Falkland Islands War, Would aerial torpedoes have worked better than bombs?

[CharlesBronson]

The Mk8 had almost 300 kg of explosive warhead, 6 times more than the 12,5 inches guided torpedos quoted above, it blew apart the good old Belgrano with no mercy.

 

[Glider]

Torpedo's were are and always will be lethal against shipping. The warhead of the Spearfish was a little smaller than the mk 8, 750 lbs of torpex vs 800 lbs but not enough to make any difference, it was the reliability that made the difference.

 

[PJay]

Nope she had the Tigerfish as well as the Mk 8, but these in the early version were unreliable and a second version was on board but was untried, so they went with the safe option, the Mk 8

Quite right sir. Memory is a fickle thing.