This I can't agree with. The Perseus, Mercury and Pegasus were good engines, as was the Hercules then under development. Their issue was not that they were no good, but that power output was insufficient for a modern all-metal fighter, and the Air Ministry was right to not purchase and waste time on developing radial engined fighters pre-WW2 because the Merlin gave the necessary power required and offered more potential. Remember that the Hurricane's contemporary was the P-36 and it had a more powerful radial in the '1830, by nearly 200 hp than the Merlin II in the Hurri Mk.I, and it was smaller than the Hurri, yet the Hurri was (marginally) faster and had a better ceiling. And that's not mentioning the Spitfire and its even greater speed margin over the P-36.
I'm not picking on you SR, just that I'm supporting what you are saying from the same thread, except the engine thing.
I didn't say the engines weren't very good, I said the engine
installations weren't very good and they weren't. Poor cowlings and poor exhaust set ups.
I don't know why they didn't try to use the Pegasus as a fighter engine except to speculate about it's frontal area although the US (and Russians) sure built a lot fighters using the Wright Cyclone and licensed copies.
The P-36 had a less powerful engine than the Hurricane. This gets complicated as some of the export Hawk 75s used slightly different R-1830s than the US Army P-36s did. Throw in the Hawk 75s powered by Wright R-1820 Cyclones and power is all over the place.
The US Army P-36s used a single speed supercharger on their R-1830s and while it offered 1200hp for take-off (2700rpm) it was rated at 1050hp max continuous (2550rpm) at 6500ft.
One plane got a higher gear on the supercharger and was rated at 1100hp for take-off, and 950hp at 14,300ft at 2700rpm. The production planes with the lower supercharger gear would have been worse, At low altitude they may have had more power than the Hurricane but in the middle teens the Hurricane had 100 hp or more (200hp?) .
The early planes may never have gotten a "military" rating and I mean
military not
WEP as all the speed tests were done at 2550rpm. Power seems to be 825-850hp at 15,000ft in level flight (using a torque meter). Climb ratings seem to be 755to 780hp at 2550rpm at 15,000ft so the engine was well past it's critical altitude.
I would note that the Mercury was good for 840hp at 14,000ft which wasn't bad at all for a 1520 cu in engine. It just isn't good enough by the late 30s.
The American radial installations may or may not have been better than the British ones, they look better

But looks are not test results.
That doesn't mean they were good enough to compete with liquid cooled V-12s at this point in time. The P-36 was supposed to have 22% more drag than an early P-40 but this may not count the difference in exhaust thrust which was much better on the P-40.
The P-36 needed a lot more power to cruise at the same speeds as an early P-40 which confirms the difference in drag.