My point is that if your tech in the factory cannot pump them out faster, quality of design doesn't matter.
Now get that nice, high-tech machine tool to cottage-industry subcontractors building the parts for these airplanes. Isn't all that much easier in a big plant? But wait, there's more. You also have to get the materials for manufacture out to these smaller shops. That, too, requires tech -- rails? Ships? And so on.
Ah. And no doubt 350 or so Japanese flying boats made as big a difference as 2700 American-built in a theater as large as the Pacific. Those superior flying boats really got it done.
No, they got shot down by fighters.
Japan was technologically behind the Allies by 1943-44. They had some good designs, and their late war carrier bomber was great, on paper. But if you look at it year-by-year, you see the tide turn -- and not only in airplanes, but ships as well.
The difference between science and technology is that science can make great designs, but technology is required to produce it in numbers.
Let me be clear, I am
not claiming, nor have I ever, that the Japanese equaled, let alone surpassed US industrial production in WW2. They did fairly well in production by world standards, but they (nor anyone else) were not in the same league as the US.
But when looking at WW2, that is kind of the equivalent of 'when your only tool is a hammer, everything looks like a nail'. If you want the US to look
great, emphasize quantity of production and wax poetic about how important all those busy factories, mines, refineries and manufacturing plants are. Sure the US was great at production. That is not necessarily what the thread is about.
My contention at any rate is that the Japanese aircraft designs, with production significant enough to play some role in the war, was equal to that of Europe and the US. I mean designs that saw action I'm not just talking about theoretical x-weapons or whatever. I think once you get into 1944 though the effects of US Strategic warfare, both bombing of Japan and (I think maybe even more) the destruction of their merchant fleet meant that they fell behind sharply in production.
I think the ratio you are emphasizing here of 2700 PBYs to 300 H6 and H8 flying boats is a bit misleading. This was a matter more of priorities rather than purportedly feeble production capabilities. They had types we never even bothered with, for example 300 of those A6M2-N seaplane fighters, I'm not sure how many of the 1,500 N1k1 were the seaplane type, but some of those were. They built 10,000 A6Ms in all variants. That isn't trivial.
I believe that the Japanese didn't produce as many flying boats because they did not prioritize all the missions those were really used for - i.e. a lot of search and rescue and crew recovery, as well as recon and ASW. The fairly antiquated PBYs were starting to be used less for daytime recon and more for ASW and search and rescue (and some night time anti-shipping strikes) in the later years of the war.
The Japanese produced over 70,000 aircraft during the war. That's fourth in the world, but lets keep in mind that their production was severely impacted in the last two years of the conflict (which was when ours was in high gear).
Let's also remember that the IJN produced 18-20 aircraft carriers during or before the war. (13 fleet carriers, 7 light carriers). The US produced far more than that (over 100, mostly late in the war), but Japan was second with (I think) more than Britain. Germans had none. Italians had one partially constructed. Soviets had none. French had maybe one in production.
The Japanese were also keeping up with the US until the mid war, in terms of carriers in the battle areas.