wuzak
Captain
How is it done?
For example, one comparison is made between a Mosquito and B-17. Often it states that they could take the same bomb load (ie 4000lb) to Berlin, but in actual fact the B-17 could take more (5000-6000lb).
In the case of the Mosquito the bomb load is one 4000lb HC (typically) or one 4000lb MC (rarely, I think).
The B-17 load can be made up of 2000lb, 1000lb, 500lb and smaller bombs.
The 4000lb HC bomb had around 75% of its weight in explosive material. The 4000lb MC bomb around 58%.
The high explosive US bombs were typically 50-55% charge to weight ratio.
So, a 6000lb B-17 bomb load would be approximately 3000-3300lb of explosives.
The 4000lb Mosquito bomb load would be arond 2300-3000lbs.
But which is more effective?
I suppose the effectiveness also is dependent on the accuracy of delivery, the type of target to be hit, etc.
I must admit it had never occurred to me to compare weight of explosives rather than weight of bombs, having thought about it when answering a question on another forum.
Is it best to compare explosives weight, assuming similar types of explosives, or the overall weight of bombs?
For example, one comparison is made between a Mosquito and B-17. Often it states that they could take the same bomb load (ie 4000lb) to Berlin, but in actual fact the B-17 could take more (5000-6000lb).
In the case of the Mosquito the bomb load is one 4000lb HC (typically) or one 4000lb MC (rarely, I think).
The B-17 load can be made up of 2000lb, 1000lb, 500lb and smaller bombs.
The 4000lb HC bomb had around 75% of its weight in explosive material. The 4000lb MC bomb around 58%.
The high explosive US bombs were typically 50-55% charge to weight ratio.
So, a 6000lb B-17 bomb load would be approximately 3000-3300lb of explosives.
The 4000lb Mosquito bomb load would be arond 2300-3000lbs.
But which is more effective?
I suppose the effectiveness also is dependent on the accuracy of delivery, the type of target to be hit, etc.
I must admit it had never occurred to me to compare weight of explosives rather than weight of bombs, having thought about it when answering a question on another forum.
Is it best to compare explosives weight, assuming similar types of explosives, or the overall weight of bombs?