I would fly a Me-109 only becaue I love the plane so much. I probably would get myself killed though. If it was not a Bf-109 I think I would love flying a P-47D. All that horse power and firepower. It would be fun.
Only because the Me-109 is my favorite aircraft. I know it was not the best but it is my fav. I love the 190 but I did not want to choose two Luftwaffe aircraft.