What was the worst Aircraft of WWII?

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

The I-16 Unstable? is it true that it had a habit of stalling in flight but....i bet the I-153 wasn't stable enough to physically ram enemy aircraft out of the sky and remain airbourne itself...the I-16 could and did it was incredibly tough and stable
 
Stability for aircraft doesn't mean how structurally sound/strong the airframe is. Its got to do with aerodynamic force acting on the plane and the likes and not being able to fly into another plane and continue flying.

Examples:
The SB2C Helldiver had unsatisfactory low-speed stability, it was unstable in high-speed dives, and

The P-51D had pretty bad directional stability when the spin was taken off of the B/C versions and a bubble canopy was added due to the lost keel area, so they put on a dorsal fin to provide for better directional stability.

And specific to the I-16:
The aircraft soon proved to be rather difficult to fly - it was almost unstable under all three axes, and had to be flown with ceaseless attention.
From http://www.nzfpm.co.nz/aircraft/i16.htm

In actual fact, the I-16 became quite unstable and required more attention from the pilot since it reacted to the slightest handling. Nevertheless, the I-16 boasted an excellent airspeed.
http://www.flugzeugwerk.net/I-16.htm

http://www.danford.net/nomon2.htm

Without knowing anything about the I-16, I would assume it was unstable if Google found many sites when the search words are "I-16 unstable", or else there's a very large misunderstanding.
 
Archer i don't know enough about the I-16 to argue any further points, i'll bow to your superior knowledge on this one - i must admit i had heard the I-16 was a bitch to fly but i didn't know the extent of the problems it encountered - i shall sit corrected


cheers
 
Just as a general point of interest - is it true that the reason the Americans so stubbornly insisted on daylight bombing raids was because they said that you could bomb better in daylight cos you could see the target? if thats true wouldn't the Norden bombsight have iradicated that problem? i heard it knew exacly where the target was gonna be as it took the aircrafts speed etc etc to calculate when they'd be over a target - and does anyone know where the expression "drop the bomb right in the pickle barrel" did they actually manage that or is it just a daft expression? Please don't tease me too harshly if i got it stupidly wrong! i don't know much about the subject
 
amy? i thought it was helen.... o well just old me getting myself confused in things and im just wondering, but how come u europeans prefer msn messenger over AIM? aim is so much simpler....
 

Users who are viewing this thread