Question about Jets vs Biplanes or lightweight single wing aricrafts

Discussion in 'Modern' started by ekirk, Feb 18, 2009.

  1. ekirk

    ekirk New Member

    Feb 18, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Hello. I have a quick question for you airplane buffs. I am seeking expert aid and knew that this was the place to come. A few friends and I were having a debate as to whether a biplane or lightweight aircraft could defeat a modern jet. Their argument stated that the lightweight aircraft would have the advantage due to it's weight and maneuverability. Now while I am willing to concede that these two elements are helpful, the jet would still be more than able to blow the light aircraft out of the sky without sustaining any damage.

    Also this man claimed that if say a sidewinder were to penetrate the wing of the lightweight aircraft without detonation that the plane would still be able to fly and continue with high chance of defeating the jet. I though that this idea was ridiculous considering the small size of the wing and the damage that such a weapon would do. How much damage can a wing sustain before the plane would need to land.

    Would this damage cripple the plane to the point of creating a sitting duck. I believe that the damage on the wing would be enough to cripple the plane. It would no longer be able to do such complex maneuvers due to the stress it would put on the wing.

    Please let me know as much as you can. I would love to get to the bottom of this issue. The man who started it called me a girl who didn't understand anything about planes and I would like to prove that I can get the information from the experts. Thanks again!
  2. Colin1

    Colin1 Active Member

    Jan 2, 2009
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Engineer and overgrown schoolboy
    United Kingdom
    against the modern jet, the biplane would have no advantage whatsoever, he could turn on a sixpence compared to the modern jet who'd go wheeling past him at a comparatively massive velocity, for all the good that would do the biplane; by the time he'd gotten onto the jet's six o'clock, it would be in the next county. The biplane's manoeuvrability would no more help him against a modern jet than the A6M Zero's did against the faster, more powerfully-armed USN late-war fighters, once the USN had worked out the Zero's ace card.

    Coming down to the speed of the biplane would be out of the question, it would be suicide, he'd likely drop out of the sky and even if he somehow didn't, he's playing the biplane at the biplane's game and consequently might still end up dropping out of the sky (what's this biplane armed with?)

    I don't believe the biplane would ever be presented with a 'high chance' to defeat the modern jet.

    I don't know enough about the modern stuff to offer a decent opinion but I'd hazard that the closing speed of the modern jet would be too much to take advantage of a 'boom and zoom' tactic; I don't know if the biplane's engine would generate enough heat for a missile lock or if there is another type of missile that the modern jet could call upon.
    He could go guns-on and come in miles out from the target and just hope the biplane kept still for long enough but somehow I doubt that; the biplane would likely (assuming he'd kept his eye on the modern jet) use his manoeuvrability to suddenly present the jet with an impossible angle.

    He could conduct a close-as-possible pass over the biplane on full afterburner, that would certainly screw his day up - he'd likely disintegrate.

Share This Page