.52 project. Even the Gloster Meteor featured a relatively thin, massive wing with a symmetrical laminar airfoil developed by the UK's NPL (while Northrop and Messerschmitt used NACA airfoils). Notably, it is in the UK that I first see a supersonic missile featuring a delta wing, while their subsonic one had a straight wing.
4. Von Karman wasn't strictly an immigrant; he came to the private institution Caltech at the invitation of Guggenheim. He wasn't German, he was Hungarian, and he served in the Austrian army during WWI. He never worked for Junkers. He studied in Göttingen under Prandtl, and in retirement, he paid tribute to his compromised mentor in his book History of Aerodynamics. He held no positions at NACA; he was an independent consultant working for the US Army. This means he might not have even known about the progress of ongoing US projects, as he lacked the necessary clearance.
5. Forward sweep was proposed in 1944 at NAA for a jet Mustang. Von Karman worked closely with NAA specifically, and by 1944, he had already traveled to Germany to visit his old colleagues and mentor. Furthermore, NAA was formed by GM out of Fokker, where initially only German immigrants worked and German was spoken on the factory.
6. The main difficulties that stalled US development occurred at low speeds. That is precisely where the Me leading slats proved useful, whereas the US had already been researching wing sweep for longer and on actual flying prototypes.
7. Operation Paperclip is a favorite topic for conspiracy theorists. Naturally, Germans couldn't just casually enter the US in 1945—there were strict reasons and procedures for it. Often, they didn't even get jobs; instead, they toured giving lectures to boost their own popularity, or were even held under investigation.
 
<delete>
 
My comparison of early transonic aircraft wing geometries

AircraftFirst FlightAirfoil (Root / Tip)Max. Thickness Position (Root / Tip)Sweep (Leading Edge / ¼ Chord)Thickness-to-Chord Ratio (Root / Tip)Empty Wing Loading, kg/m²
Curtiss CW-24BDec 2, 1941CW 6500-0015~45%–50%~32°–33° / ~24.5°~13.6% / 13.6%~57 (33%)
1,240 kg / 21.8 m²
Me 262Jul 18, 1942NACA 00011-0.825-35 / NACA 00009-1.1-4035% / 40%18.5° / ~16.5°~10.5% / 8.6%~175 (100%)
3,800 kg / 21.7 m²
Gloster MeteorMar 5, 1943EC 1240 / EC 104040% / 40%0°~12.0% / 10.0%~106 (61%)
3,690 kg / 34.7 m²
Curtiss XP-55Jul 19, 1943CW 6500-0015~45%–50%~32°–33° / ~24.5°~13.6% / 13.6%~132 (75%)
2,882 kg / 21.8 m²
Northrop XP-56Sep 30, 1943NACA 66-018 / NACA 66-01245% / 45%~30°–32° / ~26°–28°~16.0% / 10.7%~139 (79%)
3,955 kg / 28.4 m²
Boeing 737Apr 9, 1967BAC 449/450/451 / BAC 442~35%–37% / ~38%–40%~27.5° / 25°~14.0% / 9.8%~329 (188%)
41,140 kg / 125 m²
Notes:
  • All airfoils, except for the Boeing 737, are symmetrical with an aft-shifted maximum thickness. The Boeing 737 features a modern cambered "supercritical" airfoil with a reflexed (S-shaped) trailing edge, where the thickness distribution forms a flattened upper surface.
  • The Me 262 airfoils were derived and tested for speeds up to M = 0.9 in the USA in 1932–1933. The test results were published in 1934 and 1935 in NACA Report No. 492: "Tests of 16 related airfoils at high speeds" by J. Stack and A. E. von Doenhoff. [1, 2]
  • "Laminar" airfoils are distinguished by having their maximum thickness shifted aft to 45% of the chord or more. These studies were conducted in the USA in 1939 and were therefore unknown in Germany.
  • The Meteor's wing uses an airfoil developed in the high-speed wind tunnel at the NPL (National Physical Laboratory), Great Britain, by researchers W. F. Hilton and G. A. M. Hyde in 1940.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back