Light fighters alternatives, 1935-1945 (3 Viewers)

How heavy were the heavy fighters? Say, in 1943?
This comes from my collection of Profile Publications. For comparison, a P47D-22RE weighed 9,900lb empty, 13,500lb normally loaded, and 15,000lb maximum loaded. The engine had 2,300HP.

AircraftEmpty weightLoaded weightPower
Messerschmitt Bf 110G-411,220 lb20,700 lb2X 1,475 HP
Messerschmitt Me 410A-1/U213,550 lb23,500 lb2X 1,750 HP
Bristol Beaufighter Mk I13,800 lb21,000 lb2X 1,400 HP
 
While the ship has sailed in this thread on Hosho (pun intended); IJN's 1st carrier couldn't fit Claude's in its hanger without modification.

As S Shortround6 alluded in his post, the reason the Mitsubishi 1MF had to have a wingspan of only 8.5m, was the forward hanger was only 9.5m wide. So, the 11m wingspan A5M isn't going to fit. It won't even fit with folding wingtips ala Zero or Seafire. You have to put a fold mid-aileron to get the Claude to be able to fit (Aichi has such a fold on the Val, so the "B" team could be assigned to make the change. Then you could fit 8 of Mitsubishi's 1st monoplane naval fighter in the forward hanger (down from 9 1MFs as the A5M is about 10% longer). How much does an additional 100kg for the wing fold hurt the Claude's performance??

I'm not sure you can fit more than 4 Nakajima Kates in the 2 level aft hanger versus 6 of the older Judy's.

A lot of work for a little CAP/reconnaissance.

There is part of me that says having 4 Rufe fighters on each of the Chitose class seaplane tenders/pair on each of the Tone CAs ready to launch for CAP would have been better bang for the buck (basically same speed, but much better armament).
 
The twin-engined Westland Whirlwinds and Lockheed P38 Lightnings were twin-engined, but small. They had good power loading, so they could mix it with regular fighters. The Messerschmitt Bf110 successfully used hit and run tactics against obsolete fighters in Poland, Norway, the low countries and France. When they went up against aircraft that could keep up with them, they lacked the manoeuverability to complete attacks, or get out of trouble. The later Messerschmitt Me410 could just about keep up with the contemporary single-seat fighters, but again, it could not manoeuvre.

Heavy fighters were successful when they performed missions that did not involve fighting single-engined fighters in clear daylight. They could carry radar for night fighting, and they could carry heavy bomb loads as fighter-bombers.

The P-38 was almost as big as the de Havilland Mosquito, though a bit lighter.

The Bf 110 and Me 210 were marginally bigger than the P-38. The Me 210 was baout the same weights, the Bf 110 was lighter.

The Wastland Whirlwind was quite a bit smaller and lighter than the P-38.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

  • Back