Ad: This forum contains affiliate links to products on Amazon and eBay. More information in Terms and rules
Well, Mr. Rod Lewis owns TWO Tigercats and races them at Reno ... and goes pretty darned fast. Ask the people he beats! He KNOWS what the boopk says for the Remo altitude and KNOWS what his do there.
Go Stevo Hinton Jr. in Voodoo! We're hoping for another first place, of course.
Nobody races ballasted for original armament. To do so would be ludicrous in the extreme.
I would have a hard time deciding. If they met head on, the Corsair might be down right away, what with the Tigercat's cannons and MG all on centerline. But that is speculative. If there weren't a quick victory, the climb is about a wash, the speed is quite close, depending on models, the Corsair would have a better roll rate, but the Tigercat certainly has armament all over the F4U.
I'd lean toward the Tigercat if the Tigercat pilot was a good shot and lean toward the Corsair in an extended dogfight. I've seen both doing some quick maneuvers, and they both might have similar turn capabilities, but it would be tough to imagine the Tigercat rolling with the Corsair.
Sorry, I don't have a definitive answer, but would lean toward the Corsair based on roll and proven dogfight ability. However, if I were in combat it would be tough to overlook the twin engines and heavy armament of the F7F. Unfortunately we don't have a lot of F7F combat experience to help us due to the ascendency of jets and the abandonment of pistons right about when the F7F was coming into service.
What do YOU think?
I'll ask Steve Hinton after the Reno Races are over.
It may depend on when they spot each other. Corsair may try to go high. 20,000ft is near the dividing line. The higher they go they more advantage the F4U-4 has. The lower they go the more advantage the F7F has.