Long-deployed USS Lincoln to be replaced after mental health concerns and reports of poor conditions (1 Viewer)

Admiral Beez

Major
10,276
11,917
Joined
Oct 21, 2019
Location
Toronto, Canada
Paywall free: https://archive.is/wip/3Di6x

First, USS Gerald Ford returns with a clapped out crew, plumbing and fire damage issues. Now, USS Abraham Lincoln returns with a clapped out crew. Does the USN need more carriers and more crew?
 
Paywall free: https://archive.is/wip/3Di6x

First, USS Gerald Ford returns with a clapped out crew, plumbing and fire damage issues. Now, USS Abraham Lincoln returns with a clapped out crew. Does the USN need more carriers and more crew?
Let's keep in mind that we live in the age of instant disinformation.

That article (which lacks citations/sources aside from one who wishes to remain anonymous) fails to note that the USS Teddy Roosevelt is in the Pacific, the USS George Washington is currently in the Phillipine Sea, and the USS G. Bush is currently in the Arabian Sea. Several other carriers are nearing completion of refitting and deployment.
 
As of July / Aug 2026:
CVN-68 Nimitz is winding down to retirement. The process was due to begin in March 2026 but has been delayed until March 2027 to maintain fleet strength due to delays in completing the next CVN, Kennedy (see below).

CVN-69 Dwight D Eisenhower completed a 15 month refit in April but it will be some time before she and her air group are fully worked up ready for deployment.

CVN-70 Carl Vinson completed a 9 month deployment in Aug 2025 and won't be available again for some time.

CVN-71 Theodore Roosevelt is operational in the Pacific having just participated in the latest RIMPAC exercise. She is due back at sea Sept 2026. Her previous deployment was 278 days ending Oct 2024. The following refit lasted until spring 2026.

CVN-72 Abraham Lincoln has been deployed in the Arabian Sea since January, 2026 clocking up over 260 continuous days at sea.

CVN-73 George Washington is the carrier forward deployed to Yokosuka, Japan. Her 6 year RCOH was completed in 2023. Latest news reports indicate she will probably replace Lincoln on station.

CVN-74 John C Stennis is currently still undergoing her RCOH that started in 2021. Completion has been delayed by over a year and is expected to complete in Oct 2026, which means she won't be ready to deploy until later in 2027.

CVN-75 Harry S Truman completed an 8 month deployment in June 2026. Now beginning her 5-6 year RCOH.

CVN-76 Ronald Reagan was until Aug 2024 the forward deployed carrier in Japan. Began a refit in 2025 that is due to complete end of Aug 2026. So probably mid-2027 before she and her air group are ready to deploy.

CVN-77 George H W Bush deployed to the Middle East & Arabian Sea in March 2026 as replacement for CVN-78 Gerald R Ford.

CVN-78 Gerald R Ford returned to Norfolk in May 2026 after a deployment lasting 326 days, the longest deployment of any US carrier since the Vietnam war. The deployment had been scheduled to last 7 months (somewhere near the norm) but was extended again and again until it reached 11 months.

CVN-79 John F Kennedy is in her new ship trials phase and is due to commission in March 2027, hence the need to keep Nimitz in service for another year.

The USN does have a problem with its CVNs. Building new ships is taking longer, RCOH long refits are taking longer (increase from 5 to 6 years). There are many reasons for this. These, along with increased need for carriers in operational theatres is leading to extended deployment times. Extended deployment times lead to more problems needing fixed when carriers return home which leads to longer refit times to fix them which leads to more need for longer deployment times. It just becomes a vicious circle. And a carrier doesn't leave a refit period and be ready to be back months line. The ship itself needs to work up, the air group needs to work up, and then they need to work up together.

And that is without considering the strain on the crews and aircrews. While the ship is at sea most never get to see daylight. And the operational tempo of those "in action" has been such that there have been no regular runs ashore as would be the case in other times.

At any one time one of the 11 carriers will be in RCOH. 1 is permanently forward deployed to Japan. 5 are currently allocated to East coast ports (with Bush deployed to the Arabian Sea) and 4 to West Coast ports (with Lincoln deployed to the Arabian Sea). Of the 10 available, rule of thumb, one carrier on the front line, one in refit and one working up.
 
Is there any reason they could not simply rotate at least parts of ship and air crew with those from currently inactive carriers?
Multiple reasons I can think of.

A crew has to work together to form a single cohesive unit to be ready to fight together. The same applies to the air group. Drafting people in and out breaks that cohesion. Replacing an odd body here or there is one thing but replacing a large chunk of the 5,000+ crew on a CVN with the right skill sets is quite another.

The CVN are not identical. Setting aside the Ford which is the first of an entirely new class, the 10 Nimitz class were built between 1968, when Nimitz herself was laid down, and 2009 when the Bush commissioned. Yes they have been refitted but again that has happened over time. The class essentially breaks down into a number of sub-classes - CVN-68 to 70, CVN-71to 75 and CVN-76 to 77. There will be differences internally and to equipment fits.

When ships are in port between deployments, the sailors and aircrew are not sitting idle. Those periods are used with them assisting in ship or aircraft maintenance, or away on training courses that will help both the Navy and them personally in career development. Personnel also require periods of leave.

Air groups often use the time to convert to new aircraft types. At present some squadrons are due to convert from F-18E/F to F-35C while the E-2C squadrons will upgrade to the E-2D as time and aircraft become available. They will also absorb new personnel from training schools while others will leave for other positions.

Typically a carrier air group will go through 4 phases from the time it ends one deployment until it begins the next.
1. Maintenance & Reset: Post-deployment phase where aircraft undergo deep maintenance, engines are overhauled, and squadrons are integrated back into their parent Naval Air Stations (NAS).
2. Unit-Level Training (ULT): Individual pilot and crew proficiencies are re-earned, focusing on basic flight safety, instruments, and tactical qualifications.
3. Field Carrier Landing Practice (FCLP): Pilots perform repetitive touch-and-go maneuvers on ashore runways painted with simulated carrier deck landing lines to maintain currency before actual carrier re-qualification.
4. Integrated Strike Exercises: Advanced group training conducted at specialized facilities like the Naval Strike and Air Warfare Center in Fallon, Nevada, to prepare for composite strike group integration.

Having gone through those phases it will then return to a carrier for a further period of training at sea. Only then can it, and its parent carrier, be considered ready for an operational deployment. All this has been worked out over many many years.

When it comes to the air groups the USN only has 9 for the 10 carriers not in RCOH. So swapping out a whole air group is really not possible given that refit cycles of carriers and air groups are inter-related. Also there are no spare squadrons so the ability to swap out individual squadrons is limited.
 
Paywall free: https://archive.is/wip/3Di6x

First, USS Gerald Ford returns with a clapped out crew, plumbing and fire damage issues. Now, USS Abraham Lincoln returns with a clapped out crew. Does the USN need more carriers and more crew?
It's also possible competent officer were replaced with less capable ones for ideological reasons. While morale issues are within the purview of the captain, that person can't conjure a supply ship out of thin air.
 
A personal view is the simple lack of planning. From start to finish there seems to have been a lack of planning and I am not just thinking of the political issues. The ships have been deployed for a long time and there was no option to support / replace them after a set time. As a result you have a situation where people are being pushed beyond normal limits.

On a mechanical level I don't know how long her next refit was planned to take but they had better double it. Everything is going to need refurbishing
 
A personal view is the simple lack of planning. From start to finish there seems to have been a lack of planning and I am not just thinking of the political issues. The ships have been deployed for a long time and there was no option to support / replace them after a set time. As a result you have a situation where people are being pushed beyond normal limits.

On a mechanical level I don't know how long her next refit was planned to take but they had better double it. Everything is going to need refurbishing
Planning only goes so far.

The problems run much deeper and into the entire US shipbuilding and repair industry. New ships with delivery dates constantly being pushed back so old ships having to be kept in service at increased cost and refit time. Refits running over schedule and budget, forcing the next on the refit line to be kept going a bit longer.

CVN-79 John F Kennedy, the Nimitz replacement, I've already noted. CVN-80 Enterprise, the Eisenhower replacement, was due to be delivered in March 2028. The latest delay, of many, has pushed that back to March 2031. Nimitz will be 52 when she finally leaves service next year. Eisenhower will be nearly 54 when she is replaced. Keeping old ships going costs time & money.

Ships kept on deployment longer take more time to refit before the next deployment.

And all this builds up over time until it reaches crisis point.

There is only one shipyard with the current capability of building a CVN. That same yard is the only one capable of carrying out a RCOH. That is Newport News. There is not enough work to have two yards involved in either activity if a steady drumbeat of work is to be maintained on each line. But a delay has knock on consequences for the next ship scheduled. And it is not just carriers affected, it is virtually every type of ship in the navy.
 
Planning only goes so far.

The problems run much deeper and into the entire US shipbuilding and repair industry. New ships with delivery dates constantly being pushed back so old ships having to be kept in service at increased cost and refit time. Refits running over schedule and budget, forcing the next on the refit line to be kept going a bit longer.

CVN-79 John F Kennedy, the Nimitz replacement, I've already noted. CVN-80 Enterprise, the Eisenhower replacement, was due to be delivered in March 2028. The latest delay, of many, has pushed that back to March 2031. Nimitz will be 52 when she finally leaves service next year. Eisenhower will be nearly 54 when she is replaced. Keeping old ships going costs time & money.

Ships kept on deployment longer take more time to refit before the next deployment.

And all this builds up over time until it reaches crisis point.

There is only one shipyard with the current capability of building a CVN. That same yard is the only one capable of carrying out a RCOH. That is Newport News. There is not enough work to have two yards involved in either activity if a steady drumbeat of work is to be maintained on each line. But a delay has knock on consequences for the next ship scheduled. And it is not just carriers affected, it is virtually every type of ship in the navy.
I have to agree with what you say but you should plan to make the best use of what you have, and that clearly wasn't done.

Your comments on the status of the shipyards is spot on. It isn't widely advertised but parts of the USN Virginia Class submarine project are being built in Rosyth, Scotland by Babcock.
 
I have to agree with what you say but you should plan to make the best use of what you have, and that clearly wasn't done.

Your comments on the status of the shipyards is spot on. It isn't widely advertised but parts of the USN Virginia Class submarine project are being built in Rosyth, Scotland by Babcock.
Babcock also manufactures missile tubes for the common missile compartments of the new USN Columbia class and RN Dreadnought class SSBN.
 
There is no doubt that the U.S. Armed Forces are under-armed at present. More on that in a moment. Let me just say up front that in various past eras, many men were deployed for the "duration" and fed and "housed' under heck of a lot worse conditions than anyone on the Lincoln. History anyone...? Also, take a tour of any of the WWII ships open for tour, for example, the U.S.S. battleship Alabama, etc. etc.

We are all currently NOT "the greatest generation"
 
There is no doubt that the U.S. Armed Forces are under-armed at present. More on that in a moment. Let me just say up front that in various past eras, many men were deployed for the "duration" and fed and "housed' under heck of a lot worse conditions than anyone on the Lincoln. History anyone...? Also, take a tour of any of the WWII ships open for tour, for example, the U.S.S. battleship Alabama, etc. etc.

We are all currently NOT "the greatest generation"
The military stance of the US government was changed by Barack Obama in 2013 by a budget change. This is outlined in the following article.:https://breakingdefense.com/2012/03/navy-shrinking-while-obama-pivots-to-asia-does-not-add-up/

To be fair, a lot of the ships that were reduced were part of the dead fleet of old World War II US cargo vessels that were mowed in the James river off of Fort Eustis Virginia in Warwick County that's for a time held national food, emergency supplies such as rice, flour, etc. these were eventually done away with.
I remember growing up in Newport News during the era when the Newport News shipbuilding a dry dock company laid to kill and then built the USS Forest stall the first super carrier in a matter of about 3 1/2 years it was really something to go downtown and stand under the bowel of this mighty ship as it was being built one of my fondest memories
And later years, I was offered an internship at that company to work in the shift drafting department, but I had other plans so I let it go by. It is interesting to be 82 1/2 years old and I've seen so much history go by I hope we do better in the next 80 years than we've done in the past
Ed
 
The military stance of the US government was changed by Barack Obama in 2013 by a budget change. This is outlined in the following article.:https://breakingdefense.com/2012/03/navy-shrinking-while-obama-pivots-to-asia-does-not-add-up/

To be fair, a lot of the ships that were reduced were part of the dead fleet of old World War II US cargo vessels that were mowed in the James river off of Fort Eustis Virginia in Warwick County that's for a time held national food, emergency supplies such as rice, flour, etc. these were eventually done away with.
I remember growing up in Newport News during the era when the Newport News shipbuilding a dry dock company laid to kill and then built the USS Forest stall the first super carrier in a matter of about 3 1/2 years it was really something to go downtown and stand under the bowel of this mighty ship as it was being built one of my fondest memories
And later years, I was offered an internship at that company to work in the shift drafting department, but I had other plans so I let it go by. It is interesting to be 82 1/2 years old and I've seen so much history go by I hope we do better in the next 80 years than we've done in the past
Ed
Forgive the spelling in the above as my store-bought teeth are not clearly understood by my iPhone😊
 
There is no doubt that the U.S. Armed Forces are under-armed at present. More on that in a moment. Let me just say up front that in various past eras, many men were deployed for the "duration" and fed and "housed' under heck of a lot worse conditions than anyone on the Lincoln. History anyone...? Also, take a tour of any of the WWII ships open for tour, for example, the U.S.S. battleship Alabama, etc. etc.

We are all currently NOT "the greatest generation"
A young friend of mine recently joined the USN and is training as a submariner.

When home on leave, he mentioned that "serving aboard a sub will take some getting used to, they're really cramped".

I said "bro, my Uncle served aboard subs in the Pacific during WWII. Your subs today are luxury hotels compared to his Gato and Baleo class boats..."
 
A young friend of mine recently joined the USN and is training as a submariner.

When home on leave, he mentioned that "serving aboard a sub will take some getting used to, they're really cramped".

I said "bro, my Uncle served aboard subs in the Pacific during WWII. Your subs today are luxury hotels compared to his Gato and Baleo class boats..."
...and my father grew up in a house without running water and slept in an unheated attic in a house with no central heat. On the other hand, his naval service in the Pacific didn't involve running short of necessities, like food. If you can't get the logistics, reconsider your plans.
 
...and my father grew up in a house without running water and slept in an unheated attic in a house with no central heat. On the other hand, his naval service in the Pacific didn't involve running short of necessities, like food. If you can't get the logistics, reconsider your plans.
My Uncle Fred was not only a Torpedoman, he was also the boat's steward - one of his escapades involved "liberating" an ice cream machine with one of his cohorts, from one of the carriers while in Pearl Harbor during a refit.
Not sure if it was the Grayling, another boat or the Cavalla, but a feller has gotta do what a fellers gotta do... :lol:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back