Excluding pilot skill, what is the single most important factor in determining the winner of a 1 vs 1 dogfight (1 Viewer)

what is the single most important factor in determining the winner of a 1 vs 1 dogfight

  • Top speed

    Votes: 8 61.5%
  • Turn rate

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Dive rate

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Roll rate

    Votes: 1 7.7%
  • Armor and ruggedness

    Votes: 2 15.4%
  • Destructive weapons

    Votes: 3 23.1%

  • Total voters
    13

mig-31bm

Airman 1st Class
237
112
Joined
Mar 28, 2014
So in a many vs many dogfight, it seem to me that the most important characteristic of a piston fighter seem to be top speed, since you can fly aways when the enemy is at your tail and instead try to engage other unsuspecting targets instead. It is important as it allow you to dictate when and where you engage and runaways when needed. But in a 1 vs 1 duel when there is no "unsuspecting target", what would be the most important factor that determine the winner? (except for pilot skill of course, for the sake of argument, let just assume both pilot are ace level)
1- Turn rate
Extreme example: Zero
images.jpg


2- Top speed, Power to weight
Extreme example: P-51H, Spiteful XVI
IMG_5948.jpeg


3- Armor protection and ruggedness
extreme example: F6F Hellcat, P-47, FW-190D
full1.jpg


4- Destructive weapon
Extreme example Bf 110 G-4
330px-Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-377-2801-013,_Flugzeug_Messerschmitt_Me_110.jpg


5- Roll rate
Extreme example FW-190
FW-190D.png
 
Voted for top speed.

Aircraft posessing the substantial edge in top speed can force or decline fight, and even the weak-ish firepower will still bring down the fighter of the day. Cue P-51B vs. the toughest Fw 190s.
 
Your poll is missing one factor: initial position to the enemy. If you're higher than the enemy, you'll have the energy advantage, even if your airplane is slower..and you'd not do some stupid simmer action and keep your energy up instead.
I know altitude matter but I think that mostly depend on the role of the fighter and tactic rather than the spec of the aircraft
 
Voted for top speed.
Aircraft posessing the substantial edge in top speed
I'm curious, how much different in top speed can be considered substantial ?.
Take for example: Spiteful XVI top speed is 495 mph, de Havilland Hornet top speed is 475 mph. So that a different of 20 mph or 32 km/h. Would that be enough to disengage at will?
can force or decline fight, and even the weak-ish firepower will still bring down the fighter of the day. Cue P-51B vs. the toughest Fw 190s.
But If your aircraft is slower but turn faster, wouldn't that mean you will always be able to turn your nose toward the enemy once they re engage?.
Again let take Havilland Hornet vs Spiteful XVI for example, Spiteful is about 32 km/h faster. However, hornet wing loading is 217.74 kg/m2 compared to Spiteful wing loading of 231 kg/m2. That mean hornet will turn better. If the initial pass doesn't result in a decisive outcome or mutual destruction, the Hornet could potentially work its way into the Spiteful's rear after a few turns.
Assuming Spiteful didn't try to turn with Hornet and just use superior speed to disengage instead. Once spiteful come back to re engage, the situation reset into another head on pass again. They both carry 4 hispano 20 mm cannon but Hornet bigger size probably assure it able to survive more 20 mm impact than spiteful.
 
I'm curious, how much different in top speed can be considered substantial ?.
Take for example: Spiteful XVI top speed is 495 mph, de Havilland Hornet top speed is 475 mph. So that a different of 20 mph or 32 km/h. Would that be enough to disengage at will?
Seems like 30 mph was enough - so Bf109E vs. Hurricane I, Fw 190 vs. Spit V, or F4U vs Zero.
 
But If your aircraft is slower but turn faster, wouldn't that mean you will always be able to turn your nose toward the enemy once they re engage?.
See the RAF tests of Emil vs. Hur I, and the next step the British did: install then-best engine to cancel the speed gap.
Similar with Spit V - remedy vs. the 190 was the increase of speed via the better engines.
 
Last edited:
See the RAF tests of Emil vs. Hur I, and the next step the British did: install ten-best engine to cancel the speed gap.
Similar with Spit V - remedy vs. the 190 was the increase of speed via the better engines.
would you mind giving me the source please please
 
I'm curious, how much different in top speed can be considered substantial ?.
Take for example: Spiteful XVI top speed is 495 mph, de Havilland Hornet top speed is 475 mph. So that a different of 20 mph or 32 km/h. Would that be enough to disengage at will?

But If your aircraft is slower but turn faster, wouldn't that mean you will always be able to turn your nose toward the enemy once they re engage?.
Again let take Havilland Hornet vs Spiteful XVI for example, Spiteful is about 32 km/h faster. However, hornet wing loading is 217.74 kg/m2 compared to Spiteful wing loading of 231 kg/m2. That mean hornet will turn better. If the initial pass doesn't result in a decisive outcome or mutual destruction, the Hornet could potentially work its way into the Spiteful's rear after a few turns.
I just realize something, Spiteful being a short wing aircraft will roll much better than Spitfire Mark 24 (and Spitfire Mark 24 being a single engine fighter already roll much faster than Havilland Hornet). Some source seem to say that Hornet can roll at : ~70–72° per second
 
The ability of an aircraft to disengage at will. That might be climb rate or top speed or diving ability, depending on the circumstances.

The Me-262 could disengage in virtually any combat. BUT late in the war, the most likely time period for a combat, there was not a whole lot of unoccupied Germany left and they only had so much fuel on board. While the jets could run away, a fast prop job such as a P-51, could keep after them and sooner or later the Luftwaffe pilot would find a need to turn and the prop fighter could cut the corner and get a few rounds into them at long range.
 
I think one factor that very often overlooked í the ruggedness of the fighter.
The Zero was superior to the F4F-4 in speed and climb at all altitudes above 1,000 feet, and was superior in service ceiling and range. Close to sea level, with the F4F-4 in neutral blower, the two planes were equal in level speed. In a dive the two planes were equal with the exception that the Zero's engine cut out in pushovers. There was no comparison between the turning circles of the two aircraft due to the relative wing loadings and resultant low stalling speed of the Zero.
From Mikesh in Zero Fighter
A6M2 Model 21 had better speed, better climb, better ceiling, better range, tighter turning circle, more destructive weapon than the F4F-4. Yet F4F-4 still achieve facorable Kill ratio thanks to ability to absorb more punishment
 
The ability of an aircraft to disengage at will. That might be climb rate or top speed or diving ability, depending on the circumstances.

The Me-262 could disengage in virtually any combat. BUT late in the war, the most likely time period for a combat, there was not a whole lot of unoccupied Germany left and they only had so much fuel on board. While the jets could run away, a fast prop job such as a P-51, could keep after them and sooner or later the Luftwaffe pilot would find a need to turn and the prop fighter could cut the corner and get a few rounds into them at long range.
I think this worth take a note when they tested the slow Ki-100 against the faster Ki-84
"Aeroplane" November 2005, "Ki-100 fighter Database" p. 61-77.

Textual quote : P. 76:

"At these schools, the cream of the IJAAF's instructors, all very experienced combat pilots, would give their opinion on the new fighter (Ki-100). Almost all the Akeno instructors were graduates of the 54th Class of the Army Air Academy and also highly-qualified sentai commanders in their own right.

During March and April they would fly the Ki-100 in comparison tests against the most capable Japanese fighter then in service, the Ki-84 "Frank". After extensive testing the conclusion drawn by the Akeno (Akeno flight school) pilots left little to the imagination.

In short, it stated that given equally skilled pilots, the Ki-100 (585 km/h) would ALWAYS win a fight with the Ki-84 (640-660 km/h) in any one-to-one combat. They further added that in a combat situation with up to three Ki-84s, the Ki-100 pilot could still develop the battle to his advantage.

The results of the evaluations at the Hitachi school (separate series of tests) were just as clear-cut. Captain Yasuro Mazaki and captain Toyoshia Komatso, both graduates of the 54th class, developed the combat evaluation situations for the new fighter, and in order to give an unbiased opinion of the aircraft, they swapped aircraft after each engagement and attempted combat from the opposite standpoint.

In the first combat the Ki-100 was flown against a single Ki-84, with the Ki-100 winning outright.

Mazaki stated: "When we entered combat with the Ki-100 taking the height advantage, the Ki-100 won every time. Even with an altitude disadvantage, the Ki-100 could hold down the Ki-84 in two or three climbs during the exercise."

He added that the Ki-84 was "only superior to the Ki-100 in diving speed. The Ki-100 was much better in the turn and while climbing."
 
IMHO, regarding timeframe and technology progression that your question is about, I'd say I agree with tomo pauk tomo pauk . I believe from options in your poll, Speed is most important one, just imagine being sole remaining after a devastitanig aerial combat, in a badly damaged aircraft, you steel need speed to reach at least a "safe" location, either to try to land or eject. Surely you'll preffer to land as close as possible to friendly units in the area, or in a an area under overall friendly control.
 
Yet F4F-4 still achieve facorable Kill ratio thanks to ability to absorb more punishment
The rugged nature of the Wildcat was a feature but the pilots learned to avoid engaging the Zero except under favorable circumstances and found out about the deteriorating maneuverability of the Zero at the higher speeds. By the way, the Oscar pilots in the battles near Guadalcanal found the performance and pilot skill of their F4F opponents to be a rude shock.
 
This might be of interest. IMO it is quite telling in that any large advantage in one of the maneuver categories translates into a major advantage in dogfighting. It does not cover armour, ruggedness, or armament. I transcribed it from an AFDU report (I think) covering various aircraft.

Maximum speeds, VNE, & TTH according to the Air Ministry Aircraft Data Sheets:

Spitfire Mk XIV_____465 mph___26,000 ft
(5-blade prop)_____ 429 mph___12,000 ft
VNE______________470 mph IAS
TTH_____________ 8 minutes to 20,000 ft

Hornet Mk I_______ 475 mph___21,000 ft
__________________445 mph____7,500 ft
VNE______________420 mph IAS
TTH_____________ 5 minutes to 20,000 ft
Spit Mk XIV vs Hornet F Mk I.jpg
 
Last edited:
But the Hornet could no doubt carry a significant bomb load over a significant distance, and that would be the only reason for continuing to produce and operate a prop driven aircraft in the age of jets. Judged postwar, the P-47N had to be the most outstanding and "best" late model fighter of WW2.
 
This might be of interest. IMO it is quite telling in that any large advantage in one of the maneuver categories translates into a major advantage in dogfighting. It does not cover armour, ruggedness, or armament. I transcribed it from an AFDU report (I think) covering various aircraft.

Maximum speeds, VNE, & TTH according to the Air Ministry Aircraft Data Sheets:

Spitfire Mk XIV_____465 mph___26,000 ft
(5-blade prop)_____ 429 mph___12,000 ft
VNE______________470 mph IAS
TTH_____________ 8 minutes to 20,000 ft

Hornet Mk I_______ 475 mph___21,000 ft
__________________445 mph____7,500 ft
VNE______________420 mph IAS
TTH_____________ 5 minutes to 20,000 ft
View attachment 886947
Quite interesting, it would seem that the advantage of Spiteful XVI over Hornet Mk 1 is quite similar to advantage of Hornet over spitfire XIV
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back