Light fighters alternatives, 1935-1945 (3 Viewers)

Going back to the overall OP the question becomes why would you choose a light fighter instead of a full blown fighter?
I think that your two points - Gladiator and J.22 - are well made.

When compared with 'full size' fighters like the Hurricane or Spitfire, their performance and firepower, the Gladiator tick a lot of the boxes as a light fighter. IMO, it's purchase process underscores the wishes of the AM to have it's bases covered in case the new fighters and/or their new engines suffer a big delay, if not cancellation. Or, if another spec misses the target by a land mile, as it happened with the Defiant.
It was probably too bad that a small monoplane with retractable U/C was not also designed (hopefuly by my favorite company: DH, as many times before), powered by either Mercury or Kestrel. The J.22 example points out to the relatively high-performing fighter on modest power, and not everyone has access to the many hundreds, let alone thousands of Merlins, Sabres, DBs or R-2800s.

These are all forced decisions in different ways. Ceteris paribus the full power fighter will always be at an advantage but that does not necessarily mean that a good light fighter cannot be useful at all. Using grossly underpowered engines cannot be compensated for by bolting on less aeroplane and never works.
There is no point in over-did it.
One will never make a reasonable fighter around the Argus engines, or around the 1-row Wasp, or around the Gipsy 12, or around any of the 500-ish HP engines. But once the 1000-1200 HP engines are in series production, access to the 750-850 Hp engines will be much easier, both for the domestic and foreign needs. Once the 1300-1600 HP engines are available for the mainstream fighters, up-engining the 750-850 HP light fighter with a 1000-1200 HP engine should not be a long shot.

I do still wonder what might have been if the Bristol Aquila had reached later Hercules or even Taurus levels of specific power in a Vickers Venom……
A 950 cu in engine, or a bit bigger than half of the R-1820, or about 40% of the Hercules? Assumes decent supercharging, and 2-speed S/C drive - probably 700-750 HP with 145 or 150 grade fuel for post-war use? 600-650 HP with 130 grade?
 
I can only see two reasons to go down the light fighter road.

One is to benefit from the shorter take off and landing possibilities.
Don't confuse cause and effect. A Hurricane was practically an STOL machine compared to some fighters (once they got a good propeller). At least aerodynamically. Weight of the machine and size of tires are a different matter on soggy French airfields. I do wonder how well most (all?) of the French "light" fighters would have fared on the crappy airfields they gave the British. High wing loading means higher take-off and landing speeds. Poor power to weight ratio means more time/distance to get up to speed. Light fighters with small wheels may have zero advantage in mud. Doesn't matter how easy it is to push the plane by hand if the plane noses over and wrecks the propeller while taxiing.
Gladiator was not just light, as a biplane it had huge wing area (a tiny bit more than a P-38). Most "light" fighters, in order to go fast with low power, cut the wing area to reduce drag and operated with wing loadings close to the 1939-40-standard fighters. Japanese were pretty much the exception here.
The other is the inability to acquire the preferred full size fighter.
This quite true.
Success can also depend on the expected mission/s or theater of operations. The Swedish fighter may have been excellent in combat, especially considering the power of the engine. Landing field requirements may be similar to may conventional fighters. I do have my doubts about range. Japanese would not have been happy with the J 22 unless it was pretty much tasked with base defense. Shorter European distances work better for it.
 
I do still wonder what might have been if the Bristol Aquila had reached later Hercules or even Taurus levels of specific power in a Vickers Venom……

A 950 cu in engine, or a bit bigger than half of the R-1820, or about 40% of the Hercules? Assumes decent supercharging, and 2-speed S/C drive - probably 700-750 HP with 145 or 150 grade fuel for post-war use? 600-650 HP with 130 grade?
Tomo sums it up very well.
The other side of this is what else does NOT get done while fooling around with this tiny engine?
A let us not forget that the Taurus was actually not a very good engine.
The Aquila was about 61% the size of the Taurus. Best the Taurus ever did in service was 1130hp at 3500ft.
Super fighter with 690hp at 3500ft? Now just fix the cooling problems the Taurus had making that power at 3500ft.
Also requires a fair degree of faith in the Venom performance figures. Nobody seems to have any proof that the guns were ever fitted?
 
and Ki48 remained viable with developments albeit increasingly less so as time went on. For the outlier Japanese situation they made sense when designed and built.
The Ki-48 only made sense if the Chinese remand the only enemy.
the Ki-48 II only entered production April of 1942. It was too little too late, and they certainly did not replace the entire Ki 48 I fleet in a few months.
Ki 48 had a top speed of 298mph which not too bad, but with the single speed superchargers it was done at 3500 meters which means that just about anything that can fly can dive on you from above. Also means defenders can reach you with less warning time.
Cruse speed for the Ki-48 I is given as 350kph at 3500meters or 217mph at 11,500ft (rounded off). I am sure the plane could cruise faster, much faster but then the range goes down.
The Ki-48 was certainly an improvement over the Ki 32 single engine bomber but the world had left Japan behind and using two 14 cylinder engines and 4 men to deliver a 300kg bomb load was certainly a poor return in investment.
Basically, the Japanese, in the fall of 1940 introduced faster but slight shorter-range Blenheim that needed more crew, didn't carry as great a bomb load, and could not defend itself as well. British had 14 squadrons of MK IV Blenheim's in service at the end of 1939, 9 months earlier.
Blenheim is pretty low hanging fruit.
By the late spring/summer of 1942 when the Ki 48 IIs start to show up (over 1 1/2 years later) the improvements are not enough. They resort to night bombing and/or escort by huge numbers of fighters. More like 6-12 Ki-48s are acting as bait to lure defending fighters to fight the 3 squadrons or so of escorting fighters.
They are light but two 14 cylinder engines and constant speed props are not cheap and neither is trained aircrew.
 
The Ki-48 only made sense if the Chinese remand the only enemy.
the Ki-48 II only entered production April of 1942. It was too little too late, and they certainly did not replace the entire Ki 48 I fleet in a few months.
Ki 48 had a top speed of 298mph which not too bad, but with the single speed superchargers it was done at 3500 meters which means that just about anything that can fly can dive on you from above. Also means defenders can reach you with less warning time.
Cruse speed for the Ki-48 I is given as 350kph at 3500meters or 217mph at 11,500ft (rounded off). I am sure the plane could cruise faster, much faster but then the range goes down.
The Ki-48 was certainly an improvement over the Ki 32 single engine bomber but the world had left Japan behind and using two 14 cylinder engines and 4 men to deliver a 300kg bomb load was certainly a poor return in investment.
Basically, the Japanese, in the fall of 1940 introduced faster but slight shorter-range Blenheim that needed more crew, didn't carry as great a bomb load, and could not defend itself as well. British had 14 squadrons of MK IV Blenheim's in service at the end of 1939, 9 months earlier.
Blenheim is pretty low hanging fruit.
By the late spring/summer of 1942 when the Ki 48 IIs start to show up (over 1 1/2 years later) the improvements are not enough. They resort to night bombing and/or escort by huge numbers of fighters. More like 6-12 Ki-48s are acting as bait to lure defending fighters to fight the 3 squadrons or so of escorting fighters.
They are light but two 14 cylinder engines and constant speed props are not cheap and neither is trained aircrew.
My apologies. My brain said Ki43 but my fingers wrote Ki48…..
 
No worries, people on this forum have been putting up with my less than dexterous fingers for well over a decade ;)
My peace of ship cellphone's spellcheck has entered the chat...
 
It is as if the IJA was trying how to misuse the engines, fuel and other war material on both the Ki-45 and -48. Too much investment for feeble gains.
To be honest, the KI-45 was perhaps the best of all heavy fighters Allied or Axis.

The IJA could have done better with the KI-46 III-Kai sooner, though, and done away with the KI-45 altogether.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back