Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
The text states that they are "claims" but on Sept 24 it states that his "claims" were forwarded to higher command and intercepted by ULTRA.
Compared with the claims recorded in 11,400 traceable air to air combat reports (form 1151), covering all RAF fighter pilots' claims, 55% were by Hurricane pilots, 33% by Spitfire pilots and 12% by pilots of other fighters.
(Please don't shoot me, I'm just the messenger)
Funny how the conclusion now is that the LW should've concentrated more on bombers in NA, the same directive that led to her quick demise over France and Germany a few years later. Of course whenever that scenario is discussed everyone is quick to point out how stupid Goering was by concentrating on attacking the bombers. But it doesn't matter, the goal seems to be more in line with "if Marseille wasn't a liar he was at least an arrogant prick with no regards for the life of his comrades on the ground".
About what you are talking?
The Axis were attacking till Alamein! Do you understand attacking not defending!
Rommel had endless fights with the Luftwaffe to actually get them some cover to stop his supply lines being hit, and anywhere they stopped and dug in.
They did not act as well as they did in France by any means, with close coordination to overall strategic and tactical plans.
The average German (and Italian) soldier mostly never saw a friendly aircraft above them, even when the numbers on both sides were close (or on the Axis's side).
But were the numbers ever close..?
Much was made of individual experten by the Nazi propaganda machinery.
In western allied air forces, particularly the RAF, much more emphasis was placed on a team effort rather than individual brilliance.
I wouldn't in general say the LW didn't do teamwork.
Strafing of sand/sand dunes was common, usually practicing deflection shooting by trying to hit there own planes shadow.
It is arguable that the problem of fraudulent claiming was exacerbated in the Luftwaffe by the way the system worked. Much was made of individual experten by the Nazi propaganda machinery. Certain awards were more or less directly linked to certain scores. The system encouraged fraud in some unscrupulous individuals. I still believe that despite this, these men were a small minority and that most claimed in good faith.
In western allied air forces, particularly the RAF, much more emphasis was placed on a team effort rather than individual brilliance. Nonetheless over claiming remained a problem for intelligence officers throughout the war.
Cheers
Steve
They also NEVER question the claims made by Western, particularly the RAF Aces...
I never said there wasn't over claiming, be it intentional or unintentional. You mentioned strafing sands dunes, and I told you one reason why they did that.But not then returning to claim fraudulent aerial victories. This is about blatant fraudulent claiming in the summer of 1942, outright lying, there is no nicer way to express it. You seem to be wilfully missing the point.