Anyway, to get back to japanese aircraft, the Ki-61 discussed earlier was so late again purely from IJAAFs fault, what on earth were they thinking to ask Kawasaki to design TWO separate aircraft powered by the exact same engine, just differing in wing size, one ostensibly as interceptor and the other as multipurpose fighter. Especially with the Ki-44 already flying.
Just focusing on (preferably) the Ki-61 would have perhaps saved 6-9 months in timing, which is a long time in WW2. Even better if they put the 1250HP Ha-112 radial on it from the start, they will avoid a lot of reliability and productivity issues at the price of about 20 kph in speed, but with better climb and turning performance. The Ki-100 was well liked by the pilots, it could have been ready as soon as the 1500HP Ha-112-II was available, that is 1943 for prototypes and early part of 1944 for production.
That's a great question and the answer has to do with logistics. Essentially, the takeoff roll of the Ki-44 wasn't short enough to be used on hastily-constructed, frontline airbases. The biggest technological failing of the Japanese military was its inability to deploy heavy moving equipment to distant airfields. They were largely reliant on manual labor for building airbases, which meant their airstrips were shorter, rougher, and oftentimes their airbases lacked sufficient radar. In other words, their airfields lacked adequate defenses and early-warning systems. Furthermore, their most effective interceptors couldn't take off from their most vulnerable airbases.
Time, and time again, the Japanese army and navy got caught with their pants down as Allied heavy and medium bombers absolutely flattened loaded airfields. The various airbase destructions devastated Japanese aircraft, mechanics, facilities, and pilot rosters in the South Pacific. However, you'll notice that in areas such as China, where Japan possessed better airfields, they were able to deploy better interceptors and defenses and consequently didn't have the same losses as in the South Pacific.
So, in a longwinded way, the Ki-61's large winged, high-lift wing was designed to allow the interceptor to be deployed in such theaters as New Guinea and elsewhere. The Ki-44 could only be deployed in China, the Philippines, and the Japanese mainland due to its long takeoff roll.
Regarding the Kinsei 60-series, Ha-112-II, it was produced alongside the 1,300 HP Kinsei 50 series. It reached production in 1941 and could probably have been in an aircraft as early as 1943 according to Horikoshi. Although bombers and transport aircraft used the 50-series engine long before that period. It's likely that Horikoshi's estimate was based on having to redesign the Zero to incorporate a dimensionally larger engine. Had the Navy used the Kinsei from the very beginning, it's likely that the Kinsei 62 could have been used earlier.
Part of the problem for the Ki-60/Ki-61 was the fact that the Japanese got the License for the DB 601A while the Germans were sticking DB 601N and E engines.
The 601N needed 96 octane fuel and probably wasn't going to work for the Japanese but the Germans were sticking the 601E engine which used 87 octane in the 109F-4 in beginning of 1942.
The Ki-60 did serve some purpose at it showed what NOT to do in some cases.
The two programs did not overlap 100% even though the start date was about the same.
Assuming a 9 month gain in timing is to assume that the Ki-61 would have been much closer to the finished product without the input from the Ki-60s.
We are also assuming that the Ha-112 was available in late 1942 or early 1943 at the power level wanted.
The Kinsei 50 series engines are not going to work.
According to what I've read from NAASM and on Wikipedia, the Ha-112-I (which is the Kinsei 50-series) reached series production in 1941, was initially used in bombers and transports. The fuel-injected Kinsei 62 was produced and developed at the same time as the Kinsei 50-series (or Ha-112-I), although it looks like the 50 was used in aircraft a year earlier than the 60-series. But more or less, it looks like a Ki-61 with a 1,300, MW50-injected radial was possible as early as 1941 as a prototype and 1942 as a frontline fighter.
One other thing worth mentioning is that the top-speed of Japanese aircraft might be 3.5% faster than Japanese numbers due to a discrepancy in how WEP numbers were reported by Japanese evaluation standards (
great source here). I suspect that the reason the Japanese didn't record WEP values is because their manufacturing tolerances were worse compared to the Allies and so their engines constantly leaked oil. This is a major reason why the Imperial Japanese servies preferred radial engines as radials don't require the same tight manufacturing tolerances of in-line engines. But more or less, an engine that constantly leaks oil is not going to be able to maintain a WEP as long as an engine with better manufacturing standards. It's likely that the Japanese "overboost" was not as usable as WEP in an Allied fighter.