- Thread starter
-
- #121
Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
Which NCO was derelict in his duties?I think the second most dangerous experience I had was being with an Officer who had a map - and a compass !
I always thought you guys were exaggerating with stories like this but...A US Marine officer who served in Vietnam told me that once his tank unit was paralleling an infantry unit on a sweep through the jungle, and the commanding infantry officer came over and asked him where they were. The tanker basically had been following the infantry unit but had been more or less keeping track of where they were. He showed the infantry guy a spot on the map, who responded, "We can't be there! We are not supposed to be there!" and then told one of his NCO's to bring over a compass. He then laid the compass on top of the M48, where the needle just spun around. The infantry officer scooped up the compass, said, "It's broke! Get me another one!" and tossed it back to the NCO.
There is no reason to think that a compass laid atop a huge steel object with a running engine and operating radios would not read correctly, is there?
And that is why the inf walks.A US Marine officer who served in Vietnam told me that once his tank unit was paralleling an infantry unit on a sweep through the jungle, and the commanding infantry officer came over and asked him where they were. The tanker basically had been following the infantry unit but had been more or less keeping track of where they were. He showed the infantry guy a spot on the map, who responded, "We can't be there! We are not supposed to be there!" and then told one of his NCO's to bring over a compass. He then laid the compass on top of the M48, where the needle just spun around. The infantry officer scooped up the compass, said, "It's broke! Get me another one!" and tossed it back to the NCO.
There is no reason to think that a compass laid atop a huge steel object with a running engine and operating radios would not read correctly, is there?
In Germany a dumb 2nd Lt who couldn't read a map almost led a Corporal Missile Bn over the border into Czechoslovakia.And that is why the inf walks.
I think they only teach gps nowadays. Dead reconing is not difficult. Just have to shoot two back azimuths from two known points. Hopefully you can find two known points and not just left tree and right tree. There is nothing like a several hours across Germany drive in the dead of winter with thick fog and snow at night to an area outside of the area you reconned the month before. Impressed the f*** out of Sqdrn staff. All done in a M1 prior to gps. To bad, the Co Cmdr forgot he sent me there. I got there on time, set up the battle position, coordinated with an 8th inf Plt that was blocking the main road through a small town. I found a nice place with flanking shots covering the main road. The orange units came sailing down the road to fight the inf. We popped up and wanted firing instructions from the co. I was told not to engage yet. My gunners were drooling. I sent in a spot report. CO said to hold fire. He returned on the radio, where the h*** are you LT. At the CP you order me to down south at 0100 hrs this morning. I did not send you there meet us at some check point I don't remember. Let's see, you sent your driver to my BP when I just went to my 3o minutes of sleep for the night to wake me up to tell me to call you on the radio. I chewed on the Plt because no one was on radio watch and I got busted for it. The co wanted me to radio him so he could tell me to relocate to the south. It's rough being a Lt. At lease I was an O2 and not an O1. Sorry, I got side tracked.I always thought you guys were exaggerating with stories like this but...
There's currently a TV series on down here with teams trying to move from point A to point B while being tracked by ex NZSAS soldiers. There was one team who had an ex US 'Special Forces' on it who ended up moving 180º from where they were meant to be, and then spent the next day going around in circles trying to work out where they were.
Don't they teach basic map work in the military over there?
Don't they teach basic map work in the military over there?
I think they only teach gps nowadays.
So the concept of 'continued competence' doesn't exist for the miliitary?No, standard map and compass land navigation is still taught. Its just whether any of them remember it after they get to an operational unit.
It's like when I was learning to fly. We were not allowed to use a GPS. Just a sectional, instruments, stop watch, and E6B. Why? Because those items never experience a dead battery.
So the concept of 'continued competence' doesn't exist for the miliitary?
All of my licence renewals consist of dead reckoning for the nav.