Hey Thumpalumpacus,
re ". . . and precise milling requires precise tooling."
The Japanese were quite capable of producing precision parts (where they were needed) both in terms of quality and in terms of numbers/man-hour. But the total volume of production is not the same thing - that requires volume of people and materials - neither of which Japan had in comparison to the Allies. I said Japan had 1/5 the industrial capacity of the US, and Shortround6 says that Japan had 1/8 the capacity, either way it does not allow for keeping up with the Joneses - and hence it is a forgone conclusion not needing argument or allowing value to the argument. The only way it can apply is if you wish to base being ahead or behind only on industrial capacity.
Hey Shortround6, (oops, cross posted here, but still valid I think)
re "I would also tend to discount the issue of fuel. Not eliminate it but discount it at least until 1944-45. But that also means that any country that planned to use better fuel and could not had made errors in planning to some extent. . . "
I believe the US adopted 100 octane as standard in 1938? and the UK in 1939? for all further engine development. I may be wrong about the exact year but it was somewhere about then.
The way (I think) to tell if the argument is valid is to try to think of what the progressive US/UK line-up would have looked like in 1940 thru 1945 if they had not had access to fuels higher than 87/91 grade. From your posts in other threads I think you are quite aware of the ramifications on engine development and the consequent impact on aircraft performance.
Admittedly only from a quick look, but as far as I can tell we are saying that (until late-war) no Allied fighter or TB/DB aircraft would have more than ~1100-1200 BHP available at altitude, until the mature 87/91 grade Griffon/Sabre and R-2600/2800 series came into use. There is no way the later aircraft the Allies fielded in real life (ie F4U, F6F, F7F, F8F, P-47, P-51 - Allison or Merlin, Typhoon, Tempest, etc) could do what they did if limited to 87/91 grade. The best the 'Hookerized' Merlin 45 would do is about 1200 BHP at 16,000 ft? The 2-stage Merlin 60 would still be worthwhile, but what would the power be with 87/91 grade? Maybe 1000 BHP at 23,000 ft? Can you imagine what the climb rates for the mid-war Allied single-engine aircraft (US in particular) would be if they were required to carry the same amount of armour, fuel load/SSFT, and armament, as in the real timeline? They might make the Fulmar look competitive. The P-38 with the turbosupercharger would still have been a good climber, as would a P-51/Merlin 60 (relatively), but what would the top speeds be - maybe 390-405 mph?
Single engine attack aircraft would suffer similar limitations.
Similarly, there would have been significant limitations on the medium and heavy bombers. The differences would perhaps been less due to somewhat conservative design requirements for the heavy bombers, but I do not think you would have seen anywhere near the combined bomb and fuel loads carried in the real timeline, not without sacrificing armour/SSFT and defensive armament.
The problem is I don't know what the actual limitations of the US 100 octane fuel were. And there is/was a definite difference between US 100 octane and British 100 Octane fuel in 1939-40. That whole not less than 20% aromatics vs not more than 2% aromatics thing.
Or what the differences were between 87 octane and even 92 octane and that is huge in itself.
We don't even know what British 87 octane was.
If the British 87 octane was 15-20 % aromatics it may have acted like something in the low to mid 90s under rich conditions. The British were specifying the aromatic content for a reason even if they didn't know why/how it worked at the time. They knew it did and they wanted it.
I don't know when in late 1940 or in 1941 things changed. The US had short lived specification for 125 fuel while the British went for the 100/130 fuel (as I have said before, BoB fuel when tested later ranged between 100/115 to 100/120) so designing developing engines in 1940-41was not as straight forward as it seems now.
You are quite right, the later war performance levels would not be reached. However the limits of the R-2800 powered aircraft were as much limited by the engines themselves as the PN of the fuel. The F4U, F6F and P-47 were all using intercoolers and were limited to about 11-12lbs of boost with 100/130 fuel. Merlin's could run 18lbs of boost without an intercooler. Merlin III was limited because of the gear ratio in the supercharger, they could use 9-10lbs of boost on the Merlin VIII and Merlin X engines with lower geared supercharges.
Edit> The single stage R-2800s in the B-26s were limited to 52in ( about 11 lbs?) so was it a engine cooling thing?
We also don't know what else could have been done. Jimmy Doolittle (among others) had experimented with water injection in the early 1930s and gotten about 900hp from a P&W R-1340 engine on test stand. In the early 30s the R-1340 was not quite a 600hp engine. The experiments were side lined with the development of better fuels.
Better fuels were also expensive and not needed for cruise.
We also don't know if better superchargers could have been developed.
Your example of the Merlin 45 is interesting as the Merlin 46 was designed to boost the altitude of the Merlin 45 by several thousand ft. However the bigger single stage, single speed supercharger cost 80-100hp at lower altitudes (and was the engine used in the Darwin Spitfires) however the Merlin 60/61 replaced it, however there were several experimental Merlin's at about that time. One was a Merlin 46 with a higher gear ratio and an intercooler, power was 1100hp at 26,000ft with 9lbs of boost.
There were a couple of experimental two speed engines, one with an intercooler and one without but using methanol injection. Both gave 1150hp at 23,000ft with 9lbs of boost using the standard 10.25 impeller.
There was also a two speed engine with a cropped impeller also using 9lbs of boost.
There were avenues that were not explored any further because they didn't need to be.
Supercharge design was one of them, some of the 1939-41 superchargers were literally god awful.
Using a mediocre supercharger with great fuel solved a lot of problems
Hispano-Suiza superchargers in the late 30s were sometimes noted as having blistered the paint off the supercharger housing. Now take that hot air and feed to engine using 87 octane fuel? Using 100 octane fuel was a band-aid, not a cure. we are talking 4-5lbs of boost.