Sunderland Vs Catalina

cheddar cheese · May 20, 2004

and you call yourself an englishman, indeed, 'old bean' is a well like phrase round here chappy and yes, the sunderland was better 8) but look! no-ones argueing with us because its true 8) so lets hark back to the good ol' days and spam

the lancaster kicks ass · May 20, 2004

and you call yourself an englishman,

but i'm a cornishman..............

cheddar cheese · May 20, 2004

cornwall is a county of england and to think youre top set geography...

Lightning Guy · May 20, 2004

Cat - longer range, more versatile, more successful at sinking U-boats (the Sunderland's main duty), and probably the equal at defending itself (fewer guns, but heavier).

plan_D · May 21, 2004

And all that equals Cat, better.

You lot have sets for Geography? We didn't we just had sets for Science and Maths, which I was top in both.

the lancaster kicks ass · May 22, 2004

we're setted in quite a few of our lessons, i am, of course, in top set for all.................

plan_D · May 25, 2004

I took the Higher GCSE exam, in everything that I took.

cheddar cheese · May 25, 2004

im top setted for all too, but you already knew that

the lancaster kicks ass · May 25, 2004

back on topic, the sunderland looked better than the cat, that's one of the things me and C.C. agree on..................

Lightning Guy · May 25, 2004

I still say the Sunderland looked too fat. The Cat had a sleeker look to its hull.

cheddar cheese · May 26, 2004

me think the cat did look better, yes, but the sunderland was better 8)

plan_D · May 26, 2004

The Cat was better and better looking than the Sunderland.

cheddar cheese · May 26, 2004

i need reinforcements, i cant win an argument just by saying it was better (it was better BTW )

the lancaster kicks ass · May 26, 2004

i cant win an argument just by saying it was better

yes you can, after all, i'm backing you up, you can't loose when i'm on your side................

Lightning Guy · May 26, 2004

But you haven't put forth any true arguments as to why the Sunderland should be considered better in a while. Fact: The Cat had longer range, ie. endurance. Fact: The Cat was more versatile, patrol, torp bombing, night bombing, barge-busting. Fact: The Cat sank more U-boats. There are three good reasons why the Cat was better.

the lancaster kicks ass · May 26, 2004

The Cat was more versatile, patrol, torp bombing, night bombing

you can't use that as the sunderland wasn't needed for these roles...............

cheddar cheese · May 26, 2004

the lancaster kicks ass said:
i cant win an argument just by saying it was better

Click to expand...

yes you can, after all, i'm backing you up, you can't loose when i'm on your side................

yes i can, you're a liability

Lightning Guy · May 26, 2004

Ok, Lanc, even if you discount that (which I don't think you should), you still haven't given me a reason why the Sunderland was better.

plan_D · May 27, 2004

I don't need to be here on LGs side, but I am. The Cat sinking more U-Boats equals more damage to enemy, therefore more effective than the Sunderland.

Lightning Guy · May 27, 2004

And shouldn't that really be the bottom line? The Cat hurt the Germans more than the Sunderland.

Sunderland Vs Catalina

Major General

Major General

Major General

Master Sergeant

Lieutenant Colonel

Major General

Lieutenant Colonel

Major General

Major General

Master Sergeant

Major General

Lieutenant Colonel

Major General

Major General

Master Sergeant

Major General

Major General

Master Sergeant

Lieutenant Colonel

Master Sergeant

Users who are viewing this thread

Similar threads