The 109 was a slow to medium-speed dogfoghter and was at a breat disadvantage when going faster then 300 mph. In its envelope, it was very good.
At 400+ mph, it was running or relocating for attack at slower speed ... not trying to fight. At 400 mph, it could not even aim at something 20° off it's course with anything like quickness.
200 mph? Beware the 109.
450 mph? Ignore the 109 as it wasn't able to do anything. Not so the Mustang, the La5 FN, LA-7, Stptfire IX/XIV, Tempest, even the P-38 (got sluggish at higher speed than 400 mph). The P-47 was better at 400+ mph than it was at 280 mph.
The Me 109 was similar to the Zero in that it was a slowmedium--speed dogfighter. To beat it, go fast and don;t slow down. If it saw you, it could run at high speed or climb steeply, but could not do much else. That is for ALL variants, including the last one. High top speed doesn't mean maneuverability at same, and it did not have it and never did.
It is still one of my candidates for the best fighter of all times due to war record and kills scored.
Due to pilots? Maybe, but it DID score well. But the best-performing piston fighter airframe as far as handling in air combat? Never, no way. All you have to do is talk with a pilot who has flown both the Me 109 and Mustang to know. You cannot ask someone who has not flown both due to no basis for comparison. Ditto the Spitfire. The late-war Russian Lavochkins and Yaks were WAY better at low-to-medium altitudes. Many a 109 stalled and spun in trying to follow a Yak or Lavochkin in a low-altitude hard turn. If the Messerschmitts or Focke-Wulfs flew higher, the Russian ignored them and attacked troops and equipment. So the German fighters HAD to come down and fight or watch their troops be shot up. That's why they suffered so many casualties ... they came down and fought in the best envelope for the La's and Yaks, from necessity.
All you 109 fans, remember the Luftwaffe was shot out of the sky by the Soviets in mid-1943 - 1945 after having done the same to the Soviets in earlier times. The ground troops were soundly defeated (yes, with the help of winter, which the Soviets had been counting on, but is true nonetheless). They did it with FUEL, good pilots, tactics, and from having learned what did NOT work. Many Luftwaffe 109's and 190's were lost to even P-39's, which were not bad at all when able to fight at 12,000 feet or less. Check the Soviet scores and see.
True, Hartmann, Barkhorn, and Rall were on that front and achieved their scores, but they were not always in the right place at the right time. Don't even try to tell me that they weren't harassed and even shot down themselves, they were. Hartman was shot down 16 times and Rall was shot donw 8 times. Don't have the figures for Barkhorn just now. After all, they were only three guys and three Messerschmitts, even though they were the best.