Could a Hurri really out-turn an Me?
The Hurri could take punishment and some had armour field-upgrades.
I also think the engine was tougher?
Plus it was fighting on home turf...
I take it we're discussing the Spit MkI/II and the Emil?
Well in that case I'd put the two equal, depending on pilot choice.
The Me was better @ high alt, the Spit @ lower. The Me could choose the venue, but it was (on Goerings orders) at the Spits best level.
For me, it would depend on the day, but if I weren't allowed the hub cannon on the Emil, then it'd probably always be the Spit.