'Turret-less' vs. 'turreted' tank-destroyers? (6 Viewers)

Just about all TDs did not have co-ax machine gun for the main gun and only few had a hull mounted machine gun which did limit them for some missions, including infantry support. Granted there are host of photos showing American TD crews firing their 50cal guns from the top of the turret and they may have been supporting infantry but since the main gun is usually pointed somewhere else (sometimes over 90 degrees) and since the machine gunner has over 1/2 his body exposed it might not be close support.
The .50 MG on the knocked out M10 TD sure came in handy for Audey Murphy during the battle of Holtzwihr.
 
I may very well be in error about the need for the driver to dismount/move.
e_Medenine_front_in_Tunisia__11_March_1943._NA1076.jpg

one book but not a manual says the gun recoiled 40in (1 meter) when fired. Maybe there was enough room behind the gun and shield (and there was one).
No mention in the book if the vehicle guns had modified recoil systems with shortened recoil. Archers used the standard breech block with the vertical breech.
They do NOT have the recoil cylinder sticking out the front underneath the gun like the towed guns so something changed.
Firefly's had the breech block rotated 90 degrees and the breechblock moved horizontally and they modified the recoil system substantially, cutting the recoil to closer to 10 inches.
Radios may not have been moved due to recoil of the gun but trying to put the 17pdr shells into the breech with the radios in the original space may have been interesting (smashed fingers and broken radio knobs?)
 
I may very well be in error about the need for the driver to dismount/move.
View attachment 903670
one book but not a manual says the gun recoiled 40in (1 meter) when fired. Maybe there was enough room behind the gun and shield (and there was one).
No mention in the book if the vehicle guns had modified recoil systems with shortened recoil. Archers used the standard breech block with the vertical breech.
They do NOT have the recoil cylinder sticking out the front underneath the gun like the towed guns so something changed.
Firefly's had the breech block rotated 90 degrees and the breechblock moved horizontally and they modified the recoil system substantially, cutting the recoil to closer to 10 inches.
Radios may not have been moved due to recoil of the gun but trying to put the 17pdr shells into the breech with the radios in the original space may have been interesting (smashed fingers and broken radio knobs?)

In post #30 in the ww2talk link I posted there is very brief period newsreel footage of the recoil in the Archer (around the 9 sec mark). Nothing like 40in.

There was also a recoil guard fitted to the gun mounting, not the gun barrel itself. It sat behind the driver's head with the gun barrel recoiling towards it. It can be seen in the various illustrations on page 2 of that link.

As for the photo you posted that is of the 17pdr "Pheasant", officially the QF 17/25pdr. This was a stopgap weapon produced in late 1942 / early 1943 to get the 17pdr into service to counter Tiger tanks expected to show up in North Africa. It was a 17pdr gun mounted on a 25pdr carriage. Only 100page or so produced.

The proper carriage met some production delays and was different completely different split trail design as shown below. The barrel still recoiled some distance backwards.

1794992503705.jpeg


But the Archer used its own bespoke recoil system.

As for the Archers radio, the No 18 set was fitted behind the sloped front armour to the rhs of the driver and on top of a container for 13 x 17pdr rounds.

If your comments about the radio are referring to the Firefly, you seem to have forgotten about the changes made to the rear of the turret. The radio was removed from its regular turret position. A hole was then cut in the turret bustle armour and a new armoured box welded over the hole. Into that box went the radio. Plenty of photos of the detail of the Firefly turret arrangements can be found on the Sherman Minutia site.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back