German logistics, purchase programs and war booty, reality and alternatives 1935-43

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

Seems like that Germans didn't know what to actually do with the G&R 14N engines. The report from 19th March 1943 says:

14MN.jpg

Roughly: out of 1400 of the 14N engines 'found' in France, 1000 are the complete engines, and 400 is the equivalent in the spare parts. Further engines 'found' will be delivered to the GL/E. Repair capacity is in both Germany (in Hameln) and in France.

Report that predates that, dated at 12th February, notes the intention to outfit the Me 323 with the 14N engines, and asks about the repair facility in Germany to cover these engines:

14MN-2.jpg

The even earlier report, from December 1942, is talking about the winterization of the Me 323/14N and the Ju 52/BMW 132 (because "sooner or later the Me 323 transporters will be going to the East"), especially about the oil system of the 14N:

14NM-3.jpg

Report from November 1942:

14MN-4.jpg

... comments that the further increase of Ju 52 production is not possible because of (lack of?) engines. The Me 323 is mooted as to be powered by the Alfa Romeo engines (radials?).
Idea for the AR engines for the Me 323 is mentioned in the October report.
Report from late July 1942 says that Me 323 'has not yet started' (presuming start of production?).

What might be a tl;dr from all of this?
Seems like it took Germans almost 2.5 years to figure out what to do with the war booty of 1000+400 of G&R 14N engines. Engines that, while not being roses and unicorns, were perfectly suitable to install in the transport aircraft, or to be send to Italy to bolster their feeble output of the aero engines. The attempt to make anything from the from the 14R series, that landed in the German lap in 1940, was all theory.
Germans felt the need to use the weakest of the meaningful French engines, the 14M; granted, these saved the Hs 129 program - lets give credit where credit is due. OTOH, a Ju 87 with a 14N in the nose might've been armed with two MK 101 or 103 guns and still give a fine service.
 
Seems like that Germans didn't know what to actually do with the G&R 14N engines. The report from 19th March 1943 says:

View attachment 821795

Roughly: out of 1400 of the 14N engines 'found' in France, 1000 are the complete engines, and 400 is the equivalent in the spare parts. Further engines 'found' will be delivered to the GL/E. Repair capacity is in both Germany (in Hameln) and in France.

Report that predates that, dated at 12th February, notes the intention to outfit the Me 323 with the 14N engines, and asks about the repair facility in Germany to cover these engines:

View attachment 821796

The even earlier report, from December 1942, is talking about the winterization of the Me 323/14N and the Ju 52/BMW 132 (because "sooner or later the Me 323 transporters will be going to the East"), especially about the oil system of the 14N:

View attachment 821797

Report from November 1942:

View attachment 821798

... comments that the further increase of Ju 52 production is not possible because of (lack of?) engines. The Me 323 is mooted as to be powered by the Alfa Romeo engines (radials?).
Idea for the AR engines for the Me 323 is mentioned in the October report.
Report from late July 1942 says that Me 323 'has not yet started' (presuming start of production?).

What might be a tl;dr from all of this?
Seems like it took Germans almost 2.5 years to figure out what to do with the war booty of 1000+400 of G&R 14N engines. Engines that, while not being roses and unicorns, were perfectly suitable to install in the transport aircraft, or to be send to Italy to bolster their feeble output of the aero engines. The attempt to make anything from the from the 14R series, that landed in the German lap in 1940, was all theory.
Germans felt the need to use the weakest of the meaningful French engines, the 14M; granted, these saved the Hs 129 program - lets give credit where credit is due. OTOH, a Ju 87 with a 14N in the nose might've been armed with two MK 101 or 103 guns and still give a fine service.
You might be interested in my recent uploads of the boxes AI 3 D 334 1 and GR 3 P 141 here:

The former deals with Vichy era aircraft production plans and agreements with Germany, while the latter rather deals with licenses/production plans and requests for ground equipment, either requests from Vichy itself or from the Germans. IIRC some of the spare parts weren't even intended stock or new production, but simply parts that were supposed to go in production materiel in 1940 that were left idle.

It says a lot that some mid 1941 and 42 OKW requests are still about refitting Hotchkiss tanks, completing unbuilt turrets and guns or refitting Somua S35s with S40 engines...All stuff that could have been made almost immediately after the Armistice.
 
Further about the tank busters.
The Fw 190 armed with two MK 103s was found to not to be such a good idea since the stress from the recoil was too harsh. Or that is my understanding of the matter. However - perhaps have it carry two MK 101s? Rate of fire is far smaller (talk 60% of what the MK 103 was doing), so the total stress on the wing might be not that bad? Install an even bigger muzzle brake for each gun.
 
Seems like that Panzerschreck fired from the Fw 190s stood a good chance for killing tanks - 52 190s supposedly destroyed 14 tanks, and damaged another 4 (although we don't know in how many sorties, and how many actual rockets were used):

antiPz.jpg

That is despite the low MV (105 m/s); each Fw 190 carried 12 Panzerschreks.
Panzerblitz was to be available in two flavors, the initial (325 m/s initial velocity) and improved (385 m/s).
The rocket-dispenser, that deployed 14 SD4s via two missiles and while using timed fuse was also considered.
 
Some alternative German fighters, that might represent the resources better spent:
- initial small & light Fw 190 powered by a V12 engine (DB 601 preferably) already in 1941 - leaves a lot of good features of the 190 (rate of roll, small drag, good cockpit, good if not great internal volume for such a small fighter, excellent fuel load), and removes the main problem before late 1942 - unreliable, heavy and gas-guzzling engine
- He 100 with the normal cooling
- Fw 187 with good V12s - should combine the agility of the Bf 109 with the protection and powerful firepower of the Fw 190 for the day fighter duties, and might be the best platform for another step in firepower, talk 2-3 MK 103 cannons or the equivalent; also, it should do well bombed-up, or as a recon

Something gets axed - obviously the whole Bf 110/210/410 series, as well as many Bf 109s past 1942?
 
- He 100 with the normal cooling
I would take the He112B over any He100 (as much as I like the He100) because the 112 held much more potential.

Longer range, better firepower potential and it's performance was comparable to the Bf109 at the time.

It may not have been a world speed record setter, but it would have made a solid adversary.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back