It should also be noted that the P47N manual states that before going into a dive you should trim the flaps, close the cowl flaps, decrease the manifold pressure, do not retard the throttle quickly, just the sort of action you would do in a combat situation when there is plenty of time.
Good point, and perhaps being prepared is what the manual for an aircraft is all about.
In combat, would i suspect that a pilot has his cowl flaps open, his throttle wide open, and his trim out of neutral so that a sudden dive might require the adjustment of all those aspects of the aircraft to ensure the safest dive? Maybe only in a climb.
Look at other parts of the manual, if he's in combat, his cowl flaps would be closed, his flaps should be up, and he should only be prepared to trim and throttle, like any other plane.
Should you get into compressability then the nose gets heavy, controls tighten up, sounds a bit like the Spit doesn't it. Then there is the blunt statement, intentional spinnng is forbidden. Also the types of aerobatics are limmited and the ominous phrase 'All other manoeuvers are prohibited. They teach you nothing and are extreamly dangerous'. It also makes a specfic point of emphasising that snap rolls can damage the structure.
Sure, there are a list of limitations for every aircraft.
Most manuals, particularly training manuals always drill procedure with a healthy safety margin.
You seldom ever see them allowing spins, particularly if it is a training manual.
Normally, with spin limitations there is always an emphasis on speed.
If you were to tell me the Spit had a larger envelope for spinning, i would have to agree.
Intentionally spinning might only be done to practice recovery procedure while training.
Aside from spinning, the P-47 had good stall characteristics. "It doesn't have a tendency to spin."
In the Spitfire spinning is only banned when carrying external stores or fuel in the rear tank which is fair enough. Also the emphasise you put on the Spit getting tail heavy in a dive is misleading, you omitted to mention that the counteraction was to use the trim tab. Which is far less complicated than the list of does and don'ts associated with putting the P47 into any dive.
Actually, I referred to a paragraph out of the manual.
See my former post and look under Handling/Dive...
There is nothing misleading there.
Its the counteraction required of the trim tab that made it dangerous.
Going from countering "nose up" tendency to countering a "nose down" tendency in the event of compressibility.
It actually forbids the use of the trim in the event of compressibility and requires the pilot to use the control column alone.
Looking at the paragraph above that one, the pilot would also need to combat yaw, not uncommon when diving in most planes even the P-47.
The P-47: Most of what you refer to is the procedure for dive recovery in the event of compressibility which is a bit more extensive, otherwise normal procedure isn't that complicated but there are more limitations on the types of maneuvers the plane can perform going into a dive, such as a split S at full throttle.
It also states that at that time, it was a better understood phenomenon, something that earlier may have made compressibility more dangerous.
Anyways...
How does that make the later Spitfire less than ideal for high altitude flying?
Well, buy comparison if it needs to dive to hold a higher sustained turn than either P-47 or P-51, then its already losing altitude over those two birds.
If high speed dives are too dangerous to manage with trim in a Spit XIV, then it requires the pilot to manage all the force of the control column through
the dive which might also keep the pilot from diving as aggressively, perhaps at a shallower angle.
Fuel...The manual says 15,000ft with rear tank filled. My guess would be if it was intended to fly higher than that it would use the tank to climb, probably something
that was calculated in the field. Anyway, not much range, which also limits time in the air something already discussed earlier.