This is why I do not have much regard for Eric Brown as a expert on the various types of WW-II planes.
Sure, he flew them all and has a huge resume', but anyone who thinks the Spit 14 was a great plane is either a Nationalistic Fan Boy, or delusional.
He may have know his stuff just a little better than you....
It was slow to service and had to have many defects fixed before it was considered safe to send out into less experienced hands.
I'd like to see a source for that.
As for slow to service, it was no longer than many of its contemporaries.
The size and area of the Verticle fin and rudder were both enlarged two or three times depending on who said what and how much of an enlargement we are talking about.
The fin was the same size, the rudder area increased.
Also, not an unusual thing to happen in prototype aircraft.
It was too heavy and they almost universally removed two of the four 20 mm guns to aid the rate of role and rate of turn.
Too heavy? Compared to what?
Apart from a small number of Mk Vs, and the later 20-series models (with new wings) none of the Spitfires were equipped with 4 20mm cannon. The usual armament was 2 x 20mm plus 4 x 0.303" at the start of production and later it was 2 x 20mm plus 2 x 0.50" when the E-wing came along (also used in the IX and XVI).
The Spitfire could give away quite a bit turn radius and still be comfortably turn inside a 109 or 190. The Spitfire XIV didn't roll as fast as a Fw 190A, but not much did. It was comfortably faster in roll rate than the Bf 109 and could out-roll most other allied aircraft up to 350mph IAS.
Most actual Spitfire pilots of the war claimed that either the Mk-V was the best of the lot in terms of how it flew, or they preferred the faster and more powerful Mk-IX even with it's snaking and poor pointability. The -IX's four bladed prop started the round of increasing the area of the tail to cure stability problems and the five bladed prop on the XIV made it down right dangerous until the "Spitful" tail was installed.
Dangerous?
The XIV required change of rudder trim with throttle changes.
Snaking? Poor pointability?
You are aware that the P-51B and -D suffered problems with lack of fin/rudder area too? Solved with the larger tail of the -H.
Then there is the fact that nearly, or more than, one year elapsed between the Mk-XIV's entry into service and it's first kill! If it was so great, why was that? How many pilots made Ace in the Mk-XIV? I mean during that exact same period of time that the -XIV was in service AFTER it's first kill and getting fixed, there were fifteen or twenty times as many new pilots who made Ace in the older types of Spit! IIRC only 22, or maybe 28 pilots made ace in the Mk-XIV? I've got the Osprey book on it someplace.
You better get your old Osprey book out and start quoting.
The Spitfire XIV became operational in January 1944.
It's first enemy aircraft kill was in 1944, but after they were used against the V-1s. I don't have the actual date, but it wasn't more than a year.
In any case, the lack of success speaks more to the lack of opportunity than any issues with the ability of the aircraft.
So, we have the opinion of a test pilot, with how many kills on the side of the Mk-XIV Spit, Vs the Opinion of Major General, IIRC, Chuck Yeager who thought the P-51 was the Cat's Meow, Vs America's top ace who thought the P-38 was it and Russia's top ace who thought the Yac-3, or P-39 was the best, or the Top Jap who shot down 86+- planes in a Zero and the top 300 Aces of all time who like the Me-109 for some unknown and totally mysterious reason! ( Given that it had less of almost everything than any of the other choises above!)
Dick Chuck Yeager fly a Spitfire XIV? Eric Brown flew P-51s.
Did Bong fly a Spitfire XIV? Eric Brown flew a P-38.
Brown didn't fly a Yak-3, but he flew a Yak-1, a Yak-9 and a Yak-11. Did the Russian ace fly a Spitfire XIV?
Brown did also fly the P-39.
And he flew several variants of the Bf 109.
He may have known a thing or two about the qualities of fighters.
List of aircraft flown by Eric "Winkle" Brown - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
btw the reason that the Bf 109 scored so many more kills than any other aircraft was simple opportunity. They were built in more numbers than any other fighter of WW2, flew more combat sorties than any other WW2 fighter, had more engagements than any other WW2 fighter.