So in a many vs many dogfight, it seem to me that the most important characteristic of a piston fighter seem to be top speed, since you can fly aways when the enemy is at your tail and instead try to engage other unsuspecting targets instead. It is important as it allow you to dictate when and where you engage and runaways when needed. But in a 1 vs 1 duel when there is no "unsuspecting target", what would be the most important factor that determine the winner? (except for pilot skill of course, for the sake of argument, let just assume both pilot are ace level)
1- Turn rate
Extreme example: Zero
2- Top speed, Power to weight
Extreme example: P-51H, Spiteful XVI
3- Armor protection and ruggedness
extreme example: F6F Hellcat, P-47, FW-190D
4- Destructive weapon
Extreme example Bf 110 G-4
5- Roll rate
Extreme example FW-190
1- Turn rate
Extreme example: Zero
2- Top speed, Power to weight
Extreme example: P-51H, Spiteful XVI
3- Armor protection and ruggedness
extreme example: F6F Hellcat, P-47, FW-190D
4- Destructive weapon
Extreme example Bf 110 G-4
5- Roll rate
Extreme example FW-190