Light AA by this state of the war were not controlled by high angle / low angle FC systems and RPC.
Agreed. however the 20mm effectiveness was greatly increased in effectiveness later in the war, according to the Nav weapons site, which states as follows "In 1943 the revolutionary Mark 14 Gunsight was introduced which made these guns even more effective. This gunsight was developed by Dr. Charles Draper of MIT, who calculated that since the guns fired at relatively short ranges, a crude but simple and effective relative-bearing system could be used to control these weapons. The Mark 14 gunsight used two gyros to measure vertical and lateral rate of change, calculated the lead angle to the target aircraft and then projected an off-set aiming point for the gunner. Use of the Mark 14 did require that an electric power connection be provided to the formerly free-standing mountings. This gunsight was later adopted as part of the Mark 51 director which was used to control the 40 mm Bofors, greatly increasing their effectiveness"
No Beatty released their torpedoes outside the effective range of 40mm /5" guns and it is questionable whether or not 20mm firing non mine rounds have a decisive effect on twin engined bombers to justify this differentiation, but it is possible, at least.
A "Beatty" is a wwi admiral in the RN. A "Betty" is either a womans name, or the code name for the principal land based torpedo bomber used by the IJN during the war.
The reference to a 40 mm I assume could be either a 2 pounder, or a bofors. A 2 pounder had a max range of 6200 metres (approximately), and an effective range of about 3400 metres. The Betty could not launch torps outside of 2000 metres, so it would on average be in the kill zone of the 2 pounder for about 15 seconds.
The Bofors had a theoretical range of about 10500 metres, but an effective range of about 3200-7000 m (depending on nationality and ammunition type), As a broad generalization the gun had an effective AA range of about 4000 metres. Against the betty target, it could engage for about 20-25 seconds before the torps were released.
The US 5 In from memory had an effective range against aircraft of about 8500 metres (from memory, have not checked properly), If this is correct, the bettys would be under fire for abour 50 seconds
As far as can be judged from Force Z, the Beatty torpedo bomber released their torpedoes from distances of about 2.000m, which would be well within effective firing range of 20mm light AA.
Ah, no. The effective range of the 20mm did not exceed 1000 metres until much later in the war (source Nav weapons). Incidentally, the main attackers of Fze Z were the much older Nells. If my memory is correct, the Bettys were not even committed, being held back as a reserve wave, if needed.
The torpedoes indeed could be dropped at even larger distances but to what effect? Dropping range and deflection are in direct relationship with hitting probability.
Ah no, 2000 was the max efffective range for the Type 91 torps used by the IJN
Quote:
Compared to a swordfish, the betty was relatively better off because it could launch from a greater distance, and was much faster. The Swordfish, however, had the priceless advantage of being Night capable, probably more sturdily constructed, and apparently somewhat immune to enemy fire because of their low speed.
Wasn´t the Beatty called "type one lighter"?
Yep, and the Swordfish was the Stringbag. both were unarmoured, and vulnerable. the Betty was more prone to ignition because of its unprotected fuel tanks, but the swordish was much slower. Its launch distance was 1500 yds @ 40 kts, or 3500 yds at 27 kts. AFAIK the longer range setting was not used against warships. because of the poor speed. That means that the exposure times for the stringbag was much greater when they were engaging the bismarck and Tirpitz (and the italians as well, of course). By simply turning to run in the same direction as the Swordfish a warship travelling at 30 ktd could reduce the closure rate to under 50 kts, particualrly in a headwind.
Quote:
I know that i have somewhere the estimated ammunition expenditures per kill by the USN, which by late 1944 was about 1500 rounds per kill. By comparison, the land based flak units of the LW were expending about 16000 rounds per kill. Probably not comparable, however, as the primary target of the german flak at this time was high level bombers.
As You have already mentioned, this comparison compares apples with oranges. There are ammunition breakdowns for naval vessels of KM and USN readily accessable in the net to make proper comparisons.
Note that naval AAA doesn´t "need" to kill in order to be successive
I have not seen the average ammunition expenditures for any axis navies, Can you provide the links please, i would like to have a look.