Soren said:
Lunatic didnt you see my previus post ?
I was editing my post, with several delays for phone calls, when CB and you posted. It is hard to get tables to line up in this editor.
Soren said:
I know i was wrong, i aparantly mixed up some data.
NP, we all make goofs sometimes.
Soren said:
However the 50.cal had a normal velocity of 853m/s, and 890m/s for aircraft ammunition.
Jeeze, I've given you the data strait out of the manual. And the manual is edited to peacetime specs, in wartime ammo was loaded hotter. The velocity of the .50, it depends on the ammo. Check the link to the other thread I gave for velocity info, and then factor in that these figures are taken at 78 feet and must be adjusted up to get an actual muzzle velocity. Then factor in that WWII ammo was loaded hotter than peacetime ammo. Normal quoted WWII figures are 870 m/s for the .50 AP/Ball round at 78 feet, and 880 m/s for the Hispano 20mm at 90 feet (Actually the ANM2 version of the Hispano II).
Soren said:
However i ca't see how you define the MG131 as weak !! It could easely rip holes in a P-47 and its 900rpm is also an advantage !
Hmmm.... .50's fired at 800-850 rpm stock, 950-1050 if the "nickle trick" was used (very common for the P-51B and inner pair of guns on the P-51D), but this was not generally done on the P-47D. The P-47N on the other hand (at least the late models) had the .50 M3, and fired at 1200 rpm. The MG131/13mm fired at a maximum syncronized speed of 840 rpm, but this also could be lower depending upon engine rpm. Overall, 800 rpms for both guns are reasonable estimates, which means the P-47 has 4 x the volume of fire as compared to the MG131's of the 109K. Alternatively if you want to use maximums, the max rate of fire of the standard BMG is 850 rpms.
Now lets consider the kinetic energy of the rounds. At the muzzle, using the figures for the MG131 API vs. the M2 AP round (I have not run the ballistics for the M8 API, its a very involved process), we get:
M2 AP at 0 meters = 48.6 x 867 x 867 = 36532085.4
MG131 API at 0 meters = 38.5 x 710 x 710 = 19407850
M2 AP at 100 meters = 48.6 x 822 x 822 = 32838242.4
MG131 API at 100 meters = 38.5 x 619 x 619 = 14751698.5
M2 AP at 200 meters = 48.6 x 778 x 778 = 29416802.4
MG131 API at 200 meters = 38.5 x 539 x 539 = 11185058.5
M2 AP at 300 meters = 48.6 x 736 x 736 = 26326425.6
MG131 API at 300 meters = 38.5 x 472 x 472 = 8577184
So as you can see, at 0 meters the .50 AP has 88% more kinetic energy than the MG131 API. At 100 meters the advantage grows to 123%, at 200 meters to 163%, and at 300 meters it has grown to 207%. So in terms of kinetic energy, the .50 is more than double the power of the MG131 at 100 meters, and more than triple the power at 300 meters. And it just gets worse with increasing range.
The MG131/13 was a very weak HMG. It was about 2.5x more powerful than the 7.9mm guns it replaced, and had a little better ballistics too, but compared to other 12.7mm class HMG's it sucked! Why can't you accept this fact?
=S=
Lunatic