...searching for the best USAAF interceptor...

Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules

Hey plan D,
How are you?
Thanks for the help… But what did I say/type that led you to believe I had made an error? What are you trying to tell me, or remind me of?

As you said XP-51 was the first American designation, but as the 'series' goes it was the second, if you are going to be 'nit picky' the NA-73X was the first, prototypes are always 1st in the series, and I believe you are mistaken in regard to the 'order' of models... As uasual…too much info below

Original privately financed prototype the NA-73X prototype contract was signed on May 23, 1940. On May 29, a provisional RAF procurement was issued for 320 aircraft, contingent on satisfactory testing of the prototype. NAA agreed to start deliveries in January 1941. In a contract approved on September 20, 1940, it was agreed that the fourth and tenth production NA-73s would be the planes diverted to the Army. The designation XP-51 was to be assigned to these two planes.

Vance Breese flew the NA-73X for the first time on October 26, 1940. On November 20, 1940 test pilot Paul Balfour forgot to change fuel tanks, ran out of gas, and the plane ended up on its back in a farmer's field.

In December 1940, the RAF ordered 300 more of the Mustang Is which embodied minor modifications, assigned NA-73 by NAA.

The NA-73X aircraft resumed flying on January 11, 1941 and continued in the initial development program until being retired on July, 1941.

During testing there were several changes in the geometry of the ventral ducting and the controllable flaps. By the time that the NA-73 had been cleared for production, the duct had had its inlet moved downward so that its upper lip was lower than the underside of the wing, thus avoiding the ingestion of a turbulent boundary layer of air into the radiator cooler.

Since the NA-73X had encountered very few problems during tests, production for the RAF began almost immediately, but the first production Mustang I for the RAF flew for the first time on April 23, 1941, well behind the original schedule. Most of the first 20 RAF Mustang Is were retained by NAA for special measurements and trial installations, designated NA-83 by the factory.

The fourth and tenth NA-73s, XP-51s were delivered to the US Army in May of 1941 for testing at Wright Field, Ohio. Inexplicably, no Army orders were forthcoming.

NA-73s finally arriving in Liverpool on October 24, 1941, had lacked a radio, a gunsight, and certain other equipment which was by contract to be supplied by British manufacturers. The completed aircrafts were evaluated at the Aeroplane Armament Experimental Establishment at Boscome Down and by the Air Fighting Development Unit at RAF Duxford.

The newly-arrived Mustang was quickly recognized as being the best fighter aircraft yet to be delivered from the USA; it was superior to the Kittyhawk, Airacobra and Spitfire in both speed and maneuverability at low altitudes. Maximum speed was 382 mph at 13,000 feet. At all heights up to 20,000 feet, the Mustang was faster than any other fighter then in service with the RAF. Rate of climb, acceleration, speed in a dive, stability, handling in all configurations, rate of roll and radius of turn were all rated as being satisfactory to outstanding. Mustang's range was nearly double that of any other RAF single-engined fighter. It was 25 to 45 mph faster than the Spitfire V at altitudes up to 15,000 feet. Yet there was the rapid fall-off in performance above 15,000 feet, caused by its low-altitude Allison engine as it was supercharged for best performance at low levels. The relatively poor high altitude performance of the Mustang was more than just a minor deficiency, since most aerial combat over Europe at that time was taking place at medium to high altitudes.

The first RAF unit to receive the Mustang was No 26 Squadron at Gatwick which began to operate the fighter in February 1942. The first Mustang combat mission was undertaken by Flying Officer G. N. Dawson of No. 26 Squadron on May 10, 1942, strafing hangars in France and shooting up a train.

Tactical reports from RAF army cooperation units were; The Mustang I and IAs were able to take an incredible amount of battle damage; The range of the Mustang made it an excellent tactical reconnaissance aircraft and its heavy armament made it effective against most ground targets. At the time at sea level, the Mustang could run away from any enemy aircraft. The flaps were very useful in combat to reduce the turning radius. Mustang Is and IAs served with the RAF up until 1944. It knew few equals in the role of low-altitude interdiction and reconnaissance.

On March 11, 1941, the Lend/Lease Act was passed; September 25, '41, the US Army ordered 150 Mustangs under the provisions of Lend-Lease for delivery to Britain. Lend-Lease Mustangs were designated Mustang Mark IA by the RAF and NA-91 by the NAA factory. The British did not get all of these NA-91s. For contractual purposes, these aircraft were assigned the US designation of P-51. The Mustang IA differed from earlier versions in having the machine guns replaced by four 20-mm wing-mounted Hispano cannon, with most of the long barrels protruding well ahead of the wing. Throughout 1941, the Army referred to these aircraft under the name *Apache*, but this was changed to *Mustang* at about the time the deliveries began in mid- 1942, I do not have any info on the number, but as far as I can tell deliveries started with the Peterson Field Recon School in Colorado. In March of 1943, some 25 or so F-6A/P-51s were assigned to the 154th Observation Squadron at Oujda in French Morocco. This was the 1st US Mustang unit. The first mission was a photographic coverage of Kairouan airfield in Tunisia on April 10, 1943, which was the first USAAF Mustang mission of the war. The 1st combat loss was a friendly fire incident in which Allied AAA failed to recognize the difference between the F-6A/P-51 Me-109, with fatal results.

NA-73 Mustang Mk I: 1st batch of 320 aircraft for RAF
1,150-hp twelve-cylinder Vee liquid-cooled V-1710-F3R Allison engine
382 mph @ 13,000ft
Four 0.5-in and four 0.303-in machine guns (two .0.5s mounted on underside of engine fired through the prop)
Many fitted with cameras for reconnaissance

On April 16, 1942, the Army finally ordered 500 NA-97s. The NA-97 was a ground attack version and was designated A-36A. The A-36 seems to have been known by several different names--it was initially called *Apache*, which was the name that the Army initially assigned to the P-51, but there was an effort to change the name to Invader following the invasion of Sicily.

The A-36A differed from previous Mustang versions in having a set of hydraulically-operated perforated door-type dive brakes mounted on both the upper and lower wing surfaces outboard of the wing guns. The brakes were normally recessed into the wings, but were opened to 90 degrees by a hydraulic jack to hold diving speeds down to 250 mph. Armament of six 0.50-inch machine guns (two in lower fuselage nose, four in the wings) was fitted, however the two nose guns were often omitted in service. The wing guns were moved closer to the main landing gear strut in order to minimize stress under taxi and takeoff conditions.

The first A-36A flew on September 21, 1942. Deliveries of the A-36A were completed by the following March. The A-36A equipped the 27th and 86th Fighter Bomber Groups based in Sicily and in Italy. Both of these Groups arrived in North Africa in April of 1943 just after the end of the Tunisian campaign. Their first actions were attacks on the island of Pantelleria, starting on June 6, 1943. The only other Group was the 311, of which I know nothing, except they were based in India.

A-36A (NA-97) "Apache," later "Invader," finally "Mustang" dive bomber variant with hydraulic retractable dive brakes in wings
8,370 lbs normal, 10,700 lbs max
Six 0.5-in machine guns (two in lower fuselage nose four in the wings), 2 X 500 lbs bombs
Pylons for two 500-lbs bombs;
Allison twelve-cylinder Vee liquid-cooled V-1710-87 (F21R) 1325 hp at 3000 ft
356 mph @ 5000 ft "clean," 310 mph w/two 500-lbs bombs
500 built, three to RAF

The next Army contract for Mustangs consisted of an order on August 24, 1942 for 1200 NA-99 versions with the USAAF designation of P-51A, these aircraft from the start were meant to be fighters, not bombers. The first P-51A flew on February 3, 1943, and the first deliveries began the next month. 310 P-51As were actually built between March and May of 1943 as production was switched over to the Merlin-powered P-51B. 35 P-51As were fitted with twin-K24 camera installations and had their guns removed. These were designated F-6B. 50 P-51As went to the RAF, becoming Mustang IIs. The first P-51A group was the 54th, which remained in Florida for replacement training. Later, P-51As went to Asia with the 23rd, 311th, and 1st Air Commando Groups. Almost all of the P-51As served in the China, Burma, India (CBI) theatre of operations.
 
.....continued:

P-51A (NA-99)
6433 lbs empty, 8600 lbs normal, 10,600 lbs max
Allison V-1710-81 (export V-1710-F20R) engine, 1,200 hp @ takeoff , 1125 hp @ 18,000 ft
340 mph @ 5000 ft, 360 mph @ 10,000 ft, 380 mph @ 15,000 ft, 390 mph @ 20,000 ft
2.2 minutes to 5,000 ft, 4.4 minutes to10,000ft, 9.1 minutes to 20,000ft. Service ceiling was 31,350 ft
No nose guns, four 0.5-in wing machine guns, pylons for two 500-lbs bombs
310 built, 50 to RAF as "Mustang Mk II"

Info from:
*Fighting Mustang: The Chronicle of the P-51, William N. Hess, Doubleday, 1970.
* The American Fighter, Enzo Angelucci and Peter Bowers, Orion Books, 1987..
* USAF Museum web site search
*Janes Vintage Aircraft: Tony Holmes, Harper Collins, 2005
* P 51 MUSTANG : From 1940 to 1980 (Planes and Pilots) by Andre Joineau

I did however make a mistake about the '47…Ds were coming out of the Evansville factory in September of 1942, and Farmingdale February 43. But production block D-22-RE and D-23-RA came out in October 43, and along with paddle blades, T-bolts finally had jettisonable canopies. Twitch, did they field mod '47Cs to paddle blades?

Tony…good luck on that '63
 
You just proved your initial statement wrong with all that. You claimed in your first statement that the P-51 was still the A-36. But the P-51 came before the A-36, and not just the XP-51.

Your words : "The P-51 was still the A-36. The last of the initial ordered 500 Apaches were delivered in March of '43."

"In March of 1943, some 25 or so F-6A/P-51s were assigned to the 154th Observation Squadron at Oujda in French Morocco. This was the 1st US Mustang unit. The first mission was a photographic coverage of Kairouan airfield in Tunisia on April 10, 1943, which was the first USAAF Mustang mission of the war."

How was the P-51 still the A-36 when the P-51 flew into combat first? I knew all that history, and it's all well and good being able to copy it like a parrot. But actually read, and take in the information.

In order, it went XP-51, P-51, F-6A/P-51-1, A-36A, P-51A.
 
plan_D, to me, truth be told, it is very confusing the beginings of the 51... USAAF changing it's mind on the names and designating them in a seeming hap-hazzard manner.

The two NA-73s (XP-51) the 25 -some report to be as many as 60- or so NA-91 (F-6A/P-51/P-51-1) were diverted or approiated, they were not bought, and they filled no spec; they were the 1st US "Mustang" unit as that was the name the Brits gave the plane they had 'speced'.

In this thread the Spitfire is discounted as a candidate American interceptor. The difference here is what exactly, the NAA factory was in the States?

America never ordeded NA-91s. The US did order On April 16, 1942, and specify NA-97 (A-36A), naming the bird Apache, a name they had unofficially given to the F-6A/P-51 British Mustang; NA-97 was designated A-36A. The Designation stayed the same as the name was changed later in mid '42 to Mustang, however the name Apache 'stuck' to the A-36. After the Invasion of Sicily the pilots tried to get the name changed to 'Invader'.

The US did order and specify NA-99 (P-51A) on August 24, 1942, the first American arcraft of this family to start life with the name of Mustang... Just as the 1st A-36As were rolling from the NAA factory.

Since the NA-91s (F-6A/P-51/P-51-1) resemble NA-99s more than they resemble NA-97s It seems forgotten that in the US, NA-91s are named Apache as well as the A-36A.

Regardless of our dissagreement, the origional thread is about an interceptor, an American interceptor available in mid '43. In mid '43 the Mustang was still the A-36 this is my point.
 
I'm completely confused as to what the thrust is here. Simply model/sub-model evolution?
NA-73 1 made
Mustang I- ie., 2nd NA-73 prototype send to England 319 followed
XP-51 2 made
Mustang I revamp 300 made
P-51 or NA-91 -no letter designation 148 made for RAF with 4 20mms Hehehe! 93 to RAF as Mustang IA, 55 went to USAF as F-6As
P-51A with 4 .50s 310 made as Lend-Lease planes 50 to RAF as Mustang IIs, 35 became F-6Bs
XP-51B 2 made with Packard-built Merlin original designation XP-78 tentative name Apache
A-36A was a version of the P-51A 500 built
P-51B flys 1st mission with 4th FG 12/1/43

Is that generally the sequence?
p-51_2.gif
 
The P-38 could get to 20,000ft as follows

P-38F - 5min 28sec British test
P-38 J-10 - 5min 37sec
P-38L is in the same area but with 64" a lockheed test puts it at 5min flat and one AAF test was at 4.91min but I no longer have that test and cannot confirm conditions.

In '44 104/150 fuel became available with it the AAF raised the highest available MAP to 75" for the P-38J (Documentation is at spitfireperformance.com ) The 8th AF raised aircraft in the war zone to 65" MAP giving the P-38J/L another 500-800fpm. At 75" the estimate climb rate for a P-38J is 4640 at sl

The real killer climber would be the P-38K with 1875hp engines and paddle props. The mule achieved 45,000ft max speed a critical alt was 432Military 450 was expected in WEP. From a standing start it could reach 20,000ft in 5min flat with a military power climb of 4800ft min initially. More on this can be found at
The P38K
Theres a wealth of info about the P-38, Republic, Flying Tigers and others at this site. The P-38K was killed because the WPB did not want to accept a 2 week delay in production.

wmaxt

how about mustang?4500ft/min at 1600 ft

Mustang III Flight Trials
 
What?? For interceptions range doesn't really matter (look at the Spitfire, the 109 or in later years the Lightning - all had short ranges). The Mustang would of managed fine as an interceptor (except for climb rate) and its range would enable it to in to intercept the targets further away from their destination which is a good thing...
 
The Mustang was not an interceptor...

Yes but if needs be it could have been used as one although it would of been slower than the other interceptors on the climb. Just because it has a long range doesn't mean it couldn't of been used as an interceptor although I don't think it wouldn't of been that successful as it wasn't designed for being one.
 
I would think P-38 Lightning as well. P-51 Mustang really doesn't have a good useful range for interception...

The P-51 was definatly not an interceptor but where do you come up with that it had no useful range. I think you need to hit the books some more.

P-51D had a range of 1650 mi with external tanks. That is a pretty long range for a single engine fighter of WW2.

What aircraft do you think escorted the B-17s and B-24s all the way from England to Germany and back?

Besides range is not the most important attribute for an interceptor. Interceptors sit on the ground and get vectored from ground radar into a bomber formation to intercept them.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back