Light fighters alternatives, 1935-1945 (6 Viewers)

Not sure that Griffon Spitfires might be categorized as the real light fighters of the day. Despite them being lighter than the Tempests or the heavy US stuff.
The Spitfire_XIV, which did see significant action during WWII, was the smallest, lightest 2,000HP aircraft of the war. The Nakajima Ki.84 had the same maximum take-off weight, but it was a smidgen less powerful. Supermarine did not pay much attention to manufactureability. Those sexy curves were expensive.
 
There were several times in the 1950s where a new engine was in whole new area of power to weight which sort of changed the rules.
The Bristol Orpheus engine weighed about 800-850 pounds and provided 4000-5000lbs of thrust.
The J-35 engine used in the F-86 prototype weighed around 2400lbs and gave 3,850lbs of thrust, the early J-47s were also around 2500lbs and gave 5200lbs of thrust. Later versions had more thrust (all without after burners). Having a smaller and much lighter engine (1/3rd the weight) with almost as much power (or 80%?) allowed the entire airplane to be smaller and lighter. In the 1930s and WW II the piston engines never had such a radical shift in power to weight. Yes some engines were better than others but jump of almost 2.5 to 1 power to weight was phenomenal.
With the J-85 engines used in the F-5s there was another huge jump in power to weight (and power to size the J-85s were around 20in diameter) and 3850lbs thrust (with after burner) for 525lbs weight the much lighter weight of the engine installation (even twins) opened up new ground.
In the 1930s and 40s smaller engines almost always had a poorer power to weight ratio than more powerful engines, especially at altitude.
 
The Spitfire_XIV, which did see significant action during WWII, was the smallest, lightest 2,000HP aircraft of the war. The Nakajima Ki.84 had the same maximum take-off weight, but it was a smidgen less powerful.
IMO, a 2000+ HP fighter is not a lightweight fighter. YMMW.

Supermarine did not pay much attention to manufactureability. Those sexy curves were expensive.
True for the 1st sentence.
Having the curves does not elliminate the manufactureability. Manufacturer's decisions & abilities do.
 
IMO, a 2000+ HP fighter is not a lightweight fighter. YMMW.


True for the 1st sentence.
Having the curves does not elliminate the manufactureability. Manufacturer's decisions & abilities do.
If you insist on 2,000HP, the Spitfire_XIV is lightweight.

If you have single curves, you can punch out a piece of flat sheet metal and attach it to your frame. If you have a double curve, you need to process your flat sheet metal in an additional process. As the war continued and demand for Spitfires increased, they may have made some tooling to do this.
 
If you insist on 2,000HP, the Spitfire_XIV is lightweight.
I don't insist on 2000 HP.

If you have single curves, you can punch out a piece of flat sheet metal and attach it to your frame. If you have a double curve, you need to process your flat sheet metal in an additional process.
Spitfire was hard to make because the usage of stampings was limited. That meant most of the ribs contained like a dozen of alloy profiles each, that were put tugether by riveting. See here, for example.
Many of other companies made the ribs as single-piece in a presse - Mitsubishi (not only) for the Zero, MTT for the Bf 109, US companies etc. Formers were also built-up from numerous pieces. The more bits and pieces, the harder it is to mass-produce stuff.

Mentioning the curvy look of the Spitfire as a thing that precludes easy mass production was yet another 1950s-60s fig leaf painted by some British historians as an excuse when one started asking pointed questions.
Supermarine was not alone in this group - Italians were there with their fighters, too, see MC.205 for example.
 
Prof Willy and boys would not have designed the 109 the way did if they had been told to use eight guns to begin with. Of course, an eight gun 109 using a Jumo 210 would have been a disaster.
Bf 109 was certainly a light fighter when comapred with the Hurricane, at least when 1st designed - former was with a small engine, small size, light, and with feeble firepower. Comparison shows that the airframe designer can afford to be very conservative if he has a real deal under the hood.
The 109 also shows that a light fighter does not need to sit where it is - there is still a lot of room for improvement, and the initial small size is beneficial wrt. the drag.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back