But I still maintain that it was a dated aircraft going into 1943, and should still have had its production run ended for more Spitfires or other aircraft types.
Yeah, coulda... but d'you think Hawker, a supplier of fighters to the RAF/RFC/RNAS since the Great War (as Sopwith) would want to build a direct competitor's aircraft, particularly when it had its own in the Tempest (and Fury) in production? Not likely.
So to say that the parts pipeline would suddenly stop is not accurate.
Show me where I said it would suddenly stop.
There are numerous factors to take into consideration. In hindsight we can say P-40 production should'a been stopped, but what impact would that have had on Allies still using it? And again, it depends on when those who suggested it to have been stopped actually think it should have been stopped. If it was stopped with the P-51 in service in '42 - 43 perhaps? Still lots of P-40s in the Pacific and North Africa and in hindsight the war went on for another two years. That would have affected the supply chain.
This whole argument is based on presumption without any established facts, from my point of view and from yours and everyone else's. We don't know what exactly would have happened because there are so many variables, but suffice to say, it might not have made the best of sense to stop production of the P-40 before the date it was stopped because, a. no one knew when the war was going to end, and b. there were allies to the USA that were using it until the very end of the war.
Same with the Hurricane - I would'a also thought
someone would have suggested stopping production of the Bristol Blenheim, which was declared obsolescent well before the Hurricane, yet production went on for long after suitable replacements were being built even by the parent company in the Beaufighter. But again, in the Hurricane's case, the Typhoon didn't pan out and a work force had to be kept busy and even in 1942 - 43, the Hurricane was still in useful employ, despite being obsolescent. As for the Blenheim, with aircraft like the Mosquito and Beaufighter available, and Boston, Mitchell and Marauder from the USA... head scratching... Maybe something to do with numbers, perhaps?