No I don't take it as fact but it should be representitive. But I suppose I deserved that one.
Its not even close to representative wmaxt, its downright BS.
AS I posted Rall compared the Spitfire to the P-38.
There is also a well known competition with a Spit Griffon that the P-38 dominated.
Stienhoff stated "the clear superority of the Lightning in speed and maneuverability over our aircraft"
Galland couldn't get away.
Knoke couldn't close
The AAF pilots belived they could and they actually flew P-38s in combat against Fw-190s - I'm willing to bet your German pilots, judging from their remarks, never saw a P-38, or bounced the one they did.
last here is a test by the British of a F model againse a SpitIX and comparison with a Fw-190 on the Docs page.
http://prodocs.netfirms.com
Rall

Why does everyone always quote Rall ?
Rall never dared fly any a/c to its true limits, and there are many examples of this, one being that after one near fatal accident in a 109E where one slat jammed in a banking maneuver sending Rall into a vicious spin, caused him never to even attempt flying the 109 at the verge of stall anymore. So then what makes you think he'll try the same maneuver in a Fw-190 then ? Thats right, he wouldn't, he had already specialized himself in B&Z tactics and had become an expert at it, so thats the tactic he was going to use no-matter the a/c.
Thats great, but I was talking about the Fw-190 wmaxt, and it certainly had a better roll rate than what you make out to be. (Up to 180 degree's/sec )
Btw, that is an impressive roll rate for the P-38 I must admit though.
It was done and witnessed. My pilots handbook for the P-38 gives a power on full flaps gear down minimum speed at 67mph
The P-38 had very effective flaps, there's no getting around that, but deploying full flaps was impossible in a dogfight wmaxt.
Sorry, I gave you examples where it was done, who did it, the opinions of "Both" sides that even give the P-38 an edge on the very best the Germans had. That should be enough to pique your intrest to find out for yourself. All you've come up with is derision, flat statements, and a couple of quotes from German pilots that probably never encountered a P-38.
Sorry but I take RAF and USAF tests with Axis aricraft with a BIG grain of salt, especially the Fw-190 tests, as both aileron and engine problems were ignored. The Navy's Fw-190 and Faber's Fw-190 both exibited aileron flutter and reversal, leading to premature stalling in turns or any violent pitch maneuver. The LW mech's knew about this problem and routinely checked and corrected it, but Allied mech's didn't, not until well after the war where no further tests were carried out.
And about the RAF's 109 tests, they're just too ridiculous, flying them against their own cleanly loaded fighters while still having cannon pods attached and pissing their pants each time the slats deploy thinking the airplane is going to stall. Those tests are just worthless, absolutely worthless..
Four out of five German aircraft that met P-38s, 5 out of six in the MTO, didn't make it home. The fifth got the P-38, he, with some right probably thought it wasn't capable. Did they really or was it a successful bounce, The P-38 was a turkey for the first 30 seconds if caught unawares when the pilot was switching from cruise to combat mode.
And where exactly are you getting those stats wmaxt ?
The P-38's tally is result of ground kills and bouncing unaware LW boys on their way home from a bomber intercepting mission. If the P-38's had normally engaged an aware Fw-190 or 109 pilot it would have been a different story.
Fact is most LW boys got shot down as a result of a bounce, one where they never even knew they being bounced until they were hit, and then it was usually too late.
Areodynamic certaintiy? Heres a couple of examples of why the P-38 works as well as it does
1, high aspect ratio of 8 giving high speed while preserving maneuverability and climb.
2, Power was split doubling prop sweopt area giving efficent use of the power available and for above average pilots differential throttle control. Trim changes were minimal, single engine aircraft change trim every time power changes. Central guns.
3, Tail length to chord ratio in the P-38 was 4:1, most fighters had a ratio of 2/2.5:1. The longer ratio gives more torque to the controls and lets them be smaller for less drag for the same effect. it also lowered control forces
4, the J-25 and L models had hydralic ailerons that got better as the speed increased even after it became too hard for other planes to maintain their roll rate.
Here's a couple you forgot:
1)Massive flat plate area
2)High power-loading
3)High lift-loading
4)Disturbed airflow over the wings because of engine placement
5)High aspect ratio wing advantage ruined by engine placement
6)Low CL-max of tip airfoil
Those were some of the most important, but there's plenty more...
Well if its all the old propaganda I can see where your coming from. I'm dissapointed you won't even considder looking into it, I've certainly given enough info to question it.
Old propaganda ? Do you believe that the USAF's museum archives are dealing out propaganda ?
Btw, by your logic the Bf-110 was one hell of a dogfighter !
